congratulations with phd

Readings With Hope

48 Congratulations Messages for PhD or Doctorate Degree Students

Have you ever witnessed the culmination of years of hard work, dedication, and relentless pursuit of knowledge? 

Imagine the elation, the sense of accomplishment that comes with achieving the pinnacle of academic excellence. 

As we celebrate the remarkable journey of Ph.D. students, it’s imperative to convey our heartfelt congratulations in a way that truly honors their extraordinary achievement.

Here, we present some heartfelt messages that encapsulate the pride and admiration we feel for these exceptional individuals as they embark on the next chapter of their scholarly endeavors.

Congratulations Messages for Phd Admission

• “Congratulations on your admission to the PhD program ! Your hard work and dedication have truly paid off. This is a remarkable achievement and the beginning of an incredible journey in academia. I have no doubt that you will contribute valuable insights to your field!”
• “Well done on securing your spot in the PhD program! This is a testament to your brilliance and perseverance . I’m thrilled to see where this next chapter takes you. Your future is undoubtedly bright, and I’m excited for all the discoveries and contributions you will make.”
• “ Congratulations! You’ve been admitted to the PhD program, a milestone that speaks volumes about your academic excellence and passion for your field. This journey will be challenging but incredibly rewarding. Your dedication is inspiring!”
• “This is fantastic news! Being accepted into a PhD program is no small feat, and it clearly demonstrates your commitment and capability. Embrace this new adventure with the knowledge that you are fully equipped to excel. Congratulations!”
• “Congratulations on your PhD admission! Your journey has been nothing short of inspiring , and this achievement is a significant milestone. The dedication and resilience you have shown are commendable. I look forward to seeing the impact of your research.”
• “I’m so proud of you for getting into the PhD program! This achievement is a clear reflection of your hard work, determination , and intelligence. The road ahead is full of possibilities and I’m excited to see the contributions you will make to your field .”
• “Your admission to the PhD program is well-deserved. Congratulations on this incredible accomplishment ! Your passion and dedication have led you to this moment, and I have every confidence in your success moving forward.”
• “ Heartfelt congratulations on your PhD admission! You’ve crossed a major threshold in your academic career, and I’m thrilled to witness the excellence you’ll bring to your research and the academic community.”

• “Congratulations on your admission! It’s a privilege to see someone so dedicated and talented achieve this significant milestone . Your PhD journey will be demanding, but I know you will rise to the challenge and excel .”
• “Well done on earning your place in the PhD program! Your perseverance and academic prowess have truly paid off. This journey will be one of growth and discovery, and I’m excited for the contributions you will make to the world of academia.”
• “Congratulations on your PhD admission! This is a testament to your exceptional skills and dedication. I’m confident that you will bring fresh perspectives and innovations to your field. Your future is incredibly promising!”
• “Achieving admission to a PhD program is a significant accomplishment , and I’m so proud of you for reaching this milestone. Your dedication to your studies and research is admirable , and I’m excited to see where this journey takes you. Congratulations!”
• “Congratulations on your PhD admission! Your drive and intellect have opened the door to an amazing opportunity. This journey will challenge and inspire you, and I can’t wait to see the innovations you’ll bring to your field.”
• “ Bravo for securing your place in the PhD program! This achievement is a testament to your exceptional talent and hard work. The journey ahead is full of promise, and I’m confident you’ll make a lasting impact .”
• “Your admission to the PhD program is incredibly well-deserved . Congratulations on reaching this milestone! Your commitment to your research is inspiring, and I have no doubt you will excel in this new chapter.”
• “This is a momentous occasion ! Congratulations on your acceptance into the PhD program. Your dedication and perseverance have paid off, and I’m excited to see you thrive in this challenging and rewarding environment.”

• “ Heartiest congratulations on your PhD admission! You’ve proven yourself to be a formidable scholar , and this is just the beginning. The academic community awaits your contributions with great anticipation.”
• “Well done on your PhD admission! Your hard work and dedication have clearly shone through. This is a golden opportunity to further your research and make meaningful contributions to your field. Congratulations!”
• “Congratulations on this spectacular achievement ! Being admitted into a PhD program is a clear indicator of your academic excellence and potential for groundbreaking research. I’m thrilled about your future discoveries.”
• “Your PhD admission is a testament to your brilliant mind and unwavering dedication . This milestone is just the beginning of a journey filled with discoveries and success. Congratulations on this well-deserved accomplishment!”
• “ Incredible job on earning your place in the PhD program! Your ability to tackle complex problems and push the boundaries of knowledge is truly inspiring. I’m looking forward to seeing your impact on your field.”
• “Congratulations on your PhD admission! This step is a huge leap towards fulfilling your academic and research ambitions. Your passion and perseverance have led you to this point, and they will guide you to even greater achievements.”
• “ Congratulations on your well-deserved PhD admission! Your journey so far has been a testament to your hard work and dedication . The academic world is ready for your contributions, and I’m excited to see where this path takes you.”
• “Securing your admission into the PhD program is a major milestone —congratulations! Your commitment to excellence is evident, and this opportunity will enable you to explore and transform your field in unimaginable ways.”

Congratulations Messages for Phd Graduation

• “Congratulations on your PhD graduation ! This is a testament to your incredible perseverance and dedication. You’ve not only advanced your own knowledge but are set to contribute significantly to your field. Well done !”
• “ Heartfelt congratulations on achieving this monumental milestone! Your PhD is not just a degree, but a symbol of your relentless dedication and passion for research. The world awaits your innovations and discoveries.”
• “Congratulations on your outstanding achievement ! Completing your PhD is a remarkable feat that speaks volumes about your intelligence, determination , and hard work. Your future endeavors are bound to be exceptional .”
• “Well done on reaching the pinnacle of academic excellence —your PhD graduation! This milestone is a launchpad for your career, and I have no doubt you will make waves in your field. Congratulations on this incredible success !”
• “ Bravo on your PhD graduation! You’ve climbed the highest academic mountain, and your view must be spectacular. Your journey has been inspiring , and your future is as bright as your brilliant mind . Here’s to many more achievements!”
• “Congratulations on your PhD graduation! This is a major accomplishment that showcases your expertise and commitment to your field. The dedication you’ve shown is truly commendable. Your journey is just beginning .”
• “Achieving your PhD is a monumental success that few attain. Congratulations on this significant milestone! Your hard work and sacrifices have culminated in this proud moment. The impact of your research will be far-reaching .”
• “Your PhD graduation marks the culmination of years of research, study, and sacrifices. Congratulations on achieving such a prestigious milestone ! Your dedication to advancing knowledge is truly admirable .”

• “ Heartiest congratulations on your PhD graduation! You’ve proven that with perseverance and passion , even the loftiest goals are achievable. Your academic journey has been nothing short of inspiring .”
• “Congratulations on your PhD graduation! You’ve mastered the art of perseverance, dedication , and scholarly excellence. This achievement opens up a world of opportunities . I can’t wait to see where your talents take you.”
• “ Warmest congratulations on your PhD graduation! Your journey has been a beacon of inspiration for all who aspire to pursue their dreams. Your contributions to your field are already impressive , and the best is yet to come.”
• “Congratulations on your PhD graduation! You’ve achieved the highest level of academic excellence and are poised to make a significant impact in your field. Your hard work and determination have truly paid off .”
• “Congratulations on your PhD graduation ! The dedication and passion you’ve shown on this journey are truly remarkable . Your ability to overcome challenges and push the boundaries of knowledge is inspiring . Here’s to your continued success!”
• “ Huge congratulations on achieving such a monumental milestone—your PhD graduation! Your journey has been a testament to your resilience and unwavering commitment . I am excited to see the impact your future work will have on the world.”
• “Completing your PhD is an extraordinary achievement that reflects your hard work, intelligence, and dedication to your field. Congratulations on reaching this pinnacle of academic success ! The future holds endless possibilities for you.”
• “ Bravo on your well-deserved PhD graduation! You’ve not only earned the highest academic degree but also demonstrated exceptional skill and perseverance. Your contributions to your field are sure to be groundbreaking .”

• “Congratulations on your impressive achievement ! Graduating with a PhD is a clear indication of your expertise, dedication , and passion for research. Your future endeavors are bound to be successful and influential .”
• “Your PhD graduation is a significant accomplishment that speaks to your hard work and academic brilliance . Congratulations on reaching this milestone! Your journey has been inspiring , and I look forward to your next chapter.”
• “ Heartfelt congratulations on completing your PhD! This milestone is a reflection of your incredible dedication and the hard work you’ve invested in your research. Your achievement is truly commendable .”
• “Congratulations on your PhD graduation! You’ve demonstrated exceptional perseverance and intellectual rigor throughout your journey. Your ability to contribute meaningfully to your field is undoubtedly remarkable.”
• “ Warmest congratulations on your PhD graduation! Your journey to this point has been filled with challenges, but your determination and passion for your work have shone through. The academic and professional worlds await your innovations .”
• “Congratulations on achieving this pinnacle of academic excellence —your PhD! Your dedication to pushing the boundaries of knowledge is admirable . This achievement marks the beginning of a promising future filled with impactful contributions .”
• “Your PhD graduation is not just an academic achievement; it’s a testament to your incredible resilience, intellect , and commitment to making a difference in your field. Congratulations on this well-earned success!”
• “Congratulations on your PhD graduation! Your hard work, dedication, and brilliant insights have brought you to this moment. Your future contributions to your field are eagerly anticipated by all who know the value of your work .”

Founder @ ReadingsWithHope.com

I make sure that your cards don't go empty handed.

Congratulations Messages for PhD or Doctorate Degree

PhD Congratulations Message : Earning a Ph.D. degree is a big stepping stone towards a brighter future. Congratulate them on achieving the doctorate degree and becoming a doctor of their own destiny. Send them warm congratulatory wishes while acknowledging their hardship and sacrifices. Appreciate your brother, sister, husband, wife, son, daughter, teacher, friends, or any beloved ones for achieving their doctorate degree and make them feel great about such a great accomplishment. Earning a doctorate is not easy, so appreciate all their efforts by congratulating them on their big achievement!

PhD Congratulations Message

Congratulations on achieving your PhD. I have seen you working hard day and night and now all the hardship has paid well, proud of you.

Congratulations on your hard-earned Doctorate degree! May this be the stepping stone of your future endeavors!

Congratulations {PUT NAME}! May this Ph.D. be the beginning of many more successful endeavors.

Congratulations on successfully completing your Ph.D. and making us all proud. You have always been so dedicated and sure it is very inspiring indeed.

Your long-cherished dream of becoming a Ph.D. holder has finally come true. Many congratulations on your success. You’ve inspired all of us not only to dream but also to work hard to achieve them.

You left no stone unturned in these years and I want you to know that I am extremely proud of you. Congratulations on earning your PHD.

Your hard work has finally paid off! Congratulations on your Ph.D. and best wishes for the future.

I am extremely proud of you for successfully completing your doctorate. May God help you to achieve your other dreams too. Love you.

You never took pride in your achievements but it is time to feel proud. You have nailed it and outshined us all. Proud of you, mate.

Congratulations on shining bright and scoring this PhD Degree. It seems all your hard work has paid off at last. So proud of you my dear brother.

My warmest congratulations for making it to the end and achieving your degree. All the hardship has paid off lavishly, proud to call you my sister.

Your dream of holding a doctorate degree by your name has finally been fulfilled. I cannot be any prouder than I am today. Love you so much.

Dear Son, heartiest congratulations on earning a PhD degree. It was never easy but did not give up. May God bless you forever. Love you.

Congratulations on your Ph.D. dear daughter! I am so proud of you, and I believe that you are destined to do many more great things.

Congratulations on earning a doctorate degree. Thank you for setting such a great example, teacher. Many happy returns of such a remarkable success.

Congratulations on completing your PhD! Your compassion and perseverance are truly fascinating!

Years of labor and endurance have finally brought you this honorable success! Congratulations, doctor!

Congratulations on your remarkable achievement! I appreciate your persistent hard work!

This doctorate degree ensures a bright future with lots of money for you! You’ve got wings now and you can soar high, Mr. Doctor. Congratulations!

It is a great pleasure and honor to hear that all your hardship finally has finally paid off with this Ph.D. degree. May God bless you and help you achieve more in life.

Congratulations on earning a doctorate degree, dear husband. You are and always will be a source of inspiration for me.

I am thrilled to know about your huge triumph! Congratulations! Your achievement is extraordinary!

Sending my warmest greetings for proving yourself over and over again. Many happy returns of this day and once again congratulations on achieving a Ph.D. Degree.

Congratulations Message for Doctor Degree

Congratulations on your doctorate degree! This is surely one of many achievements to come!

Congratulations on your doctorate degree! Your hardships have paid off and lead you to the epitome of your academic journey! Good luck ahead!

Congratulations on earning your doctorate and making us all proud! You are truly an inspiration to everyone around you.

Congratulations on nailing another successful chapter of your life! I am immensely proud of you and your doctorate.

Seeing the Dr. before your name makes me feel proud. Congratulations on your doctorate!

Congratulations! You have proven to the world that hard work can fulfill any dream!

Congratulations on your doctorate degree! You always stand up to your reputation and make us proud!

Success comes to those who have earned it with their ceaseless effort. Congratulations and good luck!

Congratulations on attaining your Doctorate degree! Your hard work, patience, and perseverance were bound to bear fruit! We are proud of this success!

A hearty congratulations on your doctorate degree! You have marveled at us with your incredible dedication and hard work!

PhD Congratulations Card Messages

Nothing makes me prouder than seeing you shine brightly. Congratulations on your Ph.D. I’m glad for you!

Congratulations to you on becoming a PhD holder! I hope all the struggles are worth this drill and now you can soar higher than ever. Best wishes for the future.

I knew that you would achieve every success in life, and I am happy to see you shine. Congratulations on your Ph.D.!

Congratulations on achieving your doctorate degree. Now that you have completed such a milestone, I pray you find happiness and satisfaction in life as well.

You have proved again how dedicated and strong-willed you are. Congratulations on earning your Ph.D. I am truly happy for your success.

You truly have proved your self-dedication and perseverance, dear sister. May God bless you to achieve all the success that is waiting for you. Congratulations on your PHD.

Thank you for proving once again how strong and dedicated you are when it comes to achieving your goals. I love you so much, son. Congratulations on your degree.

Congratulation on such a major success. Your hardship and efforts have finally paid you off with a doctorate degree in your hand. Love you so much.

Thank you for holding our heads high and achieving the Ph.D. Your courage and dedication have led you to earn this, extremely proud of you.

Funny PhD Wishes

Congratulations on your PhD! I’m sure your body has more coffee running than blood by now!

Congratulations! Glad that you have obtained your doctorate before going completely bald!

If you have survived pursuing a Ph.D., life cannot knock you down anymore! Congratulations!

Congratulations on completing your PhD! Rest your brain for a while lest it short-circuits!

Ph.D. is like labor pain; the process is hard, but it’s all worth it in the end! Congratulations on your Ph.D. completion!

Congratulations! Now that you have attained your degree, it’s time to meet the outside world!

Although you have become a doctor now, refrain from performing CPR! Congratulations!

PhD Completion Best Wishes and Proud Messages

Best wishes for your PhD! Your burning passion speaks through your achievement!

Congratulations on attaining your PhD! May this accomplishment encourage you to thrive more in the future! My best wishes go to you!

Congratulations on receiving your hard-earned PhD! May you do wonders for the world!

Congratulations on your PhD! Best wishes for the upcoming triumphs and endeavors!

This milestone was not easy to reach, but you never stopped running. Congratulations and best wishes!

Congratulations on obtaining your PhD! We are delighted to see your excellent academic performance throughout the journey.

We are overjoyed to know about your academic performance! Congratulations on your Ph.D.! You have certainly made us the proudest peers ever!

Your accomplishments never fail to amaze us! Congratulations on your successful completion of your Ph.D.!

PhD/Doctor Degree Congratulations Wishes for Social Media

Weldone for successfully completing your PhD. I’m proud of you.

Finnaly, you nailed it! Congratulations Doctor on your hard-earned doctoral degree.

The journey wasn’t easy, but it was worth it. Congratulations on earning your Ph.D.!

You are smarter than most people, and now you have a Ph.D. to prove it! Congratulations and best wishes to you.

Congratulations, Dr. You have worked hard to go this far in life and deserve to be proud of yourself.

This is a prestigious degree, and you have earned it like a champ! Congratulations and much love to you.

Achieving a doctorate degree is not an easy deal. One has to sacrifice a lot to earn this. After all the hardship, the person achieving a Ph.D. deserves to be praised wholeheartedly. Sending some congratulatory messages with your warm and enthusiastic words will make the moment more cheerful. A Ph.D. or Doctorate is the highest form of education that anyone can ever get and this is not just a degree. As the degree will bring a new perspective into one’s life, let him/her enjoy the moment for achieving the hard-earned doctorate degree. Send some sweet and warm Ph.D. congratulatory messages to make them feel great about themselves as such a degree should be celebrated without any doubt. Years of hard work finally result in such an achievement so salute it. Let’s wish them a day full of sunshine a pocket full of dreams and congratulate them with encouraging words right from your heart.

You May Like

• 50+ Citizenship Congratulations Messages and Wishes
• Promotion Wishes For Boss - Congratulations Messages
• Military Promotion Congratulations Messages
• Congratulations Messages For Quitting Smoking
• Congratulations Reply Messages and Examples

Congratulations Message for PhD or Doctorate Degree Generator

Copied the message:, congratulations messages for phd or doctorate degree.

When someone close to you earns a PhD or doctorate degree, it's a big accomplishment. So, it's only natural to want to send a message of congratulations.

There are many benefits to sending congratulations messages for PhD or doctorate degrees. For one, it helps to show your support for the individual. This can be especially important during the challenging times that come with earning a higher degree.

Additionally, a congratulations message can be a great way to show your pride in the individual's accomplishment. It can also be a nice way to stay connected to someone you may not get to see as often as you'd like.

Finally, sending a congratulations message is simply a nice gesture. It's a way to let the person know that you're thinking of them and that you're happy for their success.

No matter what your relationship is to the person earning the degree, a congratulations message is always a thoughtful gesture. So, if you know someone who is celebrating this milestone, don't hesitate to reach out and let them know you're proud of them.

Below are various congratulations messages for PhD or Doctorate degree;

1.    Congratulations on your Doctorate! Today, we celebrate you.

2.    Congratulations! You earned this Ph.D.! Let me know what you're going to do with it.

3.    Congrats on your doctorate! With your new title comes all the bragging rights.

4.    Congratulations, you have completed your Doctorate Degree! We are proud of you and so happy for you.

5.    Congratulations! You've earned your Doctorate Degree! Here's to the next milestone in your education.

6.    Congratulations! You made it to the top of your field, and you deserve some recognition.

7.    Congratulations on your Doctorate!

8.    Congratulations on your Ph.D.! You made it, congrats!

9.    Congrats on your Ph.D.!

10.    Congratulations!

11.    Congrats, doctor! We hope you're enjoying your new title. We know how much hard work it was for you to get there!

12.    Congratulations! We are beyond proud of you for achieving this monumental milestone. Your hard work in school has paid off.

13.    Congratulations! You've just received your Ph.D. - congratulations!!

14.    Congratulations, Doctor! I'm so proud of you.

15.    Congratulations! You made it to the top of your field with this honor. You're so talented, and I couldn't be more excited to see what you do next.

16.    You have earned your doctorate in medicine! Congratulations. Keep up the good work, and let us know if you need any help.

17.    Congratulations on receiving your Ph.D.! Take this opportunity to plan what you'd like to publish and share it with the world. So many possibilities.

18.    Congratulations on your Ph.D.! We're happy to support you as you pursue your dream.

19.    Congratulations! You earned your Ph.D. degree! From all of us at ______. We are so proud of you.

20.    Congrats! You're a Doctorate degree-holder now. We celebrate with you.

21.    Congratulations! This is such a milestone achievement. Here are a few messages to help you celebrate.

22.    You're so incredibly amazing! Congratulations on your Doctorate.

23.    Congratulations on your Doctorate Degree! We can't wait to celebrate all your success together.

24.    Congratulations, doctor! You made it. You're officially a Ph.D. holder and you deserve to be celebrated.

25.    Congratulations on your Ph.D.! Your tenacity and hard work have paid off.

26.    Congratulations on your Doctorate Degree! Graduation Day is Here.

27.    Congratulations on your Ph.D. degree! You deserve it.

28.    Congratulations on your Ph.D.!

29.    You did it! You made it through all the studying and research. Congrats on your Doctorate Degree.

30.    Congratulations! You're almost finished with your journey to becoming a Doctor. Your hard work has paid off.

31.    Congrats on your new doctorate!

32.    You've been accepted as a University lecturer and completed your final exams! Congrats on an impressive and well-deserved Ph.D.!

33.    Congratulations on your Ph.D.! Here's an exclusive $500 gift card and our best wishes for your future endeavors.

34.    After years of hard work and dedication, you've finally earned a Ph.D. Congrats on graduating!

35.    Congratulations! You've earned this Ph.D./ Doctorate!!!

36.    Congratulations! Your hard work really paid off and you've earned your PhD.

37.    Congratulations! You have finally completed your PhD.

38.    Congratulations on your Doctorate Degree! I am here to help with whatever you need - let me know how I can provide.

39.    Congratulations! You've successfully defended your thesis. Your hard work has paid off. I'm so proud of you.

40.    Congrats, on your lifelong goal!

41.    Congratulations on graduating! You've been a busy genius the last few years and need a break. Come on get some rest!

42.    You're ready for your time in the spotlight! Congratulations on your PhD.

43.    Congratulations on your Ph.D.! You deserve this hard-earned degree!

44.    Congratulations! Your hard work paid off and now you're a doctor!

45.    Congrats! Your hard work paid off and you've earned your Doctorate! Here's to the next chapter of your life.

46.    Congratulations, you made it! You've earned your Ph.D. I am proud of you.

47.    Congrats on your Doctorate Degree! We're so happy for you. You deserve a celebration and maybe some cake.

48.    Congratulations on your new doctorate! I am hosting a celebration party for you.

49.    Congratulations on your doctorate! You're awesome.

50.    Congratulations on earning your Doctorate Degree! May we send you flowers to celebrate?

51.    Congratulations on receiving your Ph.D. Hard work pays.

52.    Congratulations on getting your Ph.D.! I'm so proud of you, and on behalf of the whole family, please accept our sincere congratulations.

53.    Congratulations! I'm so proud of you for having the courage to achieve this great milestone.

54.    Congratulations on your Doctorate Degree! You're a star! We are proud of you.

55.    Congratulations on obtaining your Ph.D.! It's a prestigious degree that requires years of studying and researching - a job well done!

56.    Congratulations on your new degree! Here's a lovingly designed card to celebrate.

57.    Congrats on your Ph.D.!

58.    Congratulations on your Ph.D.! Here's a gift from the team to congratulate you on this big accomplishment-a $100 Amazon gift card.

59.    Congratulations, Doctor.

60.    Congratulations! We're so happy for you!

61.    Congratulations on your recent Doctorate Degree! Let's celebrate.

62.    So proud to be your mom! You've been working hard and we're so proud of you. Congrats on your Doctorate.

63.    Congratulations on getting your Doctorate! You're smart, beautiful, and inspiring. You deserve the best in life.

64.    You did it! You've just completed your Doctorate Degree, and we're so proud of you. Congrats on all the work you've done and all that you'll do.

65.    You're so brilliant! We should celebrate getting your Doctorate Degree.

66.    Congratulations! You've earned this.

67.    Congratulations! You've made a significant contribution to society. Let's celebrate this big achievement.

68.    Congrats on your Ph.D.! Keep up the great work and know that you'll always have an audience.

69.    Congratulations Dr. Jones! We can't wait to see what you will achieve next.

70.    Congratulations on earning your doctorate!

71.    Wow! Congratulations! We're so proud of you for achieving this great recognition.

72.    Congratulations! I'm so proud of you. You deserve the best.

73.    Congratulations! You've completed your Doctorate Degree!

74.    You made it! You got your Doctorate Degree. Congratulations! Here's to your success.

75.    Congrats on receiving your Ph.D.! You deserve this momentous accomplishment.

76.    Congratulations on your Doctorate Degree! We believe in your capabilities and promise to be with you every step of the way.

77.    Congratulations on your doctorate. The world is now open for you to conquer.

78.    Congratulations, you've made it! I know this is a big milestone for you, and I'm so proud of everything you've accomplished. I am so excited for everything to come.

79.    Congratulations! You've passed the final exam to receive your Doctorate.

80.    Congratulations on your Doctorate! Here's a little celebratory gift.

81.    You are now officially the smartest person in your field :) Congrats!

82.    Congratulations! You got your doctorate!

83.    Congratulations on your Doctorate! You've earned a degree of distinction.

84.    Congrats! I'm so proud of you.

Other Wishes/Messages

Divorce Sympathy Messages Happy Earth Day Wishes and Messages Anniversary Wishes and Messages for Son and Daughter in Law Cheer Up Messages

• Congratulations / School and College

Doc-torate Success: Crafting Congrats for PhD Graduates

Last Updated May 15, 2024

The Significance of a Doctoral Degree

The culmination of academic excellence.

• When we talk about a doctoral degree, we’re delving into the realm of academic excellence at its zenith. It’s the culmination of years of dedication, intellectual rigor, and an unquenchable thirst for knowledge. Achieving a doctorate isn’t merely crossing the finish line; it’s reaching the pinnacle of one’s field, standing on the shoulders of giants who’ve come before, and making a significant contribution to the world of academia. This isn’t just another degree; it’s a testament to perseverance and an embodiment of the pursuit of truth.

Exploring the Intellectual Milestone

• A doctorate degree isn’t just a piece of paper; it’s a symbol of intellectual prowess. It signifies the ability to think critically, research diligently, and contribute meaningfully to a specific area of study. It’s the acknowledgment that the holder has not only mastered the existing body of knowledge but has also extended its boundaries. Doctoral graduates are the trailblazers of academia, exploring uncharted territories, and shedding new light on age-old questions. They represent the vanguard of intellectual advancement, and their achievements are nothing short of extraordinary.
• As we delve into crafting congratulatory messages for these academic stars, it’s crucial to understand the significance of their journey. It’s not just a degree; it’s a testament to human potential, intellectual curiosity, and the relentless pursuit of knowledge.

Crafting the Perfect Congratulatory Message for PhD or Doctorate Degree

The art of celebrating scholarly success.

Crafting a congratulatory message for a doctoral graduate is an art form in itself. It’s about encapsulating years of hard work and dedication in a few heartfelt words. Imagine your message as a small masterpiece, a miniature painting that captures the essence of their academic journey. Begin with a warm acknowledgment of their achievement, acknowledge the sacrifices they’ve made, and express your pride in their success. Then, add a touch of inspiration, emphasizing the limitless possibilities their doctorate unlocks. This artful blend of appreciation and motivation will create a message that resonates deeply with the recipient.

Personalized Messages for Doctoral Graduates

• “Your doctorate isn’t just a degree; it’s a testament to your unyielding determination and the mark you’re leaving on your field. Congratulations on this remarkable achievement!”
• “I always knew you were destined for greatness. Your doctorate is proof that hard work and passion can truly move mountains. Proud of you!”
• “Your relentless pursuit of knowledge has culminated in this incredible achievement. Now, the world is your oyster, and I can’t wait to see where your brilliance takes you!”
• “To the world, you may be just one person, but to me, you are the world—and now, you’re a world-class scholar too! Heartiest congratulations!”
• “The pursuit of a doctorate isn’t for the faint-hearted, and you’ve not only survived but thrived. Your dedication inspires us all. Well done!”
• “As you stand on this academic summit, remember that the view from here is just the beginning of a breathtaking journey. Congratulations on your doctorate!”
• “Your doctorate isn’t just a degree; it’s a beacon of hope for all who dream of pushing the boundaries of knowledge. You’re an inspiration to us all.”
• “In a world where knowledge is power, you’ve just become a superhero. Your doctorate is your cape—wear it with pride! Congratulations!”
• “From the first day of your doctoral journey to this moment, you’ve shown resilience, brilliance, and unwavering commitment. The sky’s not the limit; it’s just the view. Congratulations!”
• “Your doctorate is more than an academic achievement; it’s a legacy you’re leaving for future generations. Your brilliance knows no bounds. Congratulations on your incredible journey!”

Heartfelt Congratulations Messages

Cheers to doctoral dedication.

• “To your unwavering dedication, late nights, and unrelenting pursuit of knowledge, cheers! Your doctorate is a toast to your incredible journey.”
• “Raising a glass to the late nights, the sacrifices, and the sheer brilliance that brought you to this moment. Congratulations on your well-deserved doctorate!”
• “Your doctorate isn’t just a piece of paper; it’s a testament to your unyielding dedication. Here’s to you and your incredible journey to academic greatness!”
• “From the first day of your doctoral studies to this triumphant moment, your dedication has shone brightly. Cheers to your remarkable achievement!”
• “A toast to your incredible determination, intellectual prowess, and the doctorate that’s a testament to your brilliance. Congratulations!”

Messages Filled with Academic Pride

• “Your doctorate isn’t just a milestone; it’s a badge of honor. Your academic prowess shines like a beacon, lighting the way for future scholars. Proud of you!”
• “As you stand on the academic summit, know that you’re not just carrying a degree; you’re carrying the hopes of generations. Your academic pride is well-deserved!”
• “Your doctorate isn’t just a certificate; it’s a symbol of academic excellence. Your family, friends, and mentors couldn’t be prouder of your remarkable journey.”
• “From the first day of your academic journey, you’ve worn your passion for knowledge like a badge of honor. Your doctorate is the pinnacle of that pride. Congratulations!”
• “In the grand tapestry of academia, your doctorate is a thread of brilliance that enriches us all. Your academic pride is a beacon of inspiration. Well done!”

Funny and Light-hearted Messages

Adding humor to celebrate doctoral glory.

• “Congratulations on officially becoming the ‘Dr.’ in the room! Can we call you for medical advice now, or is it still just for academic emergencies?”
• “They say a PhD is like a marathon, only with more caffeine. Congrats on finishing the world’s longest coffee-fueled race!”
• “Now that you’re a doctor, should we start addressing you as ‘Your Awesomeness’ or ‘Master of Everything’?”
• “You’ve got a doctorate now, which means you’re basically a real-life superhero. Do you have a special signal for when you’re needed?”
• “Your doctorate proves you’re officially a genius. Or at least really good at faking it convincingly. Either way, well done!”

Celebrating with Laughter and Wit

• “Congratulations! You’ve successfully outwitted the academic challenges and emerged victorious. Now, can you explain your thesis to us in 10 words or less?”
• “Your doctorate is like a golden ticket to the ‘Smartest People’ club. Don’t forget us mere mortals when you’re famous!”
• “I hear doctors have excellent handwriting. Can you write me a prescription for more celebrations and laughter?”
• “Your doctorate is proof that you can endure endless coffee, late nights, and complex research—no superpowers required (we think).”
• “With your doctorate, you’ve earned the right to be the ‘I told you so’ person in every intellectual argument. We’ll prepare our concession speeches.”

Inspirational Messages

Doctoral dreams and future aspirations.

• “Your doctorate isn’t just an end; it’s a beginning—a stepping stone to a future filled with even greater achievements. Your dreams are boundless!”
• “As you receive your doctorate, remember that your dreams have no limits. Your journey is an inspiration to all who dare to dream big.”
• “Your doctorate is not just a degree; it’s the first chapter in the story of your extraordinary career. Your aspirations have the power to shape the world.”
• “Every great accomplishment starts with a dream. Your doctorate is proof that dreams can be turned into reality through hard work and determination.”
• “As you hold your doctorate, envision the incredible future ahead. Your journey has only just begun, and your potential is limitless.”

Encouraging Continued Success in Academia

• “Your doctorate is just the beginning of a lifelong journey of learning. Keep pursuing knowledge and let curiosity be your guiding star.”
• “With your doctorate, you’ve unlocked the doors to academia. Keep pushing boundaries, challenging norms, and inspiring future scholars.”
• “Your doctorate isn’t the end of the road; it’s the launchpad for your academic career. Keep soaring to new heights, and never stop reaching for the stars.”
• “As a doctor, you have the power to mentor and inspire the next generation of scholars. Your influence in academia will be profound.”
• “Your doctorate is a testament to your intellectual prowess. Continue your journey of discovery, and let your passion for learning guide your path.”

Celebration Ideas and Gifts

Making the doctoral celebration extra special.

• Graduating with a doctorate is a monumental achievement that deserves an equally remarkable celebration. Here are some ideas to make the occasion extra special:
• Virtual Toast: Organize a virtual toast with friends and family from around the world. Raise your glasses to the graduate and share stories and laughter.
• Themed Party: Host a party with a theme related to the graduate’s field of study. It’s a fun way to incorporate their academic journey into the celebration.
• Surprise Video Messages: Collect video messages from friends, family, and mentors congratulating the graduate. Compile them into a heartfelt video surprise.
• Customized Cake: Order a cake designed with a symbol or theme related to the graduate’s area of expertise. It’s a delicious way to celebrate their achievements.
• Memory Lane: Create a photo album or digital presentation that showcases memorable moments from their academic journey, from the first day of classes to graduation day.

Unique Gifts to Accompany Your Congratulatory Messages

• Alongside your heartfelt messages, consider these unique gift ideas to make the congratulatory gesture even more meaningful:
• Customized Art: Commission an artist to create a piece of artwork inspired by the graduate’s field of study or thesis. It’s a unique and thoughtful gift.
• Academic Jewelry: Gift them a piece of jewelry, like a necklace or cufflinks, featuring a symbol or element from their academic discipline.
• Professional Portfolio: Invest in a high-quality leather portfolio or briefcase for their future academic or professional endeavors.
• Book Collection: Assemble a collection of books related to their field, including classics and contemporary works that inspire further exploration.
• Online Course Subscription: Enroll them in an online course or workshop that aligns with their academic interests, allowing them to continue their learning journey.
• Leaving for College Messages from Parents to Students
• Congratulations Messages for Passing Exams
• Leaving for College Congratulation and Empowering Messages for Friends
• Motivating Messages and Quotes for Students and Grads
• College Graduation Messages, Wishes, Cards and Quotes
• Knowledge Quotes and Tips to Inspire Learning
• Inspiring College Graduation Messages to Celebrate their Achievement!
• Congratulations Messages for a Great Presentation or Speech
• Next story  Quote of the Day – Daily Wisdom Brought to You by WishesQuotes
• Previous story  Inspiring Quotes to Mark the End of the School Year

Advertisement

Recent posts.

Birthday Wishes for Your WhatsApp Status

Cancer Birthday Wishes: Celebrating the Nurturing Souls

How to Write the Perfect Leo Birthday Wish

Birthday Wishes by Zodiac Sign

The Edvocate

• Lynch Educational Consulting
• Dr. Lynch’s Personal Website
• Write For Us
• The Tech Edvocate Product Guide
• The Edvocate Podcast
• Terms and Conditions
• Privacy Policy
• Assistive Technology
• Best PreK-12 Schools in America
• Child Development
• Classroom Management
• Early Childhood
• EdTech & Innovation
• Education Leadership
• First Year Teachers
• Gifted and Talented Education
• Special Education
• Parental Involvement
• Policy & Reform
• Best Colleges and Universities
• Best College and University Programs
• HBCU’s
• Higher Education EdTech
• Higher Education
• International Education
• The Awards Process
• Finalists and Winners of The 2023 Tech Edvocate Awards
• Award Seals
• GPA Calculator for College
• GPA Calculator for High School
• Cumulative GPA Calculator
• Grade Calculator
• Weighted Grade Calculator
• Final Grade Calculator
• The Tech Edvocate
• AI Powered Personal Tutor

Teaching Students About the Honeysuckle Plant

$13 million gift to cleveland clinic from howley foundation expands aspire program, okaloosa school district to launch esports program across all high schools, white house initiative celebrates 10th anniversary with diverse 2024 hbcu cohort, college students are already regretting their student loans, fafsa rollout was ‘a stunning failure,’ college aid expert says. here’s how next year will compare, igniting the torch of progress’: stark state college opens new welding and joining lab, ‘a lovely legacy’: falk college remembers professor emerita sarah ‘sally’ short, fort leonard wood hosts combined college graduation event, new scholarship available to nc residents with thursday deadline, congratulations messages for ph.d. or doctorate degree.

Ph.D. Congratulations Message : A Ph.D. degree is a significant step toward a brighter future. Congratulate them on earning their doctorate and becoming a doctor of their own choosing. Send them warm congratulations while acknowledging their difficulties and sacrifices. Thank your brother, sister, husband, wife, son, daughter, teacher, friends, or other loved ones for earning their doctorate degree and make them feel proud of themselves. Obtaining a doctorate degree is a tremendous accomplishment, so express your gratitude by congratulating them!

Ph.D. Congratulations Message

Congratulations on your doctorate. I’ve seen you working hard day and night, and now your efforts have paid off handsomely; I’m proud of you.

You left no stone unturned during these years, and I want you to know that I am extremely proud of you. Congratulations on your Ph.D.

Congratulations on your hard-won Doctorate! I hope this serves as a launching pad for your future ventures!

Congratulations on finishing your Ph.D. and making us all proud. You’ve always been so dedicated, and I’m sure it’s very inspiring.

You never took pride in your accomplishments, but now is the time to do so. You nailed it and outperformed us all. I’m very proud of you, mate.

Years of hard work and endurance have finally resulted in this prestigious achievement! Congratulations, Dr.

Congratulations on achieving this Ph.D. degree and shining brightly. Your efforts appear to have paid off. My dear brother, I am so proud of you.

My heartfelt congratulations on completing your studies and earning your degree. I am pleased to call you my sister.

Your dream of having a doctorate degree to your name has finally come true. I’ve never been more proud of myself than I am today. I adore you so much.

Dear Son, heartfelt congratulations on obtaining a Ph.D. God bless you always. I adore you.

Congratulations on receiving your doctorate. Thank you for leading by example, teacher. Many congratulations on your extraordinary success.

Congratulations on your Ph.D. completion! Your perseverance and compassion are truly inspiring!

Congratulations on your outstanding achievement! I admire your perseverance and hard work!

I am proud of you for completing your doctorate. May God also help you to realize your other goals. I adore you.

This doctorate degree guarantees a prosperous future for you! Mr. Doctor, you now have wings and can fly high. Congratulations!

It gives me great pleasure and honor to hear that your efforts have finally paid off with this Ph.D. degree.

Congratulations on completing your Ph.D. I’m very proud of you.

I am overjoyed to hear about your tremendous success! Congratulations! Your accomplishment is outstanding!

I extend my heartfelt congratulations on your continued success. Many happy returns of the day, and congratulations on completing your Ph.D.

Ph.D. Congratulations Card Messages

You nailed it, Finally! Congratulations, Doctor, on your well-earned doctorate.

Congratulations on completing your Ph.D.! I hope all of your struggles have been worthwhile and that you can now soar higher than ever. Best regards for the future.

Congratulations on earning your doctorate. Now that you’ve reached this milestone, I hope you find happiness and fulfillment in your life as well.

You have once again demonstrated your dedication and fortitude. Congratulations on your Ph.D.! I am overjoyed for your success.

Dear sister, you have truly demonstrated your self-dedication and perseverance. May God bless you with all of the success that awaits you. Congratulations on your doctorate.

Thank you for demonstrating once again how strong and dedicated you are to achieving your goals. I adore you, my son. Congratulations on your graduation.

Congratulations on your tremendous success. Your perseverance and hard work have finally paid off, and you now hold a doctorate degree in your hands. I adore you so much.

Thank you for keeping our heads held high and completing the Ph.D. I am extremely proud of you for your courage and dedication in earning this.

Your long-held ambition of earning a Ph.D. has finally come true. Congratulations on your accomplishment. You’ve inspired all of us to dream big and work hard to make them a reality.

Congratulations Message for Doctor Degree

Congratulations on receiving your doctorate! This is undoubtedly one of many accomplishments to come!

Congratulations on receiving your doctorate! Your perseverance has paid off, and you have reached the pinnacle of your academic career! Best wishes for the future!

Congratulations! You have shown the world that with hard work, any dream can be achieved!

Congratulations on receiving your doctorate! You consistently live up to your reputation and make us proud!

Success comes to those who have worked tirelessly to achieve it. Congratulations and best wishes!

Congratulations on earning your Doctorate! Your perseverance, patience, and hard work were bound to pay off! This accomplishment makes us very happy!

Congratulations, Dr. With your performance, you have earned this title! Best wishes!

Congratulations on receiving your doctorate! Your incredible dedication and hard work have amazed us!

Funny Ph.D. Wishes

Congratulations on your doctorate! I’m sure your body is running on more coffee than blood by now!

Congratulations! I’m glad you got your doctorate before going completely bald!

Life cannot knock you down if you have survived pursuing a Ph.D.! Congratulations!

Congratulations on your Ph.D. completion! Allow your brain some time to relax to avoid short-circuiting!

Congratulations! After earning your degree, it’s time to interact with the outside world.

Regardless of the fact that you are now a doctor, do not perform CPR! Congratulations!

Best Wishes and Proud Messages

Congratulations on your Ph.D.! Your achievement reflects your burning passion!

Congratulations on completing your Ph.D.! May this achievement inspire you to thrive even more in the future! My best wishes are with you!

Congratulations on your well-earned doctorate! May you do great things for the world!

Congratulations on your doctorate! Best wishes for your future successes and endeavors!

This goal was not easy to achieve, but you never gave up. Best wishes and congratulations!

Congratulations on your doctorate! We have been impressed by your outstanding academic performance throughout the journey.

We are overjoyed to learn about your academic achievements! Congratulations on your doctorate! You have made us the proudest ever!

Your achievements never cease to astound us! Congratulations on completing your Ph.D. successfully!

A doctorate degree is not easy to obtain. To obtain this, one must make significant sacrifices. After all the hardship, the person who obtains a Ph.D. deserves to be praised wholeheartedly. Sending congratulatory messages with your warm and enthusiastic words will brighten the situation. A Ph.D. or Doctorate is the highest level of education that anyone can obtain, and it is more than just a degree. Allow him/her to enjoy the moment of achieving the hard-earned doctorate degree, as it will bring a new perspective into one’s life. Send them some heartfelt Ph.D. congratulations to make them feel good about themselves, as such a degree should be celebrated without a doubt. Years of hard work have culminated in such an accomplishment, which deserves to be celebrated. Let us wish them a sunny day, a pocket full of dreams, and congratulate them with encouraging words sincerely.

400+ Merry Christmas Wishes, Messages, and Greetings

100+ christmas wishes, quotes, and messages for ....

Matthew Lynch

Related articles more from author, a guide to costas levels of questioning, april fool messages and prank texts, good morning bible verses and quotes, 70+ perfect retirement wishes, quotes, and messages for boss or supervisor, st patrick’s day wishes, messages, and quotes, bible verses about love, marriage and relationship.

Get access to 120+ AI writing tools to elevate your writing experience.

General Writing

• Paragraph Generator
• Article Rewriter
• Paraphrasing Tool
• Essay Writer
• AI Text Generator
• Sentence Expander
• Paragraph Rewriter
• Sentence Generator
• Plagiarism Remover

Assistant Writing

• Grammar Checker
• Online Proofreader
• Text & PDF Summarizer
• Spell Checker
• AI Translator
• Plagiarism Checker
• Punctuation Checker

Creative Writing

• Prompt Generator
• AI Response Generator
• Hashtag Generator
• Slogan Generator
• Tweet (Thread) Generator
• Instagram Caption Generator
• Script Generator
• AI Lyrics Generator
• AI Story Generator

Take advantage of HIX.AI's full capabilities anywhere on the web.

Productivity

Type // to enjoy our AI assistance as you write on Google Docs.

Type // craft compelling emails and personalized replies.

Explore a more powerful Bing sidebar alternative for Chrome.

Find HIX.AI's comprehensive responses among typical search results.

Select any text online to translate, rewrite, summarize, etc.

Social Media

Type // to compose concise yet powerful Twitter posts that trend.

Type // to create engaging captions for your Instagram posts.

Type // to draft interactive Facebook posts that engage your community.

Type // to provide valuable, upvoted answers on Quora.

Type // to craft Reddit posts that resonate with specific communities.

Summarize long YouTube videos with one click.

Explore the most powerful, all-in-one ChatGPT copilot for the web.

Table of Content

1. Congratulations for Phd: Captivating and Inspiring Captions for Achieving this Milestone

2. congratulations for phd: captivating and inspiring captions for celebrating academic success, 3. congratulations for phd: captivating and inspiring captions for acknowledging hard work and dedication, 4. congratulations for phd: captivating and inspiring captions for celebrating academic excellence, 5. congratulations for phd: captivating and inspiring captions for marking academic accomplishments, 6. congratulations for phd: captivating and inspiring captions for commemorating academic triumphs, 7. congratulations for phd: captivating and inspiring captions for honoring academic dedication, 8. congratulations for phd: captivating and inspiring captions for celebrating academic milestones, 9. congratulations for phd: captivating and inspiring captions for embracing academic excellence, 10. congratulations for phd: captivating and inspiring captions for acknowledging academic excellence, 100+ congratulations for phd: captivating and inspiring captions.

Are you looking for the perfect Instagram captions to congratulate someone on their Ph.D. achievement? Look no further! This article contains 100+ captivating and inspiring captions that are sure to make your congratulatory message stand out. Whether you want to express pride, admiration, or excitement, these captions cover it all!

Unleash Your Creativity with Our AI Text Generator

Amaze your friends by crafting unique messages using our advanced AI text generator before delving into the following examples.

Read also: 100+ Graduation Invitation Message: Inspiring Captions

Read also: 100+ Graduation Message to Daughter: Inspiring Captions

Read also: 100+ Graduation Message for Girlfriend: Inspiring Captions

Read also: 100+ Words to Say Thank You and Appreciation: Captions that Inspire

These captivating and inspiring captions are perfect for celebrating the academic accomplishments of Ph.D. graduates. Whether to commend their dedication, acknowledge their hard work, or simply express pride, these captions will elevate your congratulatory message to the next level. Congratulations, Dr. [Last Name]! Your success is truly commendable and worthy of celebration!

Related Posts

100+ college graduation captions instagram.

Discover 100+ captivating College Graduation Captions for Instagram in this article. Find the perfect words to celebrate your achievements.

100+ Doctor Graduation Instagram Captions

Discover over 100 captivating Doctor Graduation Instagram Captions. Find the perfect words to celebrate your achievement. Let the captions do the talking!

100+ Graduation Message to Daughter: Inspiring Captions

Discover over 100 heartfelt graduation messages to inspire and celebrate your daughter's achievements. Perfect for expressing your pride and support.

Related Articles

• 100+ Christmas Wishes for Boyfriend: Heartwarming Captions
• 100+ Iftar Invitation Message: Captivating and Memorable Captions
• 100+ Death Message: Captivating Captions That Leave a Lasting Impression
• 100+ Graduation Messages for Sister: Heartfelt Celebration Captions
• 100+ Christmas Wishes to My Love: Heartwarming Captions
• 100+ May Day Wishes in English: Inspiring Captions
• 100+ Christmas Wishes for Kids: Heartwarming Captions
• 100+ I Hate You Quotes: Clever Captions
• 100+ Funny Valentine Quotes: Add Some Laughter
• 100+ Good Luck in Your New Job Messages: Uplifting captions for success

101 Congratulations Wishes for Achieving a Phd Degree: Honoring Your Achievement and Wisdom

Earning a Ph.D. is no small feat—it’s a monumental testament to dedication, intellect, and sheer perseverance. Whether you’re the proud grad or a friend bursting with pride, finding the right words to honor this colossal achievement can be a challenge. Dive in for 101 unique and heartfelt congratulations messages that pay homage to the hard-earned wisdom of a Ph.D. degree!

101 Congratulations Wishes for Achieving a Phd Degree

1. A Ph.D. isn’t just an achievement; it’s a testament to your relentless pursuit of knowledge. Congratulations!

2. The letters behind your name now may be new, but they spell out a dedication that is not. Congrats, Doctor!

3. You’ve not just earned a title, you’ve earned a grander place in the library of human knowledge. Bravo!

4. The weight of your accomplishment is as heavy as the tomes you’ve consumed. Well done, Dr. [Name]!

5. Years of research, late nights, and the never-ending quest for truth have led you here. Congratulations on fulfilling your dream!

6. As you stand on this academic summit, may you see the numerous opportunities that stretch out before you. Congratulations!

7. You’ve turned your tassel, but the journey has just begun. The world is now your larger classroom, Dr. [Name].

8. From ABCs to Ph.D., you’ve come so far! Your achievement speaks volumes about your determination.

9. You’ve added a feather in your academic cap that’s unlike any other. Congratulations, Doctor!

10. To call you a graduate is an understatement; you’re a Doctor, and that’s an achievement to be proud of!

11. All those years of caffeine-powered study sessions finally paid off. Congrats!

12. The “Ph” now stands for Phenomenal. Phenomenal job, Dr. [Name]!

13. You’ve broken through the ceiling of academia, now the sky’s the limit. Congratulations!

14. Your dedication has been intense; it’s only fitting that you can now be called an intellectual giant. Congrats!

15. Earning a Ph.D. is like a long, academic version of a marathon, and you’ve just crossed the finish line. Well done!

16. You’ve added a prestigious layer to your educational strata, and it’s a milestone worth celebrating!

17. From now on, you’re not just a part of scholarly conversations; you lead them. Congratulations!

18. Bravo! You’ve now mastered the art of adding significant letters behind your name!

19. A Ph.D. is not the end but a new beginning in the vast landscape of academia. Congrats on reaching this milestone!

20. Your Ph.D. is a monumental stepping stone in the palace of your dreams. Kudos!

21. You’ve achieved the highest pinnacle in academia. May your knowledge continue to light your way.

22. It’s official: You can now philosophize with a doctorate!

23. They say “Knowledge is Power.” Today, you’ve become mighty powerful! Congrats, Doctor!

24. Welcome to the elite circle of intellectuals. Your Ph.D. is a badge of honor!

25. From being a student to becoming a master, your journey has been awe-inspiring. Congratulations, Dr. [Name]!

26. Just like you’ve broken down complex theories, you’ve shattered our expectations. Congrats!

27. Your Ph.D. is more than an achievement, it’s a reflection of the leader you are set to become. Well done!

28. The sleepless nights have turned into a dream come true. Congratulations on your Ph.D.!

29. For every question you’ve answered, may you find a hundred more intriguing ones in your future.

30. Congratulations on achieving your Ph.D. May this new title bring you joy and enrich those around you.

31. A doctorate is more than a degree; it’s a sanctification of your intellect. Kudos!

32. You’ve not only answered your research question but have also raised many new ones. That’s the hallmark of a true academic!

33. With a Ph.D., you’ve earned the right to be listened to; may you always have something worthwhile to say.

34. All the sacrifices you’ve made have paved the way for numerous intellectual endeavors. Well done!

35. Doctorate achieved: Mission accomplished! Here’s to your next great adventure, Dr. [Name].

36. You’ve crafted a masterpiece with your research. May this be just the start!

37. Today, you’ve earned more than a degree; you’ve earned the right to inspire. Congrats, Doctor!

38. Congratulations, you’ve conquered the academic Everest!

39. You’re now officially allowed to make things more complicated—after all, you’re a Doctor!

40. You’ve not just passed exams, you’ve surpassed expectations. Way to go!

41. The tassel was worth the hassle, and the doctorate was worth the dedication. Congratulations!

42. By achieving this milestone, you’ve shown that the sky isn’t your limit—it’s your starting point!

43. From being a dreamer to becoming a Doctor, you’ve completed a journey of epic proportions.

44. It’s not just a degree, it’s a coronation of your scholarly efforts. Well done!

45. Not everyone can reach the academic zenith. You did, and that’s extraordinary!

46. It’s a tale of unwavering will and unparalleled commitment. Congrats on your Ph.D., Dr. [Name]!

47. You’ve shown that you don’t just know how to follow a hypothesis, you know how to lead with integrity. Congrats!

48. You’ve solved equations, pondered theories, and opened doors to a realm of knowledge. Bravo!

49. Your doctorate is proof that you can not only handle challenges but also excel in them.

50. The ink on your degree might dry, but your accomplishments will be etched forever.

51. Your Ph.D. isn’t a piece of paper; it’s a pair of wings. Soar high, Dr. [Name]!

52. Just like you’ve enriched academia with your research, may you enrich lives with your knowledge.

53. Not just a Ph.D., but a trophy of your dedication, sacrifice, and enthusiasm. Kudos!

54. Doctorates don’t just happen. They’re earned with blood, sweat, and occasional tears. Congratulations!

55. Congratulations on proving that hard work and honesty are indeed the best policies.

56. You’re not just a degree-holder; you’re a degree-defender. Congratulations on earning your Ph.D.!

57. When it comes to chasing your dreams, you’ve not just set the bar, you’ve raised it. Well done!

58. Your Ph.D. doesn’t just stand for ‘Doctor of Philosophy’, it stands for ‘Dedication, Passion, and Hard-work’.

59. Time to update your business cards, email signature, and LinkedIn profile. Congrats, Doctor!

60. You’ve not only passed an academic milestone, you’ve achieved a monumental life goal.

61. Today, your knowledge has been stamped with the highest seal of approval. Congrats, Doctor!

62. You’ve knocked on the doors of wisdom and they have swung wide open. Congratulations!

63. You’ve turned your can’ts into cans and your dreams into plans. Kudos, Doctor!

64. You’ve earned a Ph.D., but more importantly, you’ve earned our immense respect.

65. Your research wasn’t just about answering questions, but questioning the answers. Well done!

66. With a Ph.D., you’ve secured a special place in academia. May your research illuminate minds!

67. You’ve not only won a title but also our admiration. Congratulations, Doctor!

68. Your Ph.D. isn’t just a piece of paper; it’s a bookmark in the grand narrative of your life.

69. To us, you’ve always been a source of wisdom. Now, you have the degree to prove it!

70. Your journey to a Ph.D. is like a scientific paper—meticulous, substantial, and absolutely inspiring.

71. Your scholarly journey has been a marathon, and today you’ve crossed the finish line. Cheers, Doctor!

72. You’ve gone from reading textbooks to writing them. Congratulations on your Ph.D.!

73. May your research continue to disrupt the status quo and set new academic standards.

74. Your doctorate is a monumental stride in a lifetime of leaps and bounds. Congratulations!

75. You’ve now mastered the art of finishing, but may you never stop starting new endeavors.

76. Congrats, Dr. [Name]! You’ve now unlocked the highest level in the academic game.

77. Today you’ve proven that the ink of a scholar is more sacred than the blood of a martyr.

78. You’ve donned the cap, turned the tassel, and earned the title. You’re officially fabulous, Doctor!

79. Becoming a doctor of philosophy isn’t just about understanding the world, but changing it. You can, and you will!

80. Congratulations on achieving the highest and the rarest level of educational attainment!

81. The alphabet runs from A to Z, but your achievement runs from dedication to zeal. Well done!

82. Your hard work and ambition have cemented your place among intellectual giants. Bravo!

83. Your Ph.D. is an impressive key that will unlock numerous doors in the professional world.

84. Congratulations on joining the pantheon of scholars. You’re a modern-day academic deity!

85. The journey of a thousand miles began with a single step, and look how far you’ve come. Kudos, Doctor!

86. Your new title is the PhD equivalent of a knighthood in academia. Arise, Doctor [Name]!

87. This doctorate adds a new dimension to your identity. Congratulations on this remarkable achievement!

88. This is just the beginning, Doctor. Your research will echo in the corridors of academia.

89. Your intellectual odyssey has reached a significant milestone. May the journey never end!

90. You’ve punctuated your educational journey with the highest credential. Period!

91. With your Ph.D., you’ve climbed the Everest of academia, planting your flag of intellectual conquest!

92. From today, every debate you enter has a winner before it even begins—Dr. [Name].

93. A Ph.D. doesn’t make you smarter; it makes you more persevering. And that’s even better!

94. Today, you’ve not just added three letters after your name but a lifetime of credibility.

95. When it comes to a Ph.D., it’s not just about the diploma; it’s about the journey to wisdom. Congrats!

96. You’ve scaled one of life’s loftiest peaks. Here’s to enjoying the view, Dr. [Name]!

97. You’ve not just opened the door to a new chapter but a whole new book. Congratulations!

98. Your pursuit of academic excellence didn’t just earn you a Ph.D., it earned you a lifetime of opportunities.

99. With this Ph.D., you’ve not only raised your personal bar but also lifted everyone’s expectations. Congrats!

100. You’ve shown that not all superheroes wear capes; some earn Ph.D.’s!

101. The ink of academia writes history, and today, you’ve written yours. Congratulations, Dr. [Name]!

Written by Gabriel Cruz - Foodie, Animal Lover, Slang & Language Enthusiast

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

PhD Congratulations Messages: Celebrating Academic Milestones

If someone you know has recently completed their PhD, sending a congratulatory message is a wonderful way to show your support and celebrate their amazing achievement. However, crafting the perfect message can be a daunting task, as a PhD is a significant accomplishment that may leave you struggling for the right words. Thankfully, we have you covered with a comprehensive guide to help you write the best PhD congratulations message that truly conveys your genuine happiness and admiration for their achievement.

PhD Congratulations Messages

“Congratulations on earning your PhD! Your unwavering dedication, relentless pursuit of knowledge, and exceptional intellect have led you to this incredible achievement. May your future be as bright as the stars you have reached for.”

“Congratulations on your outstanding achievement, Dr. [Name]! Your hard work, dedication, and perseverance have culminated in this well-deserved milestone. May your future be filled with even greater accomplishments.”

“Dr. [Name], you have truly reached the pinnacle of academic excellence! Your passion and commitment have led you to this incredible moment. Wishing you a lifetime of continued success and intellectual pursuits.”

“It is with immense joy that we celebrate your triumphant PhD journey, Dr. [Name]. Your unwavering determination has paved the way for a bright and prosperous future. Cheers to your incredible success!”

“Warmest congratulations on your PhD, Dr. [Name]! Your devotion to your field and thirst for knowledge are truly inspiring. May this be the beginning of a remarkable and fulfilling career.”

“Dr. [Name], you have reached the stars with your hard-earned PhD! We are immensely proud of your incredible accomplishment and look forward to seeing the great things you will undoubtedly achieve.”

“You have done it, Dr. [Name]! Your hard work, tenacity, and resilience have finally paid off. This significant milestone is a testament to your dedication and passion for your field. Wishing you all the best on your journey ahead.”

“Congratulations, Dr. [Name], on your phenomenal achievement! Your commitment to research and education has earned you this momentous honor. May you continue to soar to new heights in your career and beyond.”

“A standing ovation for the newly minted Dr. [Name]! Your tireless efforts and unwavering focus have led you to this magnificent accomplishment. Here is to your future successes and the impact you will make in your field.”

“It is an honor to congratulate you, Dr. [Name], on your exceptional achievement! Your relentless pursuit of knowledge and academic excellence has earned you a well-deserved place among the elite. May your future be as bright and prosperous as your journey thus far.”

“Dr. [Name], your dedication and passion for your field have culminated in this momentous occasion. Congratulations on your PhD! We are thrilled to celebrate this significant milestone with you and eagerly anticipate the incredible contributions you will make in the years to come.”

“Bravo on your phenomenal accomplishment! Your PhD is a testament to your perseverance, curiosity, and commitment to excellence. May this milestone propel you to even greater heights in your personal and professional endeavors.”

“Earning a PhD is no small feat, and you have done it with grace and determination. Your passion for learning and your drive to contribute to your field is truly inspiring. Congratulations on this well-deserved success!”

“Congratulations on earning your PhD! Your hard work, dedication, and unwavering commitment to your field have truly paid off. Welcome to the world of esteemed scholars!”

“Bravo on your outstanding achievement! Earning a PhD is no small feat, and you have demonstrated the tenacity and intellectual prowess required to make it to the finish line. We are all so proud of you!”

“A monumental accomplishment like earning your PhD deserves the highest praise! Your journey has been filled with countless hours of research, late nights, and perseverance. You have truly earned the title “Doctor.””

“Heartfelt congratulations on your hard-earned PhD! This milestone signifies not only your expertise in your field but also the countless sacrifices you have made along the way. Your dedication is inspiring!”

“The world of academia has gained an exceptional new doctor! Congratulations on your remarkable achievement of earning your PhD. Your hard work and persistence have opened the doors to a world of opportunities.”

“Earning a PhD is an extraordinary accomplishment that speaks to your intelligence, passion, and perseverance. Congratulations on joining the ranks of esteemed scholars and paving the way for future generations!”

“Cheers to you, Doctor! Your journey towards your PhD has been filled with challenges and triumphs, and you have shown unwavering resilience throughout it all. We couldn’t be prouder of your incredible achievement.”

“Your tireless dedication and commitment to your field have finally culminated in the prestigious title of “Doctor.” Congratulations on your well-deserved PhD and the bright future that lies ahead!”

“Today, we celebrate not only your PhD but also the incredible journey you have taken to reach this milestone. Congratulations, Doctor, on your extraordinary achievement and the difference you will make in your field!”

“You have climbed the academic mountain, and now you stand at the peak with your hard-earned PhD. Congratulations on this momentous accomplishment, Doctor ! Your dedication and passion have truly set you apart.”

“Your tireless efforts and commitment to your research have culminated in a remarkable achievement. Congratulations on earning your PhD! May your groundbreaking work continue to make a difference in the world.”

“Congratulations on earning your PhD! Your dedication, resilience, and passion for learning have not only led to remarkable contributions in your field but have also inspired your academic community. Keep reaching for the stars!”

“A huge congratulations to you on completing your PhD journey! Your hard work and determination have paid off, leaving a lasting impact on your field of study. Wishing you continued success and growth in all your future endeavors.”

“Kudos to you for completing your PhD! Your unwavering commitment to excellence has brought about significant advancements in your field. We are excited to see the incredible difference you will continue to make in the world.”

“Cheers to our newest PhD! Your journey has been filled with dedication and resilience, leading to groundbreaking contributions in your field. May this be just the beginning of a long and impactful academic career.”

“Bravo on achieving your PhD! Your passion for learning and tireless efforts have left an indelible mark on your field. We eagerly anticipate the exceptional contributions you will continue to make as you embark on the next chapter of your journey.”

“Congratulations on your remarkable achievement! Your PhD is a testament to your diligence and love for learning. Your significant contributions have enriched our academic community, and we look forward to your future accomplishments.”

“Warmest congratulations on your well-deserved PhD! Your steadfast determination and thirst for knowledge have led to extraordinary advancements in your field. We are honored to have you as part of our academic community and cannot wait to see the impact you will make in the years to come.”

“A standing ovation for our newest PhD graduate! Your hard work, dedication, and passion for your field have culminated in significant contributions to our academic community. May your future be filled with further discoveries and successes.”

“Congratulations on your doctoral degree! Your commitment, dedication, and perseverance have paid off, and you should be proud of your incredible achievement.”

“The road to earning a PhD is long and arduous, but your determination and hard work have brought you to this incredible milestone. Congratulations on this incredible achievement, and I wish you all the success in your future endeavors.”

“Earning a doctoral degree is a testament to your commitment and passion for learning, and it is a remarkable accomplishment that deserves to be celebrated. Congratulations on this incredible milestone!”

“Your PhD is a symbol of your unwavering commitment to your academic pursuits, and your hard work and dedication have brought you to this incredible moment of success. Congratulations on your achievement, and I wish you all the best in your future endeavors.”

“It takes a tremendous amount of effort, dedication, and discipline to earn a doctoral degree, and your accomplishment is a testament to your hard work and determination. Congratulations on this incredible achievement!”

“Earning a PhD is a significant milestone that requires years of hard work, sacrifice, and dedication. Your achievement is a testament to your unwavering commitment to your academic pursuits, and I am honored to congratulate you on this incredible accomplishment.”

“Congratulations on earning your doctoral degree! Your commitment, hard work, and perseverance have paid off, and you should be proud of your incredible achievement. I wish you all the best as you continue to pursue your academic and professional goals.”

“Your PhD is a symbol of your unwavering commitment to your academic pursuits and your dedication to excellence. Congratulations on this incredible achievement, and I have no doubt that you will continue to achieve great things in your future endeavors.”

“Earning a doctoral degree is a remarkable accomplishment that requires years of hard work and dedication. Congratulations on reaching this incredible milestone, and I wish you all the success in your future endeavors.”

“Your PhD is a testament to your dedication, determination, and passion for learning. Congratulations on this incredible achievement, and I have no doubt that you will continue to make a significant impact in your field.”

“Heartfelt congratulations on your momentous achievement! Earning your PhD is a reflection of your unwavering commitment to your field, and your significant contributions have already left a lasting impression. We are excited to witness the incredible feats you will continue to accomplish.”

“Hooray for our brilliant PhD graduate! Your journey has been marked by perseverance, passion, and dedication, resulting in exceptional contributions to your field. May you continue to inspire and pave the way for future scholars. Congratulations!”

“Congratulations, Doctor! Your journey to earning your PhD is a testament to your tenacity, resilience, and thirst for knowledge. You have proven that hard work and dedication truly pay off, and we couldn’t be prouder of your success.”

“Bravo on completing your doctoral journey! You have not only earned a prestigious title but also demonstrated exceptional fortitude and dedication in pursuit of your passion. Cheers to a future filled with discovery and continued success!”

“It is with immense pride that we congratulate you on earning your PhD. Your trailblazing research, extraordinary work ethic, and unwavering focus have led to this outstanding accomplishment. May your academic prowess continue to shine in your future endeavors.”

“Congratulations on your well-deserved PhD! Your hard work, dedication, and perseverance have paid off, and your research has made a significant impact in your field. You have set a high standard for all aspiring scholars, and we look forward to seeing the exciting opportunities that lie ahead for you.”

“It is a pleasure to congratulate you on earning your PhD! You have demonstrated exceptional commitment to your research, and your contributions to your field have been invaluable. We are confident that you will continue to achieve great things in your academic and professional journey.”

“Your PhD is a testament to your hard work, resilience, and dedication to your field. Your research has made a significant impact, and we are excited to see the exciting opportunities that will come your way. Congratulations on this well-deserved achievement!”

“Congratulations on your PhD! Your hard work and perseverance have paid off, and your research has made a significant contribution to your field. We have no doubt that you will continue to excel in your academic and professional journey.”

“We are delighted to congratulate you on earning your PhD! Your commitment to your research, hard work, and dedication have all paid off, and we are proud of your accomplishments. We know that you will continue to make a positive impact in your field, and we wish you all the best in your future endeavors.”

“Congratulations on your well-deserved PhD! Your hard work, dedication, and perseverance have set an excellent example for others to follow. Your research has made a significant impact, and we are excited to see where your journey takes you next.”

“We are thrilled to congratulate you on earning your PhD! Your dedication to your research and hard work have paid off, and your contributions to your field are truly remarkable. We know that you will continue to achieve great things in your academic and professional journey.”

“Your PhD is a testament to your hard work, dedication, and perseverance. Your research has made a significant impact in your field, and we are confident that you will continue to excel in your academic and professional journey. Congratulations on this remarkable achievement!”

“Congratulations on earning your PhD! Your hard work and dedication to your research have paid off, and your contributions to your field are invaluable. We are excited to see where your journey takes you next, and we wish you all the best in your future endeavors.”

“We are honored to congratulate you on earning your PhD! Your hard work, dedication, and perseverance have paid off, and your research has made a significant impact in your field. We know that you will continue to achieve great things in your academic and professional journey, and we look forward to following your progress.”

“Congratulations on your exceptional achievement! Your PhD is a reflection of your perseverance, ingenuity, and commitment to advancing your field. We eagerly await the remarkable contributions you will undoubtedly make in the years to come.”

“The journey to a PhD is a long and challenging one, but you have conquered it with flying colors. Your steadfast dedication and passion for your research have led you to this impressive milestone. Congratulations, and here is to a future filled with knowledge and success!”

“A massive congratulations on your hard-earned PhD! Your brilliant mind, unwavering determination, and commitment to excellence have culminated in this outstanding achievement. We are thrilled to see what incredible opportunities lie ahead for you, Doctor!”

“Congratulations on your amazing achievement, [Name]! Your dedication, hard work, and intelligence have paid off, and I am so proud of you. Your research on [topic] is truly groundbreaking and I cannot wait to see where it takes you in the future.”

“It is not every day that someone achieves a Ph.D., but then again, you are not just anyone, [Name]. You have always been one of the smartest and most driven people I know, and this achievement is a testament to your unwavering commitment to excellence. Congratulations!”

“Wow, [Name], you did it! Your intelligence and perseverance have never ceased to amaze me, and now you have accomplished something truly extraordinary. Your research on [topic] has the potential to change the world, and I cannot wait to see what you do next.”

“Congratulations on your Ph.D., [Name]! I have always admired your intelligence and work ethic, and now that you have accomplished this incredible feat, I am even more in awe of you. You have a bright future ahead, and I am honored to be your friend.”

“You are an inspiration, [Name]. Your dedication to your research and your unwavering commitment to excellence have led you to this incredible achievement. Congratulations on earning your Ph.D. – you deserve all the success that comes your way!”

“Congratulations, [Name], on completing your Ph.D. program! Your intelligence, hard work, and determination have paid off, and you have truly earned this achievement. I cannot wait to see what amazing things you accomplish in the future.”

“It is not every day that someone earns a Ph.D., but then again, you are not just anyone, [Name]. Your passion for your research and your unwavering commitment to your goals have led you to this incredible achievement. Congratulations on this incredible milestone!”

“Congratulations on earning your Ph.D., [Name]! You have always been one of the most intelligent and driven people I know, and this achievement is a true testament to your dedication and hard work. I am so proud to call you my [friend/family member].”

“You did it, [Name]! Congratulations on earning your Ph.D. – your achievement is a testament to your intelligence, your dedication, and your incredible work ethic. I have no doubt that you will continue to achieve great things in the future.”

“Congratulations, [Name], on earning your Ph.D.! Your intelligence, your passion for your research, and your unwavering commitment to excellence have led you to this incredible achievement. You have a bright future ahead, and I cannot wait to see where your research takes you next.”

Related Posts:

• Birthday Wishes 1st Birthday
• Happy Birthday May Allah Bless You with Good Health
• Good Health Birthday Wishes and Long Life
• Retirement Wishes for Teacher from Student
• Happy Birthday to the Man Who Stole My Heart Messages Wishes
• Let Me Love You Quotes

Congratulations on PhD Graduation Wishes & Messages

Congratulations wishes for phd degree graduation, congratulations on your doctorate degree quotes with images.

27. Congratulations to the outstanding brilliant thinker. Thumbs up to an exceptional mind who has achieved something outstanding; obtaining a PhD degree is no child’s play. May the universe be kind to you, always.

Congratulations Messages for Phd Degree Graduation

Congratulations on phd degree quotes.

The excitement is out of this world, and I’m thrilled to my toes celebrating with you! Congratulations on your PhD degree, dearest! Now, I can quote you authoritatively on everything. Well, nearly everything.

50. Four years of hard work and intense dedication have led to your PhD degree. Congratulations! May you succeed beyond measure.

PhD Graduation Card Messages

63. Congratulations on your PhD degree! You made it! You’re the best, always!

66. A heartfelt congratulations on completing your PhD degree, Happy to see you fulfil your dreams, ain’t you happy that you’ve made it?

Congratulations Message for Doctor Degree

80. A warm congratulations to you on your doctorate degree. Kudos to you for a job well done and for putting in the work. You rock!

84. Congratulations on one of the best days of your life! The best is yet to come as earning your doctorate degree is only the start. Let’s celebrate this milestone with a bash, shall we? You’ve proved yourself worthy of the ‘doctor’ title.

Best Wishes for Getting Doctorate Degree

Hope you got something really nice from this post. Kindly share this with your family and friends on all social media platforms. Feel free to drop your comments and questions. I’ll gladly respond.

Teal Smiles

Best Wishes, Quotes and Condolence

PhD Congratulations Messages

Congratulations Messages for PhD or Doctorate Degree: Getting a PhD (Doctorate degree) is not an easy task, it is a big stepping stone towards a brighter future.  A PhD or PhD is the best form of education anyone can get, and it’s not just a degree. It is a degree that will bring a new perspective to your life, so enjoy the moments of earning your hard-earned doctorate. Congratulations on getting your Ph.D. and being the doctor of your own destiny. Anyone who has a PhD degree must have sacrificed a lot to achieve it and deserves a sincere praise.

Do you know anyone who is graduating soon or are you wondering how to congratulate someone for successfully completing a PhD or thinking on what to write in a graduation card?  In this article, we have compiled the best PhD congratulations messages for finishing your Doctorate degree. Make your choice from the list below and congratulate them, acknowledging their hardships and sacrifices. Sending a good congratulatory message in warm and passionate words makes the moment even more enjoyable.

Short PhD Congratulations Messages

Finally, you are successful! Congratulations on your Ph.D.

Well-done to successfully complete your Ph.D. I am proud of you.

Well deserved. Well earned. Well praised. Well done. Am proud of you.

Hard work always pays off! A quote has proven true by you today “Doctor”.

Well done, Doctor. I wish you more success and prosperity in days to come.

What a special moment indeed. Congratulations for successfully completing your PhD.

Finally, you nailed it! Congratulations Doctor on your hard-earned doctoral degree.

Congratulations on making a mark on your own steam. No small feat indeed. Blessings.

Congratulations on receiving your hard-earned doctoral degree. Best wishes for the future.

Congratulation on the degree, my fiancé. I wish you all the love and success in life ahead!

Congratulations on your Ph.D., dear husband. You will always be a source of inspiration for me.

Best wishes for this important milestone in your life and career. May there be many more to come.

Congratulations Dr. Nerd on your success. We always knew that you are going to make it to the top.

Congratulations for completing your PhD and best wishes as you begin an exciting new phase of life.

A hearty Congratulations for getting the “Doctor” title finally. Kudos to the hard work you put in!

Being honored with the highest degree is an honor in itself. Congratulations Doctor on your success!

Congratulations Doctor. You are indeed the doctor of persistent hard work and tremendous self-belief.

Thank you for raising your head high and getting your Ph.D. Your courage and dedication made you very proud.

Success was always obliged to come before you. With the right attitude and determination of all those years.

Bravo, Doctor, I want to wish you additional accomplishment and success in the days to come. Congratulations.

Doctorate Congratulations Messages For Myself

My dream of getting my doctorate has finally come true. I can’t be more proud than today.

One of the critical things that have enabled me achieve my Doctorate degree is perseverance.

I am very proud of myself for successfully completing my Ph.D. May God help me achieve my other dreams.

Dr. [Enter Your Name] , I would like to express my warm greetings for continuing to prove myself. Congratulations is the order of the day for me.

Successful people get results by not using excuses for explaining their failures. I am a living proof of the same “Doctor”. Congrats to me!!!

PhD Greeting Card Messages

Congratulations doctor. You are certainly the sweetest and the most handsome doctor and I’m proud to be your sister.

Years of hard work and dedication has finally resulted into the biggest fruit you have ever wanted son. Many congratulations for your PhD degree.

You are truly inspirational. The hard work and efforts you put into your endeavors is beyond excellent. Congratulations on another success to you!

You have never been prideful but modest in your achievements. I am so proud of you, my son. Many congrats for your PhD degree.

I am so happy my best friend that your years of hard work has finally paid off in the best way possible. Best wishes on your PhD degree.

I sincerely congratulate you on finishing to the end and earning your degree. All hardships paid off proud and generously to call you my sister.

Congratulation on such a major success. Your hardship and efforts have finally paid you off with a doctorate degree in your hand. Love you so much.

Congratulations on becoming a PhD holder! We hope that all struggles are worth this training and can now fly higher than ever. I wish you the future.

Congratulations on your Ph.D. Having completed such a milestone, I wish you happiness and satisfaction in your life.

It’s probably the best day of your life. Celebrate with a bash “Doctor”. You’ve proved yourself worthy of the title.

Congratulations on achieving your doctoral degree. It is such a pleasure seeing you at conferences and workshops. Hope to see more of you in the coming years.

Congratulations on achieving your doctorate degree. Now that you have completed such a milestone, I pray you to find happiness and satisfaction in life as well.

Thank you for proving once again how strong and dedicated you are when it comes to achieving your goals. I love you so much, son. Congratulations on your degree.

Congratulations to you on becoming a PhD holder! I hope all the struggles are worth this drill and now you can soar higher than ever. Best wishes for the future.

I wish that all the goals that you have set become more attainable now since the biggest dream of your life has already come true. Best wishes on your achievements.

A PhD is not an easy task at all. It takes blood, sweat and a lot of coffee. Congratulations brother you made it. Congratulations on this outstanding feat. Well done.

Your old dream of becoming a PhD holder has finally come true. Congratulations on your success. You not only made us all dream, but inspired us to work hard to achieve it.

Congratulations on your Ph.D. Thank you for setting a great example, sir. Many happy returns of these amazing successes.

You were always the most dedicated and disciplined student I have ever come across. Many congratulations on your degree.

I hope you know that you haven’t put stones in the past few years and I’m very proud of you. Congratulations on your PHD.

Perseverance is that one key that has landed you to such a remarkable position of attaining your PhD degree. Many congrats.

Receiving a PhD is no less than a coronation. Congratulations for being crowned as “Doctor”. You are the King of Dedication.

Head up, chin up and always proud to be a girl. See what places your confidence has taken you. So proud of you.

I wish you all the best for all your future endeavors and that you achieve all the more success after your PhD.

Congratulations for never losing faith in yourself and always believing in yourself and your research. Good luck.

I pray that you will be able to attain all the goals that you have set, especially now that you have successfully achieved one of your greatest dreams in life. Happy graduation.

Congratulations on earning your PhD from the entire staff at the laboratory. You have earned every single moment of this praise and appreciation. Best wishes for your career path.

Many years of working hard with utmost dedication to your studies have finally borne the most fabulous fruits that you have been longing. Congratulations on this gigantic achievement.

Congratulations Messages for PhD or Doctorate Degree

Congratulations on your Ph.D. I have seen you work hard day and night and now all the hardships make you proud and well paid.

You have again proven how dedicated and strong you are. Congratulations on your Ph.D. I am sincerely happy with your success.

Congratulations on your great success. Your hardships and hard work finally gave you a PhD in your hands. I love you so much.

Your perseverance and dedication has enabled you to embark on this successful chapter of life. Congratulations and best wishes.

It’s a success for everyone who supported you in your days of hard work. So congratulations to you and your family and friends!

Dear son, I sincerely congratulate you on your Ph.D. It was never easy, but I did not give up. God bless you forever. I Love You.

You have truly proven self-dedication and perseverance. God bless you to achieve all the success that awaits you. Congratulations on PHD.

Thank you again for proving how strong and dedicated you are in achieving your goals. I love you so much. Congratulations on your degree.

Congratulations Doctor. Your motivation and optimism is an inspiration to many. Stay the same. Keep flying and attaining greater heights!

Thank you for holding our heads high and achieving the PhD. Your courage and dedication have led you to earn this, extremely proud of you.

This PhD degree guarantees a bright future with a lot of money! Now you have wings and you can fly high, doctor. Congratulations!

It is a great joy and honor to finally hear that with this Ph.D. all your hardships have finally come to fruition. God bless you.

You were not only the most disciplined learner I knew but also the most dedicated one. I wish you the best dear. Congratulations.

Many congratulations on this wonderful accomplishment. It has been a pleasure watching you successfully present your dissertation.

Congratulations for bring the most studious of us all. Never could manage to study so much. But you are different. You have done it.

Keep that sharp brain behind thick glasses ticking with newer ways for making the world more aware. Congratulations and best wishes.

You haven’t been proud of your achievements, but now is the time to be proud. You nailed it and surpassed all of us. I’m proud, friend

A Doctorate degree comes with a great deal of respect from one everybody, the respect that you can rightfully earned. Congratulations!

You have proved again how dedicated and strong-willed you are. Congratulations on earning your PhD. I am truly happy for your success.

This is just the beginning. Your flight of success has taken off and guess what? You’re the pilot. You’re going to take yourself to places!

Your dream of holding a doctorate degree by your name has finally been fulfilled. I cannot be any prouder than I am today. Love you so much.

We always knew the wonderful person you are behind your geeky glasses. I am so happy you made it to the top. Many congrats on your PhD degree.

You have made us proud everyday with everything you have achieved so far. It’s a pleasure to have a daughter like you. Congrats on your success!

Congratulations on completing your dissertation. I have learnt a lot from you working under you in the laboratory. You are an inspiration to all of us here.

Congratulations on your successful completion of your Ph.D. It makes us all proud. You have always been committed and I am sure it is very encouraging indeed.

You truly have proved your self-dedication and perseverance, dear sister. May God bless you to achieve all the success that is waiting for you. Congratulations on your PHD.

Congratulations. Your area of specialization is one that is not pursued by many. You have shown remarkable courage and brilliance. We wish you all the luck and success in life.

Congratulations Messages for PhD

Congratulations on your doctorate degree, doctorate degree quotes, funny phd completion quotes.

• PhD Congratulations Funnys

Congratulations Messages for PhD: Congratulations messages for a PhD are a great way to show your support and admiration for someone who has achieved a major milestone in their academic career. Earning a PhD is no small feat, and it deserves to be celebrated. Whether you are congratulating a family member, friend, or colleague, there are many ways to express your joy and pride for their accomplishment. When crafting a congratulations message for a PhD, it is important to remember that this is a momentous occasion and should be celebrated in a heartfelt and meaningful way. A heartfelt message should include words of encouragement and admiration, as well as a sincere expression of pride for the recipient. Additionally, it is important to acknowledge the hard work and dedication that went into earning the degree, and to recognize the importance of the achievement.

When sending a congratulations message for a PhD, it is also important to make sure that the message is tailored to the recipient. Consider their interests and passions, and use this as a way to personalize the message. Additionally, consider adding a thoughtful gift or token of appreciation to make the congratulatory message even more meaningful.

• Congratulations on completing your PhD! This is a tremendous accomplishment and a testament to your hard work and dedication.
• You did it! Congratulations on successfully completing your doctoral degree. Your perseverance and commitment have paid off.
• Congratulations on your remarkable achievement. Your PhD is a reflection of your intelligence, hard work, and perseverance.
• You have achieved something truly special. Congratulations on completing your PhD, and best wishes for your future endeavors.
• Congratulations on earning your PhD! Your research has made a significant contribution to your field, and you should be proud of all that you have accomplished.
• You did it! Congratulations on completing your PhD. Your intelligence, hard work, and dedication have paid off.
• Your dedication, hard work, and perseverance have paid off. Congratulations on earning your PhD!
• Congratulations on this incredible achievement. Your determination and hard work have resulted in a degree that will open doors and change lives.
• You have achieved a significant milestone in your life. Congratulations on earning your PhD and all the best for your future endeavors.
• Congratulations on completing your PhD. Your hard work and dedication are truly inspiring, and your achievement is something to be proud of.
• You have worked hard for this moment, and you deserve all the congratulations you receive. Congratulations on earning your PhD!
• Your commitment to your studies and dedication to your research have paid off. Congratulations on earning your PhD!
• Congratulations on earning your PhD. Your research has made a significant contribution to your field, and we can't wait to see what you accomplish next.
• You have demonstrated exceptional dedication and perseverance in your studies, and your success is a reflection of your hard work. Congratulations on completing your PhD.
• Your hard work, intelligence, and determination have resulted in this amazing accomplishment. Congratulations on earning your PhD!
• Congratulations on achieving your PhD. Your determination and hard work have brought you to this point, and we are all proud of you.
• You have achieved something truly remarkable. Congratulations on earning your PhD and best wishes for your future success.
• Your passion for learning and dedication to your research have resulted in a significant achievement. Congratulations on earning your PhD!
• You have worked tirelessly to reach this point, and your hard work has paid off. Congratulations on earning your PhD.
• Your success is a reflection of your hard work and dedication to your studies. Congratulations on earning your PhD!

Also Read: Congratulation Quotes

Send these messages to someone who has completed their doctorate degree recently and praise their hard work and dedication –

• You have overcome many challenges to reach this point, and your hard work and perseverance have paid off. Congratulations on earning your PhD!
• Congratulations on completing your PhD. Your commitment to your research and dedication to your studies have resulted in a significant achievement.
• Your passion for learning and hard work have resulted in an outstanding achievement. Congratulations on earning your PhD.
• Your intelligence, hard work, and dedication have resulted in a remarkable achievement. Congratulations on earning your PhD!
• Congratulations on achieving your PhD. Your dedication to your studies and commitment to your research have resulted in a significant accomplishment.
• Your hard work and determination have brought you to this point. Congratulations on earning your PhD!
• Congratulations on completing your PhD. Your commitment to your studies and passion for learning have resulted in a significant achievement.
• Your research has made a significant contribution to your field, and your hard work and dedication have resulted in an outstanding achievement. Congratulations on earning your PhD.
• Your intelligence, hard work, and perseverance have resulted in this remarkable accomplishment. Congratulations on earning your PhD!
• Congratulations on completing your PhD. Your hard work and dedication to your studies have resulted in a significant achievement that you can be proud of for the rest of your life.

Also Read: Congratulations messages

Below are some doctorate degree Quotes that can be sent to someone who has achieved this great feat-

• "The most important thing in life is to stop saying 'I wish' and start saying 'I will.' Consider nothing impossible, then treat possibilities as probabilities." - Charles Dickens
• "The only way to do great work is to love what you do. If you haven't found it yet, keep looking. Don't settle. As with all matters of the heart, you'll know when you find it." - Steve Jobs
• "The greatest glory in living lies not in never falling, but in rising every time we fall." - Nelson Mandela
• "Education is the passport to the future, for tomorrow belongs to those who prepare for it today." - Malcolm X
• "Believe you can and you're halfway there." - Theodore Roosevelt
• "Success is not final, failure is not fatal: it is the courage to continue that counts." - Winston Churchill
• "Do not go where the path may lead, go instead where there is no path and leave a trail." - Ralph Waldo Emerson
• "Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world." - Nelson Mandela
• "You have brains in your head. You have feet in your shoes. You can steer yourself any direction you choose." - Dr. Seuss
• "The best way to predict your future is to create it." - Abraham Lincoln

Also Read: Graduation Wishes

Share gigs with someone close who has completed their doctorate degree with flying colours –

• "I finally have a doctorate. Now I can diagnose myself with an acute case of over-education." - Anonymous
• "I'm not a doctor, but I play one in real life." - Anonymous
• "I have a doctorate in procrastination." - Anonymous
• "I'm not a doctor, but I did stay at a Holiday Inn Express last night." - Anonymous
• "I have a doctorate in binge-watching." - Anonymous
• "I have a PhD in sarcasm, but I won't bother explaining it to you." - Anonymous
• "I have a doctorate in being single." - Anonymous
• "I may have a doctorate, but I still can't fix my own computer." - Anonymous
• "I have a PhD in coffee consumption." - Anonymous
• "I have a doctorate in napping, but I'm not currently accepting patients." – Anonymous

Also Read: Congratulations

PhD Congratulations Funny

Here are some funny PhD Congratulations Messages that you can use to send to your special someone-

• Congratulations on getting your PhD! It only took you [insert number of years here] years, which is just a blip on the timeline of eternity.
• Well done on earning your PhD! Now you can officially be a Doctor Who (fan).
• You finally got your PhD! Don’t forget to add ‘Dr.’ to your name on all your Starbucks orders from now on.
• Congratulations on your PhD! You’re now a master of everything, except for basic life skills like laundry and cooking.
• Congratulations on your PhD! You’ve made your parents proud and your friends feel a little bit dumb.
• You’re now officially the smartest person I know with a PhD to prove it. Congrats!
• Congratulations on getting your PhD! I have no idea what your thesis was about, but I’m sure it was incredibly impressive.
• Well done on earning your PhD! Now you can finally start making some real money...in about 10 years.
• Congratulations on getting your PhD! Your thesis was so good, I may just have to steal some of your ideas for my own PhD (in the distant future).
• You did it! You got your PhD! It’s time to celebrate with a glass of champagne and some very nerdy jokes.

Achieving a PhD is a momentous accomplishment and should be celebrated. Congratulations messages for PhD recipients are a great way to show your appreciation and support for their hard work and dedication. Whether it’s a personalized card, flowers, or a celebratory dinner, expressing congratulations for a PhD is a meaningful way to show your admiration for the individual’s achievement.

• Birthday Wishes
• Birthday Wishes for Sister
• Birthday Wishes for Brother
• Birthday Wishes for Friends
• Birthday Messages for Husband
• Birthday Messages for Wife
• Birthday Messages for Son
• Birthday Messages for Daughter
• Birthday Messages for Girlfriend
• Birthday Messages for Boyfriend
• Birthday Wishes for Father
• Birthday Wishes for Mother
• Birthday Wishes for Boss
• Belated Birthday Wishes
• Birthday Wishes for Uncle
• Birthday Wishes for Niece
• Funny Birthday Wishes
• Christian Birthday Wishes
• Birthday Wishes Sister in law
• Happy Birthday Messages for Twins
• Birthday Wishes for Baby Girl
• Birthday Wishes for Baby Boy
• Birthday Wishes For Baby Boy From Mother
• Birthday Wishes for Friend Female
• Happy Birthday Wishes for Lover
• Birthday Shayari in Hindi
• Birthday Quotes
• Birthday Invitation Wording
• Anniversary Wishes
• Wedding Anniversary Wishes
• Marriage Anniversary Quotes for Wife
• 1st Anniversary Wishes
• Anniversary Wishes for Parents
• Anniversary Wishes for Wife
• Anniversary Wishes for Husband
• Anniversary Wishes for Girlfriend
• Anniversary Wishes for Boyfriend
• Belated Anniversary Wishes
• Anniversary Quotes
• Honeymoon Wishes
• Sorry For Your Loss Quotes
• Sorry Messages for Boyfriend
• First Day of School Wishes
• Breakup Messages
• Good Luck Messages
• Good Luck Messages for Exam
• Good Morning Messages
• Good Morning Messages in Hindi
• Good Morning Love Messages
• Good Morning Messages For Husband
• Good Morning Messages For Wife
• Good Morning Messages for Boyfriend
• Good Morning Messages for Girlfriend
• Inspirational Good Morning Messages
• Good Morning Quotes
• Have A Great Day Wishes
• Happy Tuesday Messages
• Inspirational Messages
• Inspirational Quotes
• Love Messages
• Love Quotes
• Love Messages for Boyfriend
• Love Messages for Girlfriend
• I Love You Quotes for Him
• Love Messages for Husband
• Love Quotes For Wife
• Love Shayari
• Love Messages for Her
• Love Messages for Him
• Love Messages for Sister
• Good Night Messages For Boyfriend
• Inspirational Monday Messages
• Good Luck Messages For Job Interview
• Pregnancy Wishes for Sister
• Cute Messages for Best Friend
• Flirty Messages For Boyfriend
• Goodbye Messages For Boyfriend
• Love Calculator
• Love Message for Brother
• Party Invitation Messages
• New Job Wishes
• Thank You Messages
• Thank You Messages for Mentor
• Thank You Messages for Wife
• Thank You Messages to Clients
• Thank You Messages for Teacher
• Thank You Messages For Colleagues At Work
• Thank You Quotes
• Farewell Quotes
• Farewell Messages
• Congratulations Quotes
• Congratulations Messages
• Graduation Wishes
• Job Promotion Wishes
• Condolence Messages
• Get Well Soon Messages
• Get Well Soon Messages for Boss
• Good Night Messages
• Retirement Wishes
• Whatsapp Status
• Quotes for Women
• Wedding Quotes
• Wedding Wishes for Brother
• Wedding Wishes For Sister
• Wedding Wishes for Friend
• Miss You Quotes
• Miss You SMS
• Motivational Quotes
• Funny Quotes
• Funny Toilet Quotes
• Cool Quotes
• Sympathy Quotes
• Teamwork Quotes
• Baby Shower Messages
• Good Evening Messages
• Confirmation Wishes
• Birthday Gift Ideas
• Anniversary Gift Ideas
• Engagement Gift Ideas
• Gift Ideas for Men
• Gift Ideas for Boyfriend
• Gift Ideas for Her
• Baby Shower Gift Ideas
• Naming Ceremony Wishes
• Events Categories
• Thanksgiving Messages
• Thanksgiving Quotes
• Thanksgiving Wishes for Friends
• Thanksgiving Day Messages for Colleague
• Hanukkah Wishes
• Seasons Greetings Messages
• Christmas Eve Messages
• Christmas Messages
• Christmas Quotes
• Christmas and New Year Wishes
• New Year Messages
• New Year Eve Messages
• Mens Day Wishes
• Students’ Day Wishes
• Dussehra Wishes
• Navratri Messages
• Navratri Quotes
• Durga Puja Messages
• Eid Mubarak Messages
• Halloween Messages
• Boss Day Quotes
• Boss Day Messages
• Bastille Day Wishes
• Parents' Day Messages
• Rakhi Messages
• Rakhi Quotes
• Boyfriend Day Wishes
• Friendship Day Messages
• Indian Independence Day Quotes
• Indian Independence Day Messages
• Mothers Day Quotes
• Mother’s Day Messages
• Women's Day Messages
• Baisakhi Wishes
• Bengli New Year Wishes
• Shivratri Wishes
• Tamil New Year Wishes
• Vishu Wishes
• Kwanzaa Wishes
• Republic Day Messages
• Rose Day Messages
• Propose Day Messages
• Chocolate Day Messages
• Teddy Day Messages
• Promise Day Messages
• Hug Day Messages
• Kiss Day Messages
• Valentine's Day Messages
• Father's Day Messages
• Father's Day Quotes
• Janmashtami Wishes
• Canada Day Wishes
• Fourth of July Messages
• Easter Messages
• Ramadan Mubarak Messages
• Grandparents Day Wishes
• Daughters Day Wishes
• Teachers' Day Quotes
• Teachers' Day Messages
• Diwali Messages
• Diwali Quotes

• Relationship

How Long Do Dermal Fillers Last?

Latest Posts

12 benefits of technology for seniors, how to make vagina smell go away, the essential guide to caring for a foster child who is physically disabled, what are bifocal glasses and why you should get one, 150+ congratulations messages for phd or doctorate degree.

In this article, we have compiled the best PhD congratulations messages, congratulations message for finishing PhD, congratulations on phD images, PhD completion quotes, how do you congratulate someone on a PhD, successful completion of PhD, PhD congratulations card, PhD congratulations funny, etc.

PhD Congratulations Message

Congratulations on achieving your PhD. I have seen you working hard day and night and now all the hardship has paid well, proud of you.

You left no stone unturned in these years and I want you to know that I am extremely proud of you. Congratulations on earning your PhD.

Congratulations on successfully completing your Ph.D. and making us all proud. You have always been so dedicated and sure it is very inspiring indeed.

You never took pride in your achievements but it is time to feel proud. You have nailed it and outshined us all. Proud of you, mate.

Congratulations on shining bright and scoring this PhD Degree. It seems all your hard work has paid off at last. So proud of you my dear brother.

My warmest congratulations for making it to the end and achieving your degree. All the hardship has paid off lavishly, proud to call you my sister.

Dear Son, heartiest congratulations on earning a PhD degree. It was never easy but did not give up. May God bless you, forever. Love you.

Congratulations on earning a doctorate degree. Thank you for setting such a great example, teacher. Many happy returns of such a remarkable success.

I am extremely proud of you for successfully completing your doctorate. May God help you to achieve your other dreams too. Love you.

This doctorate degree ensures a bright future with lots of money for you! You’ve got wings now and you can soar high, Mr. Doctor. Congratulations!

It is a great pleasure and honor to hear about all your hardship finally have finally paid off with this PhD degree. May God bless you and help you achieve more in life.

Weldone for successfully completing your PhD. I’m proud of you.

Congratulations on earning a doctorate degree, dear husband. You are and always will be a source of inspiration for me.

Sending my warmest greetings for proving yourself over and over again. Many happy returns of this day and once again congratulations on achieving a PHD Degree.

A PhD is not an easy task at all. It takes blood, sweat and a lot of coffee. Congratulations brother you made it.Congratulations on this outstanding feat. Well done.

Congratulations doctor. You are certainly the sweetest and the most handsome doctor and I’m proud to be your sister.

Our faculty and staff are extremely proud of our young doctorates who have accomplished this task with their hard work. Congratulations on your achievement. Wish you a successful and bright life ahead.

Congratulations. Your dissertation was impeccable. Best wishes.

Congratulations. Your academic publications reveals a sharp intellect and an observant nature. Well done.

Congratulations. Your area of specialization is one that is not pursued by many. You have shown remarkable courage and brilliance. We wish you all the luck and success in life.

Congratulations on making a mark on your own steam. No small feat indeed. Blessings.

Congratulations for bring the most studious of us all. Never could manage to study so much. But you are different. You have done it.

Keep that sharp brain behind thick glasses ticking with newer ways for making the world more aware. Congratulations and best wishes.

Best wishes for this important milestone in your life and career. May there be many more to come.

Congratulations for never losing faith in yourself and always believing in yourself and your research. Good luck.

Head up, chin up and always proud to be a girl. See what places your confidence has taken you. So proud of you.

Congratulations on receiving your hard-earned doctoral degree. Best wishes for the future.

Many congratulations on this wonderful accomplishment. It has been a pleasure watching you successfully present your dissertation.

What a special moment indeed. Congratulations for successfully completing your PhD.

Your perseverance and dedication has enabled you to embark on this successful chapter of life. Congratulations and best wishes.

Congratulations for completing your PhD and best wishes as you begin an exciting new phase of life.

Congratulations on completing your dissertation. I have learnt a lot from you working under you in the laboratory. You are an inspiration to all of us here.

Congratulations Doctor. You are indeed the doctor of persistent hard work and tremendous self-belief.

Receiving a PhD is no less than a coronation. Congratulations for being crowned as “Doctor”. You are the King of Dedication.

Well deserved. Well earned. Well praised. Well done. Am proud of you.

Congratulations on achieving your doctoral degree. It is such a pleasure seeing you at conferences and workshops. Hope to see more of you in the coming years.

Congratulations on earning your PhD from the entire staff at the laboratory. You have earned every single moment of this praise and appreciation. Best wishes for your career path.

PhD Congratulations Card Messages

Finnaly, you nailed it! Congratulations Doctor on your hard-earned doctoral degree.

Congratulations to you on becoming a PhD holder! I hope all the struggles are worth this drill and now you can soar higher than ever. Best wishes for the future.

You have proved again how dedicated and strong-willed you are. Congratulations on earning your PhD. I am truly happy for your success.

You truly have proved your self-dedication and perseverance, dear sister. May God bless you to achieve all the success that is waiting for you. Congratulations on your PHD.

Thank you for proving once again how strong and dedicated you are when it comes to achieving your goals. I love you so much, son. Congratulations on your degree.

Congratulations on achieving your doctorate degree. Now that you have completed such a milestone, I pray you to find happiness and satisfaction in life as well.

Congratulation on such a major success. Your hardship and efforts have finally paid you off with a doctorate degree in your hand. Love you so much.

You have never been prideful but modest in your achievements. I am so proud of you, my son. Many congrats for your PhD degree.

Years of hard work and dedication has finally resulted into the biggest fruit you have ever wanted son. Many congratulations for your PhD degree.

Congratulation on the degree, my fiancé. I wish you all the love and success in life ahead!

You were always the most dedicated and disciplined student I have ever come across. Many congratulations on your degree.

I am so happy my best friend that your years of hard work has finally paid off in the best way possible. Best wishes on your PhD degree.

You have made us proud everyday with everything you have achieved so far. It’s a pleasure to have a daughter like you. Congrats on your success!

Well done, Doctor. I wish you more success and prosperity in days to come.

I wish that all the goals that you have set become more attainable now since the biggest dream of your life has already come true. Best wishes on your achievements.

Perseverance is that one key that has landed you to such a remarkable position of attaining your PhD degree. Many congrats.

I wish you all the best for all your future endeavors and that you achieve all the more success after your PhD.

Congratulations Dr. Nerd on your success. We always knew that you are going to make it to the top.

We always knew the wonderful person you are behind your geeky glasses. I am so happy you made it to the top. Many congrats on your PhD degree.

Success was always obliged to come before you. With the right attitude and determination of all those years.

A hearty Congratulations for getting the “Doctor” title finally. Kudos to the hard work you put in!

Hard work always pays off! A quote has proven true by you today “Doctor”.

You are truly inspirational. The hard work and efforts you put into your endeavors is beyond excellent. Congratulations on another success to you!

A Doctorate degree comes with a great deal of respect from one everybody, the respect that you can rightfully earned. Congratulations!

It’s a success for everyone who supported you in your days of hard work. So congratulations to you and your family and friends!

It’s probably the best day of your life. Celebrate with a bash “Doctor”. You’ve proved yourself worthy of the title.

Successful people get results by not using excuses for explaining their failures. You’ve a living proof of the same “Doctor”.

This is just the beginning. Your flight of success has taken off and guess what? You’re the pilot. You’re going to take yourself to places!

Being honored with the highest degree is an honor in itself. Congratulations Doctor on your success!

People just see the results, but not the hard work, sleepless, anxiety-full nights that you must have put in. Yet you walked on the journey. Congratulations to your hard work and zeal for success!

Your success begins when you start believing in it. I had heard of this a while back and all I could think of was how you always believed in your dream and today you have achieved it. Congratulations!

Congratulations Doctor. Your motivation and optimism is an inspiration to many. Stay the same. Keep flying and attaining greater heights!

Your dream of holding a doctorate degree by your name has finally been fulfilled. I cannot be any prouder than I am today. Love you so much.

Thank you for holding our heads high and achieving the PhD. Your courage and dedication have led you to earn this, extremely proud of you.

Your long-cherished dream of becoming a PhD holder has finally come true. Many congratulations on your success. You’ve inspired all of us not only to dream but also to work hard to achieve them.

RELATED ARTICLES

What to do if a friend is arrested: a guide to navigating a difficult situation, health benefits of pepper and common diseases cured by just eating pepper, waffle house nutrition, diabetes super foods you need to start eating immediately, effective ways on how to get food out of wisdom tooth hole, don't miss, 8 tasty snacks to munch on this winter, rebuilding trust: steps to mend relationships damaged by addiction, prioritize your foot care with kerasal, unlocking the nutritional profile of protein bars, optimizing elderly care: the vital role of family nurse practitioners in medication management.

© YeyeLife | All rights reserved

Quick access

100+ andrew jackson quotes | most famous of all time, 180+ color quotes: most famous & best of all time, 150+ heartfelt grief quotes and sayings.

Global site navigation

• Celebrity biographies
• Messages - Wishes - Quotes
• TV and Movies
• Fashion and style
• Music and singers
• Capital Market
• Celebrities
• Relationships

Local editions

• Habari za Kenya Swahili

PhD congratulations messages, wishes and quotes for cards and Instagram posts

Getting a PhD degree is an achievement since many cannot afford it. Also, many never complete their PhD due to other commitments in life. So, anyone who starts or earns a doctorate deserves sweet PhD congratulations messages and plenty of gifts.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Thoughtful congratulations for phd degree, instagram congratulations for doctor degree, how to say all the best for your phd journey, phd congratulations quotes for cards and instagram posts, funny phd completion quotes, how to congratulate someone for a phd, how do you congratulate someone on becoming a professor, how do you say congratulations on your academic achievement, how do you congratulate someone who is going to university, how do you wish someone academic success, how do you congratulate someone for higher studies, what can you write on a card for a phd graduate, how do you say congratulations professionally.

This article shares long and short PhD congratulations messages, wishes, and quotes. The recipients will only take a few minutes to read them.

Sweet PhD congratulations messages

Earning a PhD degree has been one of the best decisions for many. The doctorate has helped many advance their careers and have an even brighter future. So, congratulate PhD holders for making a decision. Below are lovely PhD graduation messages to choose from:

• Success was always obliged to come before you. With the right attitude and determination of all those years!
• I am sending you a heartfelt congratulations on getting the doctorate title. Kudos to the hard work you put in!
• Hard work always pays off! A quote you have proven true today, doctor.
• You are truly inspirational. The hard work and efforts you put into your endeavors are beyond excellent. Congratulations on another success!
• A doctorate comes with much respect from everybody, the respect you have rightfully earned. Congratulations!
• It's a success for everyone who supported you in your days of hard work. Cheers to you! The entire group is celebrating your amazing achievement.
• Who would have thought you would have a PhD at such a young age? Congratulations on such a significant success.
• Congratulations on your PhD baby. Your hardship and efforts have finally paid you off with a doctorate in your hand.
• Seeing you burn the midnight oil to complete your work while being a wholesome mother was fulfilling. I love you so much.
• You have never been prideful but modest in your achievements. I am so proud of you, my son. Congratulations.
• Congratulations on your PhD degree. Only a few have achieved what you have at such a young age.
• We are sending a round of applause from all of us! Congratulations on making a mark on your own steam. No small feat, indeed. Blessings.
• Congratulations on being the most intellectual of us all. I never could manage to study so much. But you are different. You have done it.
• Many see the results but not the cold, sleepless, anxious nights you spent to get this PhD. Congratulations are in order, doc.
• You walked on the journey. Congratulations on your hard work and zeal for success!
• We have a doctor in the family! We are so proud of you, doc.
• Your success begins when you start believing in it. Congratulations on earning your PhD and believing in yourself!
• Sending a collective high-five from the whole team! Your motivation and optimism are an inspiration to many.
• Hearty congratulations from us, dear friend. Stay the same. Keep flying and attaining greater heights!
• Congratulations, my lovely sister. I wish you all the best in your future endeavors and hope you succeed more after your PhD.
• Congratulations, Dr. Nerd, on your success. We always knew you were going to make it to the top.
• Today will always be a special day for you. Congratulations, and scale higher heights.
• We always knew the intellectual person you are behind your geeky glasses. Congratulations, doctor!
• I am so happy you made it to the top. Many congrats on your PhD degree! You are a winner.
• You have always been a high achiever since elementary. I am so proud of you, my daughter.

300+ inspirational quotes for men to keep you inspired and motivated

Your family or friends deserve hearty congratulations for obtaining a doctorate. Having endured a harrowing journey studying and doing research, it is only fair that you be by their side on their graduation day. Recognize their efforts with these thoughtful congratulations for PhD degree:

• You deserve what you have after all the hard work you've put in. Congratulations on your PhD, bestie.
• You nailed it! Congratulations, doctor, on your doctoral degree.
• Congratulations on earning a PhD! I hope all the struggles are worth it.
• A PhD is an excellent success for you and your family. Now, you can soar higher than ever.
• Best wishes for the future. Your PhD is only one of the many goals that you are set to achieve.
• You have proved again how dedicated and strong-willed you are. Congratulations on your new target, doc.
• The years of hard work and dedication finally resulted in the most significant fruit you have ever wanted—congratulations on your degree.
• Congratulations on the degree, my son. I wish you all the love and success in life ahead!
• I am so happy, my best friend, that your years of hard work have finally paid off in the best way possible. Best wishes on your PhD degree.
• You have made us proud every day with everything you have achieved. It's a pleasure to have a daughter like you. Congrats on your great success!
• You have done well, doctor. I wish you more success and prosperity in the days to come.
• I wish all your goals become more attainable, especially now that the biggest dream of your life has already come true. Best wishes for your achievements!
• You have proven to many that all things are possible despite one's circumstances.
• I wish you the best in your future endeavors. The doctorate is only one among many wins.
• Congratulations sister! Being the first in the family to earn a PhD is undoubtedly a one-of-a-kind achievement.
• Thank you again for proving how strong and dedicated you are to achieving your goals. Congratulations on your doctorate.
• I love you so much, Mom. Congratulations on a truly outstanding achievement. I, too, wish to achieve half of what you have.
• Congratulations on achieving your doctorate. Please receive our warm greetings as a family.
• Now that you have completed such a milestone, I pray you find happiness and satisfaction.
• We always knew the wonderful person you are behind your geeky glasses. I am so happy you made it to the top. Many congrats on your PhD degree!
• Success was always obliged to come before you, with the right attitude and determination of all those years.
• A hearty congratulations on finally getting the doctor's title. Kudos to the hard work you put in!
• I wish society could produce many more like you. You are truly inspirational. Congratulations on your PhD, sir.
• Your hard work and efforts are beyond excellent. Congratulations on another PhD success!

Best David Goggins' quotes that will inspire and motivate you

It is a flex to have friends and family who are academic giants. So, post your beloved on social media and boast about their doctorate achievements. Write these lovely PhD congratulations wishes and captions beneath the pictures:

• Years of hard work and dedication have finally produced the most significant fruit you have ever wanted, son.
• I can't wait to see you change the world with the knowledge you gained at school. Congratulations on your PhD degree!
• Congratulations on the degree, my baby. I wish you all the love and success in life ahead!
• You have worked hard, and now you can enjoy the fruits. Congratulations on your doctorate.
• A PhD is not easy. It takes blood, sweat, and a lot of coffee. Congratulations, brother. You made it.
• It's the best day of your life. Celebrate with a bash doctor. You've proved yourself worthy of the title.
• A PhD is just the beginning. Your flight of success has taken off, and guess what? You're the pilot. You're going to take yourself to places!
• Being honored with the highest degree is an honor in itself. Congratulations, doctor, on your success.
• Perseverance is one key to your remarkable achievement of attaining your PhD degree. Many congrats!
• A salute to your success! I wish you all the best in your future endeavors and hope you succeed more after your PhD.
• Pop the champagne; you did it, Dr. Nerd! We always knew you were going to make it to the top.
• Congratulations on this outstanding feat. Well done, son. You couldn't have made me any prouder.
• Congratulations doctor. You are the sweetest and the most handsome doctor, and I'm proud to be your sister.
• Our faculty and staff are incredibly proud of our young doctorates who have accomplished this task with their hard work. Please enjoy your fruits.
• I wish you a successful and bright life ahead. The fruit of your hard work is the sweetest.
• Cheers to your achievement! Your dissertation was impeccable. Best wishes.
• Your academic publications reveal a sharp intellect and an observant nature. I’m so impressed with your achievement!
• Congratulations on your well-deserved success, dear. You have worked so hard; it is time for you to enjoy the efforts of your labor.
• Congratulations, Doctor Bookworm. Only a few have pursued your area of specialization. You are a gem in the community.
• You have shown remarkable courage and brilliance. We wish you all luck and success in life.
• A doctorate comes with a great deal of admiration from everybody. You’re remarkable.
• You have indeed worked for the respect that you have rightfully earned. Congratulations on your doctorate.
• Nice one! Congrats! We are grateful to God for the great victory He has bestowed upon you this day. Congratulations.
• It's a success for everyone who supported you during your hard work. So, congratulations on your achievement.
• We take great pride in your progress and have faith in your future. Congratulations on achieving this milestone.

110+ college graduation captions to celebrate your success

Sending people best wishes cards is one of the oldest ways of encouraging them in their endeavors. So, buy that card and write any of the following warm wishes as they start their PhD journey:

• Your sharp brain will surely find new ways to better the world. Congratulations and best wishes on your PhD journey.
• Congratulations on starting this milestone in your life and career. More success awaits you after your PhD graduation.
• Congratulations on never losing faith and believing in yourself. All the best on your PhD journey, and may your graduation be lit.
• Keep your head and chin up, be proud of yourself, and see where your confidence will take you. Congratulations, and all the best on your PhD journey.
• Best wishes on your PhD journey. Let the Lord guide you until we congratulate you on receiving your doctoral degree.
• Congratulations on taking this bold step. We believe in you, and your graduation will be a blast. All the best on your PhD journey.
• I can only imagine how excited you are about this degree. Congratulations, future doc, and remember, we will party till dawn on your graduation day.
• It will be a pleasure watching you successfully present your dissertation. All the best on your PhD journey.
• Be proud of being the newest PhD scholar in our gang. Good things come to those who work for them, and you will sure have that degree.
• All the best on your PhD journey, my baby. The family will be waiting for your graduation. I wish you all the love and success in life ahead!
• You were always the most dedicated and disciplined student I have encountered. Congratulations on embarking on a PhD journey.
• Congratulations on your new degree journey, but do not study too much. You are allowed to take a break, Miss Determination.
• Receive my congratulations on your PhD degree enrollment. It is an achievement that everyone is proud of.
• You made us proud every day with everything you achieved growing up. Earning a doctorate will be the icing on the cake. All the best on your PhD journey. We will come and watch you flaunt your shiny gown.
• It's a pleasure to have a daughter like you. All the best on your PhD journey, future doctor! Amazing things happen to amazing people!
• I cannot imagine that my baby wants to be a doctor. One more fantastic chapter to add to the book of your life! Congratulations on enrolling for your PhD, son.
• Well done, future doctor. I wish you more success and prosperity in the days to come. You're a true inspiration, and I couldn't be happier for you.
• You have begun chasing the biggest dream of your life, and it will come true. I wish you all the best on your PhD journey.
• Be happy and rejoice while keeping your eyes on the target. Best wishes for your PhD enrollment! I am delighted.
• Perseverance is one of the keys to attaining your PhD degree. You are intelligent enough to achieve this.
• I couldn't think of someone more determined to get a PhD than you. You will surely nail it! All the best on your postgraduate degree journey. XO
• Congratulations on getting into that PhD program, my dear. The time for a joyful graduation to celebrate all your hard work shall come.
• Hats off to you for dreaming about being a doctor! Congratulations on your enrollment, and all the best on your PhD journey.
• Accomplished people rarely sit back and let things happen to them. They go out and make things happen. I know you got this! Best wishes on your PhD journey.
• Best wishes on your PhD journey, upcoming doctor, and early graduation! You're off to greater places!

Happy 20th birthday captions to say goodbye to your teen years

Education is a journey that requires appreciation when one makes an achievement. For well-earned moments of pride like a PhD, your congratulations can help make someone's graduation feel extra special. Here are beautiful educational quotes to share with a doctorate graduate:

• Live as if you were to die tomorrow. Learn as if you were to live forever. - Mahatma Gandhi
• The beautiful thing about learning is that no one can take it away from you. - B.B. King
• Education is the most powerful weapon you can use to change the world. - Nelson Mandela
• Education is the passport to the future; tomorrow belongs to those who prepare for it today. - Malcolm X
• The more that you read, the more things you will know. The more that you learn, the more places you'll go. - Dr. Seuss
• Education is not the filling of a pail but the lighting of a fire. - William Butler Yeats
• The purpose of education is to replace an empty mind with an open one. - Malcolm S. Forbes
• The roots of education are bitter, but the fruit is sweet. - Aristotle
• Education is the key to unlocking the golden door of freedom. - George Washington Carver
• An investment in knowledge pays the best interest. - Benjamin Franklin
• Education is not preparation for life; education is life itself. - John Dewey
• The more you learn, the more you earn. - Warren Buffett
• Education is the foundation of all we do in life. It shapes who we are and what we aspire to be. - Julie Payette
• Learning is a treasure that will follow its owner everywhere. - Chinese Proverb
• Education is the foundation upon which we build our future. - Christine Gregoire
• Knowledge is power. Information is liberating. Education is the premise of progress in every society and family. - Kofi Annan
• Education breeds confidence. Confidence breeds hope. Hope breeds peace. - Confucius
• Education is the most powerful weapon you can use to change the world for the better. - Marian Wright Edelman
• Give a man a fish, and you feed him for a day; teach him to fish and feed him for a lifetime. - Maimonides
• The purpose of education is to turn mirrors into windows. - Sydney J. Harris

150 cheating captions for Instagram to aid your healing process

You can send a PhD graduate a funny quote as a congratulations message . They will appreciate your sense of humor if you are close to that person. Below are some funny PhD completion quotes you can send the graduate:

• Congratulations on your graduation. I learned never to ask a man his salary, a woman her age, or a PhD student when they will finish their dissertation.
• Et Al must be the world's best scientist. His name was all over your dissertation papers. Congratulations on your PhD.
• Congratulations on your graduation, my friend. Why did our physics professor break up with the biology professor? There was no chemistry.
• Congratulations, brother. You are now Dr. Awkward. How did you make it to the graduation list after writing a dissertation on nerds who love palindromes?
• Congratulations, my naughty friend. I almost went nuts when your dissertation missed an appendix at the last minute. I hope you still have one in your abdomen.
• Congratulations, my friend. I remember you complaining about findings being the most challenging part of the dissertation. Well, that's because you had too many of them. Were you flexing your intelligence?
• Congratulations on your graduation, dear. Here is a nice joke: How many PhD students does it take to change a light bulb? Only one, but it takes them three years to do it.
• Congratulations on your PhD. I remember you telling me that the last stretch of my dissertation was like my newborn baby. True to your words, it kept me up for long hours, and the papers weighed the same pounds as a newborn baby.

Congratulations for passing exams: Best quotes and messages

You can tell the person, "Well done, future doctor. I wish you more success and prosperity in the days to come. You're a true inspiration, and I couldn't be happier for you."

You can tell the professor, "A salute to your new success! I wish you all the best in your future endeavors and hope you succeed more after your PhD."

You can tell the PhD graduate, "A PhD is an excellent success for you and your family. Now, you can soar higher than ever."

You can say, "I couldn't think of someone more determined to get a PhD than you. You will surely nail it! All the best on your postgraduate degree journey. XO."

100+ aesthetic Twitter bio ideas to copy an paste on your page

You can tell the person, "Accomplished people rarely sit back and let things happen to them. They go out and make things happen. I know you got this! Best wishes on your PhD journey."

You can tell a PhD holder, "We take great pride in your progress and have faith in your future. Congratulations on achieving this milestone."

You can write, "A doctorate comes with much respect from everybody, the respect you have rightfully earned. Congratulations!"

Instead of saying congratulations, you can tell the person:

• I'm overjoyed to hear your wonderful news.
• Nice job. We're proud of you.
• This calls for a celebration.
• We're so happy for you.
• I knew you could do it.
• Sending you heartfelt congratulations.
• Wishing you the warmest congratulations on your recent achievement.

50+ best marine girlfriend's quotes for military couples

PhD congratulations messages, wishes, and quotes are excellent ways to make someone who just got a doctorate feel happy. So, send them lovely congratulations messages to brighten their graduation day.

Tuko.co.ke published a list of inspiring WhatsApp statuses . Motivating words contain messages of hope and encouragement. They are meant to encourage you or someone else to become better.

WhatsApp status is a popular way to share temporary updates with friends and close contacts. So, motivate them with as many statuses as you like.

Source: TUKO.co.ke

Gladys Mokeira Obiero (Lifestyle writer) Gladys is a content creator who has worked with Tuko since 2018, where she won the Best Writer Award in 2022. She previously held other positions, including an editing role at Kami.com.ph, Yen.com.gh, and Legit.ng. She graduated from the University of Nairobi with a Bachelor’s Degree in Project Planning and Management. In 2023, Gladys finished the AFP course on Digital Investigation Techniques. Email: [email protected]

Poetic Messages – We Made Words Sound So Poetic!

• CONGRATULATIONS
• SCHOLARSHIPS

Header$type=social_icons

Congratulation wishes, samples, and messages for doctorate or phd awards.

These congratulations wishes, samples, and messages for a doctorate or PhD awards are best wishes for the award of a doctorate or PhD degree.

Explore More

/fa-fire/ latest trending$type=list.

MOVIES$type=slider$snippet=hide$cate=0

Relationship$type=sticky$count=4$cate=1$icon=1.

• Relationship

MOTIVATION$type=complex$count=4

Quotes$type=carousel, prayers$type=three$author=hide$comment=hide$rm=hide, videos$type=two$h=0$meta=0$rm=0$snip=0, insurance$type=blogging$cate=2$count=4, meditation$type=one$count=3, congratulation$type=left$va=0$count=3.

• Congratulation

ANNIVERSARY$type=right$va=0$count=3

• Anniversary

/fa-clock-o/ Week Trending$type=list

/fa-fire/ Most Popular$type=list

Mix Reactions

Most viewed, scholarships$type=blogging$cate=2$count=4.

• Scholarships

CATEGORIES$type=blogging$cate=2$count=5

Search Poetic Messages

Congratulations Messages For Doctorate or PHD Degree

A PhD or Doctorate is the highest form of education that anyone can get. This is not just a degree. It’s one of the sweetest fruit that anyone in the field of education gets after years and years of hard work. Perseverance is the key here. It shows how persistent you are. All your life you are going to be highly respected and recognized for your achievement and your degree. Congratulations on getting your PhD/Doctorate degree. Finally, all your years of hard work and turmoil have paid off. You will now be called Dr. <Your Name> and that is a great deal of respect. Congratulate your relative/friend with us on getting their Doctorate/PhD degree.

Congratulations Messages For Doctorate or PhD Degree

You have never been prideful but modest in your achievements. I am so proud of you, my son. Many congrats for your PHD degree.

Years of hard work and dedication has finally resulted into the biggest fruit you have ever wanted son. Many congratulations for your PHD degree.

Congratulation on the degree, my fiancé. I wish you all the love and success in life ahead!

You were always the most dedicated and disciplined student I have ever come across. Many congratulations on your degree.

I am so happy my best friend that your years of hard work has finally paid off in the best way possible. Best wishes on your PHD degree.

You have made us proud everyday with everything you have achieved so far. It’s a pleasure to have a daughter like you. Congrats on your success!

Well done, Doctor. I wish you more success and prosperity in days to come.

I wish that all the goals that you have set become more attainable now since the biggest dream of your life has already come true. Best wishes on your achievements .

Perseverance is that one key that has landed you to such a remarkable position of attaining your PHD degree. Many congrats.

I wish you all the best for all your future endeavors and that you achieve all the more success after your PHD.

Congratulations Dr. Nerd on your success. We always knew that you are going to make it to the top.

We always knew the wonderful person you are behind your geeky glasses. I am so happy you made it to the top. Many congrats on your PHD degree.

Success was always obliged to come before you. With the right attitude and determination of all those years.

A hearty Congratulations for getting the “Doctor” title finally. Kudos to the hard work you put in!

Hard work always pays off! A quote has proven true by you today “Doctor”.

You are truly inspirational. The hard work and efforts you put into your endeavors is beyond excellent. Congratulations on another success to you!

A Doctorate degree comes with a great deal of respect from one everybody, the respect that you can rightfully earned. Congratulations!

It’s a success for everyone who supported you in your days of hard work. So congratulations to you and your family and friends!

It’s probably the best day of your life. Celebrate with a bash “Doctor”. You’ve proved yourself worthy of the title.

Successful people get results by not using excuses for explaining their failures. You’ve a living proof of the same “Doctor”.

This is just the beginning. Your flight of success has taken off and guess what? You’re the pilot. You’re going to take yourself to places!

Being honored with he highest degree is an honor in itself. Congratulations Doctor on your success!

People just see the results, but not the hard work, sleepless, anxiety-full nights that you must have put in. Yet you walked on the journey. Congratulations to your hard work and zeal for success!

Your success begins when you start believing in it. I had heard of this a while back and all I could think of was how you always believed in your dream and today you have achieved it. Congratulations!

Congratulations Doctor. Your motivation and optimism is an inspiration to many. Stay the same. Keep flying and attaining greater heights!

• WordPress.org
• Documentation
• Learn WordPress
• Members Newsfeed

Congratulations Messages for Ph.D. or Doctorate Degree

• Uncategorized

Ph.D. Congratulations Message : A Ph.D. degree is a significant step toward a brighter future. Congratulate them on earning their doctorate and becoming a doctor of their own choosing. Send them warm congratulations while acknowledging their difficulties and sacrifices. Thank your brother, sister, husband, wife, son, daughter, teacher, friends, or other loved ones for earning their doctorate degree and make them feel proud of themselves. Obtaining a doctorate degree is a tremendous accomplishment, so express your gratitude by congratulating them!

Ph.D. Congratulations Message

Congratulations on your doctorate. I’ve seen you working hard day and night, and now your efforts have paid off handsomely; I’m proud of you.

You left no stone unturned during these years, and I want you to know that I am extremely proud of you. Congratulations on your Ph.D.

Congratulations on your hard-won Doctorate! I hope this serves as a launching pad for your future ventures!

Congratulations on finishing your Ph.D. and making us all proud. You’ve always been so dedicated, and I’m sure it’s very inspiring.

You never took pride in your accomplishments, but now is the time to do so. You nailed it and outperformed us all. I’m very proud of you, mate.

Years of hard work and endurance have finally resulted in this prestigious achievement! Congratulations, Dr.

Congratulations on achieving this Ph.D. degree and shining brightly. Your efforts appear to have paid off. My dear brother, I am so proud of you.

My heartfelt congratulations on completing your studies and earning your degree. I am pleased to call you my sister.

Your dream of having a doctorate degree to your name has finally come true. I’ve never been more proud of myself than I am today. I adore you so much.

Dear Son, heartfelt congratulations on obtaining a Ph.D. God bless you always. I adore you.

Congratulations on receiving your doctorate. Thank you for leading by example, teacher. Many congratulations on your extraordinary success.

Congratulations on your Ph.D. completion! Your perseverance and compassion are truly inspiring!

Congratulations on your outstanding achievement! I admire your perseverance and hard work!

I am proud of you for completing your doctorate. May God also help you to realize your other goals. I adore you.

This doctorate degree guarantees a prosperous future for you! Mr. Doctor, you now have wings and can fly high. Congratulations!

It gives me great pleasure and honor to hear that your efforts have finally paid off with this Ph.D. degree.

Congratulations on completing your Ph.D. I’m very proud of you.

I am overjoyed to hear about your tremendous success! Congratulations! Your accomplishment is outstanding!

I extend my heartfelt congratulations on your continued success. Many happy returns of the day, and congratulations on completing your Ph.D.

Ph.D. Congratulations Card Messages

You nailed it, Finally! Congratulations, Doctor, on your well-earned doctorate.

Congratulations on completing your Ph.D.! I hope all of your struggles have been worthwhile and that you can now soar higher than ever. Best regards for the future.

Congratulations on earning your doctorate. Now that you’ve reached this milestone, I hope you find happiness and fulfillment in your life as well.

You have once again demonstrated your dedication and fortitude. Congratulations on your Ph.D.! I am overjoyed for your success.

Dear sister, you have truly demonstrated your self-dedication and perseverance. May God bless you with all of the success that awaits you. Congratulations on your doctorate.

Thank you for demonstrating once again how strong and dedicated you are to achieving your goals. I adore you, my son. Congratulations on your graduation.

Congratulations on your tremendous success. Your perseverance and hard work have finally paid off, and you now hold a doctorate degree in your hands. I adore you so much.

Thank you for keeping our heads held high and completing the Ph.D. I am extremely proud of you for your courage and dedication in earning this.

Your long-held ambition of earning a Ph.D. has finally come true. Congratulations on your accomplishment. You’ve inspired all of us to dream big and work hard to make them a reality.

Congratulations Message for Doctor Degree

Congratulations on receiving your doctorate! This is undoubtedly one of many accomplishments to come!

Congratulations on receiving your doctorate! Your perseverance has paid off, and you have reached the pinnacle of your academic career! Best wishes for the future!

Congratulations! You have shown the world that with hard work, any dream can be achieved!

Congratulations on receiving your doctorate! You consistently live up to your reputation and make us proud!

Success comes to those who have worked tirelessly to achieve it. Congratulations and best wishes!

Congratulations on earning your Doctorate! Your perseverance, patience, and hard work were bound to pay off! This accomplishment makes us very happy!

Congratulations, Dr. With your performance, you have earned this title! Best wishes!

Congratulations on receiving your doctorate! Your incredible dedication and hard work have amazed us!

Funny Ph.D. Wishes

Congratulations on your doctorate! I’m sure your body is running on more coffee than blood by now!

Congratulations! I’m glad you got your doctorate before going completely bald!

Life cannot knock you down if you have survived pursuing a Ph.D.! Congratulations!

Congratulations on your Ph.D. completion! Allow your brain some time to relax to avoid short-circuiting!

Congratulations! After earning your degree, it’s time to interact with the outside world.

Regardless of the fact that you are now a doctor, do not perform CPR! Congratulations!

Best Wishes and Proud Messages

Congratulations on your Ph.D.! Your achievement reflects your burning passion!

Congratulations on completing your Ph.D.! May this achievement inspire you to thrive even more in the future! My best wishes are with you!

Congratulations on your well-earned doctorate! May you do great things for the world!

Congratulations on your doctorate! Best wishes for your future successes and endeavors!

This goal was not easy to achieve, but you never gave up. Best wishes and congratulations!

Congratulations on your doctorate! We have been impressed by your outstanding academic performance throughout the journey.

We are overjoyed to learn about your academic achievements! Congratulations on your doctorate! You have made us the proudest ever!

Your achievements never cease to astound us! Congratulations on completing your Ph.D. successfully!

A doctorate degree is not easy to obtain. To obtain this, one must make significant sacrifices. After all the hardship, the person who obtains a Ph.D. deserves to be praised wholeheartedly. Sending congratulatory messages with your warm and enthusiastic words will brighten the situation. A Ph.D. or Doctorate is the highest level of education that anyone can obtain, and it is more than just a degree. Allow him/her to enjoy the moment of achieving the hard-earned doctorate degree, as it will bring a new perspective into one’s life. Send them some heartfelt Ph.D. congratulations to make them feel good about themselves, as such a degree should be celebrated without a doubt. Years of hard work have culminated in such an accomplishment, which deserves to be celebrated. Let us wish them a sunny day, a pocket full of dreams, and congratulate them with encouraging words sincerely.

Related Articles

PostsExplodiac slot: Better Methods for To experience Real money Slots that have…

ContentHur Massa Kostnadsfri Free Spins List Mi Lite?Fördelar Tillsammans Free Spins Utan…

ContentSign Up & Get Rewardup To D490,000,000 - Caca Niqueis Slot MachineAcercade…

Pedagogue is a social media network where educators can learn and grow. It's a safe space where they can share advice, strategies, tools, hacks, resources, etc., and work together to improve their teaching skills and the academic performance of the students in their charge.

If you want to collaborate with educators from around the globe, facilitate remote learning, etc., sign up for a free account today and start making connections.

Pedagogue is Free Now, and Free Forever!

• New? Start Here
• Frequently Asked Questions
• Privacy Policy
• Terms of Service
• Registration

Don't you have an account? Register Now! it's really simple and you can start enjoying all the benefits!

We just sent you an Email. Please Open it up to activate your account.

I allow this website to collect and store submitted data.

Congratulation Messages and Wishes for Doctorate/ PHD

A thoughtful Doctorate or PhD congratulation message can really mean a lot to someone who has successfully and proficiently completed and graduated  his/her doctorate /PhD’s. Here you will find an excellent collection of congratulation messages for doctorate and PhD graduates which can be easily used to congratulate your friends or relatives on their completion of Doctorate or PHD. 

So stop searching as you have reached the right spot. I am sure you will find the perfect congratulation messages for doctorate or PhD right here. 

1) Congratulations for successfully completing your education and most importantly along with degree of PhD! Indeed you should consider this as one of your greatest achievement in life. I wish and I pray that you may you find real happiness and satisfaction as well, as you start making a new life. God bless you more!

2) Your amazing perseverance as well as your dedication has at last paid off! Accept my warmest though of congratulation!  I know that you can do it because ever since you have started studying I always believe in you. So, how about a party for that?

3) I am so delighted to know that you have already attained to reach what you ever wanted. You truly have proved your self-dedication and perseverance. I want to personally congratulate you for being such a huge success and setting a good example for other teens. All the best for your new life! Cheers!

4) It was great pleasure to hear that you have gained your PhD degree after all those years of hard works and hardships in school.  Remember your study cases and thesis? All now has been paid off! Congratulations! Let me say that your 100% self-dedication and perseverance has indeed brought you in this big success! I’m so proud of you!

5) My heartiest and warmest greetings and congratulations for making it until the end! You’ve just proved to us how strong and dedicated you are in achieving such success in life. Congratulations my dear friend and I’m sure that you are going to embrace numerous of beautiful opportunities out there. God bless!

6) Congratulations! You now got your PhD and that will be perfect for you as you shine. It really does reflect that “hard works and 100% dedication will pay you off in the near future. Now that your dreams and ambitions just came true, I wish and I simply pray that you will be the best person in whatever you do, whatever career you will choose. Congratulations! Cheers!

7) Hi friend! I just heard the good news and wow! I just can’t believe it that you now have a doctorate degree! I know from the beginning that you are the one! Moreover, I would also like to thank you for being such a good role model for our youngsters nowadays. Keep up the good work! God bless! 

If you can't find the right words, a funny E-Card is always a hit.  JibJab  is a great site that allows you to create personalized cards. You can use your graduate's picture to put them in hilarious situations.

Hope you liked reading this list of congratulations messages and wishes for Doctorate/ PHD. So what are you waiting for, choose the message which you like the best and use it to convey your congratulatory wishes and greetings to congratulate your friends or relatives on their completion of Doctorate of PHD.  

Funny Good Morning Messages – Funny SMS for loved ones

Women’s day greeting cards: 180+ templates for march 8 messages and…, 200 sad messages of disappointment in life, love and longing, the warmest messages, wishes and christmas cards, 200 good morning love messages and texts for couples, where to watch jurassic world dominion, things we want to see in a dexter prequel, where to watch pretty woman, the most powerful characters in ant-man and the wasp: quantumania, top things we’d like to see in ant-man 4, teamwork quotes to inspire collaboration, peace quotes to inspire tranquility in life, mother teresa quotes and sayings, money quotes about financial freedom, personal finance, and investing, godfather quotes & dialogues filled with life lessons, memorable band names ideas that’ll kick-start your success, graduation texts to write in a graduation card, best funny usernames—cool, clever usernames, deep questions to ask a guy or girl, coolest last names to give your book, top fall runway shows, top men’s trends from spring, fashion trend: rainbow brights for summer, top trends from luxury bridal fashion week fall, the best slouchy bags that exude laid-back style, the dark side of a libra man, does the libra man cheat signs he may be, how to make a sagittarius man miss you, ignoring sagittarius man: is it ever a good idea, how to make a sagittarius man jealous, how to pull off the best red lipstick for the holidays…, the biggest celebrity hair transformations this year, y2k-inspired holiday makeup looks from marcelo gutierrez, french-girl makeup tricks to steal from the emily in paris set, skin-care trends that will dominate this year, best new products you need to know about, tools to make free business cards, top home business opportunities, how to start a subscription business, small business accounting: how to manage your own books, indiana diet lose 9 kg in 7 days without much effort…, egg weight loss diet: minus 5 kilograms in 7 days, danish diet – lose 10 kg in 2 weeks 13 day…, holoprotein diet menu: castaldo’s 21-day diet, weight loss exercises at home, effective and easy, top 157 birthday gift ideas for men, birthday gift ideas, march 8 gift ideas: choose the perfect gift for your girlfriend, gift ideas for godparents at a wedding or baptism, march 8 gift ideas for women, 300 beautiful and christian christmas and new year wishes in different…, good morning good morning at a coffee shop, march 8 wishes for women’s day for ladies and gentlemen, birthday wishes for men, 150 beautiful and funny birthday wishes for husband, declarations of love: funny, excited and longing, declarations of love for him – 50+ examples (long and short), 11 answers to the most wanted question: what is love, 13 reasons why a man who likes you ignores you and…, learn how to kiss with these 5 methods, 11 types of…, congratulations messages for phd or doctorate degree.

Congratulations Messages for Doctorate or PhD Degree 

When someone has put in the hard work to earn a Doctorate or PhD degree, it is always a momentous occasion to be celebrated. Achieving a PhD or Doctorate level of education is no small feat, requiring years of dedication and sacrifice along the way. That’s why it’s so important to show your support and make them feel appreciated by offering a sincere congratulations to them for all of their hard work and dedication.

Here are some meaningful congratulations messages to help make the occasion more special for the person that you’re honoring.

Sending Congratulations for a Doctorate or PhD 

No matter if it’s your son, daughter, or a close friend or colleague, it can be difficult to know what to say to offer them a heartfelt congratulations for their achievement. Here are some meaningful messages that you can use to personalize your congratulations for their doctorate or PhD.

• Heartiest congratulations on your well-deserved Doctorate or PhD! You have worked tirelessly to achieve this incredible academic level and I’m so proud of everything you accomplished. 

• Congratulations on your momentous achievement! You have reached an amazing milestone and have much to be proud of. 

• You have done a tremendous job on earning your Doctorate or PhD. Best wishes as you enter this new journey and take on an expert level of knowledge in your field. 

• I’m wishing you all the happiness and success that comes with the incredible doctorate or PhD you have earned. Congratulations! 

• Amazing achievement on your Doctorate or PhD! You have surpassed your goals and I celebrate with you in honor of this impressive accomplishment. 

• Congratulations for earning your Doctorate or PhD! You have opened the door to so many amazing career opportunities and I can’t wait to see all the great things you do in the future. 

• Wishing you a lifetime of joy and success on your Doctorate or PhD! You are incredibly smart and dedicated, and you deserve to be celebrated for your hard work.

Congratulation Messages in Different Languages 

Sometimes, you may want to offer your congratulations in a different language, to give it an added sense of specialness. Here are some congratulatory sayings in several languages that you can use to express your admiration and joy.

• French: Félicitations pour votre doctorat ou votre doctorat! Vous avez travaillé d’arrache-pied pour atteindre ce niveau académique incroyable et je suis si fier de tout ce que vous avez accompli. 

• Spanish: ¡Felicitaciones por tu doctorado o doctorado! Has logrado un hito increíble y tienes mucho de qué estar orgulloso. 

• Italian: Congratulazioni per il tuo dottorato di ricerca o dottorato! Sei arrivato a un livello di istruzione impressionante e lo ammiro molto.

 • German: Herzlichste Glückwünsche zu Ihrem verdienten Doktortitel oder Doktorgrad! Du hast unermüdlich daran gearbeitet, dieses unglaubliche akademische Niveau zu erreichen und ich bin so stolz auf alles, was du erreicht hast. 

• Greek: Συγχαρητήρια για τον διδακτορικό σας τίτλο ή το διδακτόριο σας! Έχεις επιτευχθεί ένα τεράστιο επίτευγμα και έχεις πολλά για να νιώσεις ικανοποιημένος.

Including Unique Congratulatory Gifts 

Words of congratulations are always nice to receive, but gifts to commemorate the occasion are even better. Here are some unique congratulatory gift ideas to express your admiration for the person who just achieved their remarkable doctorate or PhD:

• Personal Papers: A fun way to honor the accomplishment is to surprise the lucky recipient with a set of personalized papers printed with their name and the relevant degree. It’s a great way to create a tangible reminder of the achievement. 

• Luxury Stationery: Writing paper and stationery with the doctorate or PhD degree can be a classy way to mark the special occasion. Pick out a set in luxurious and substantial material that can be used for formal correspondence for years to come. 

• Collectible Silver : If you’re looking for a luxe congratulatory gift, a collectible silver piece is a fitting option. Pick a silver accent piece in a professionally designed motif that can be treasured for a lifetime. 

• Academic Keepsakes: There’s a variety of keepsake gifts that feature meaningful designs celebrating the special achievement. Look for a journal, diploma box, or a decorative plaque that serve as a testament to the hard work that was put in to earn the doctorate or PhD.

Celebrating Success with a Gathering

Another way to celebrate the graduate’s hard-earned accomplishment is with a gathering. Invite family and friends to show their support and honor the latest addition to the PhD or Doctorate degree club with a special gathering. Here are some ideas to include in your celebratory event:

• Hold a themed dinner: Celebrate the accomplishment with a dinner party in honor of the graduate. Turning it into a themed dinner party allows everyone to dress up and make the event a bit fancier. Have themed decorations, to make the dinner conversation even more enjoyable. 

• Add a cake: Whether it’s a sheet cake or a pre-made tiered option, adding a cake makes the occasion even more special. Look for a cake decorated with a unique design or edible letters spelling out “Congratulations Doctorate or PhD”. 

• Create a photo wall: Have a designated area in the room to display photos of the special graduate. It’s a great way to help everyone remember all those special moments leading up to the momentous occasion. 

• Show a video: Assemble a memorable video for the special day, full of well wishes from family, friends, and mentors. Use it as a way to end the evening and give everyone one last reminder of the special achievement.

Celebrating someone’s hard-earned PhD or Doctorate degree should be a momentous occasion. For the special people in your life who have just achieved this incredible academic level, offer meaningful congratulations and a luxurious gift. If you’re able, throw a special gathering to show your admiration and appreciation for all their hard work. Congratulations!

RELATED ARTICLES MORE FROM AUTHOR

Women’s day greeting cards: 180+ templates for march 8 messages and greeting cards, latest news, women’s day greeting cards: 180+ templates for march 8 messages and..., top 300 short and good status of happy and hard life, painful parting messages for him and her, christian messages of encouragement, optimistic texts in hard times, the shortest, longest and funnyest happy birthday messages for the beloved, 150 most beautiful good morning messages monday, editor picks, popular posts, funny, beautiful, long and short happy birthday messages for adults, wise and true status about life, the most beautiful happy birthday messages for your loved ones, popular category.

• Messages 484
• Business 70
• Trending 62

• SCHOLARSHIPS
• Jobs in Kenya
• Jobs in Nigeria
• Jobs in South Africa
• Jobs in Ghana
• COMPETITIONS
• Internships
• Learnerships
• SCHOOL GISTS

Home » Blog » PhD Congratulations Messages & Quotes For Graduation & Card 2024

PhD Congratulations Messages & Quotes For Graduation & Card 2024

Do you have a friend or relative who has just graduated with a PhD degree and you would love to give him/her a mind-blowing congratulations message and quotes? If yes, then this informative article is for you.

A short congratulation for a Ph.D. graduate will only take a few minutes of your time. Compose a sweet message, reminding them of how hardworking they are and wishing them the best. The sky is the limit for many, and if your friend or family attained that honour under challenging circumstances, your message would be an encouragement for many not to give up.

PhD Congratulations Messages And Quotes

Earning a PhD degree is a big stepping stone towards a brighter future. Congratulate them for achieving the doctorate and becoming a doctor. Here are some of the best messages and quotes:

Sweet PhD Congratulations Messages

Your brother, sister, son, daughter, or friend deserves hearty congratulations for your PhD message to achieve your doctorate. You have probably shared their journey as they studied and researched, and it is only fair that you be by their side when they are graduating. Tell them congratulations, doctor, and recognize the effort they put into earning the doctorate.

• After all the hard work you put in, you sure deserve what you have. Congratulations on your PhD bestie.
• You nailed it! Congratulations, doctor, on your hard-earned doctoral degree.
• Congratulations to you on becoming a PhD holder! I hope all the struggles are worth it.
• This is a great success for you and your family. Now you can soar higher than ever.
• Best wishes for the future. Your PhD is only one of the many goals that you are set to achieve.
• You have proved again how dedicated and strong-willed you are. Congratulations on your new target, doc.
• Evidently, the years of hard work and dedication have finally resulted in the most significant fruit you have ever wanted, baby. Many congratulations on your degree.
• Congratulations on the degree, my son. I wish you all the love and success in life ahead!
• I am so happy, my best friend, that your years of hard work have finally paid off in the best way possible. Best wishes on your PhD degree.
• You have made us proud every day with everything you have achieved so far. It’s a pleasure to have a daughter like you. Congrats on your great success!
• Well done, doctor. I wish you more success and prosperity in the days to come.
• I wish that all the goals that you have set become more attainable, especially now that the biggest dream of your life has already come true. Best wishes for your achievements!
• You have proven to many that all things are possible despite one’s circumstances.
• I wish you the best in your future endeavors. The doctorate is only one among many wins.
• Congratulations sister! Being the first in the family to earn a PhD is sure a one-of-a-kind achievement.
• Thank you for proving once again how strong and dedicated you are when it comes to achieving your goals. Congratulations on your doctorate.
• I love you so much, mom. Congratulations on your degree. I, too, wish to achieve half of what you have achieved.
• Congratulations on achieving your doctorate. Please receive our warm greetings as a family.
• Now that you have completed such a milestone, I pray you find happiness and satisfaction in life as well.
• We always knew the wonderful person you are behind your geeky glasses. I am so happy you made it to the top. Many congrats on your PhD degree!
• Success was always obliged to come before you. With the right attitude and determination of all those years!
• A hearty congratulations for getting the doctor title finally. Kudos to the hard work you put in!
• Hard work always pays off! A quote has proven true by you today, doctor.
• You are truly inspirational. The hard work and efforts you put into your endeavors are beyond excellent. Congratulations on another success to you!
• A doctorate comes with a great deal of respect from everybody, the respect you have rightfully earned. Congratulations!
• It’s a success for everyone who supported you in your days of hard work. Congratulations to you and your family and friends!
• Who would have thought that you would have a PhD at such a young age? Congratulations on such a significant success.
• Congratulations on your PhD baby. Your hardship and efforts have finally paid you off with a doctorate in your hand.
• Seeing you burn the midnight oil to complete your work while being a wholesome mother was fulfilling. Love you so much.
• You have never been prideful but modest in your achievements. I am so proud of you, my son. Congratulations.
• Many congrats on your PhD degree. Not many have achieved what you have at such a young age.

PhD Graduation Wishes

Sending people cards are one of the oldest ways of saying that you remember your friends and recognize their achievement. Buy that card today and send warm graduation greetings.

• Keeps that sharp brain behind thick glasses ticking with newer ways of making the world more aware. Congratulations and best wishes.
• Best wishes for this important milestone in your life and career. May there be many more to come?
• Congratulations on never losing faith in yourself and always believing in yourself and your research. Good luck.
• Head up, chin up, and always proud to be a girl. See what places your confidence has taken you. So proud of you.
• Congratulations on receiving your hard-earned doctoral degree. Best wishes for the future.
• Many congratulations on this outstanding accomplishment. Not many start and complete their doctorate degrees without giving up.
• I can only imagine how excited you are that you have earned this degree. Congratulations, doc.
• It has been a pleasure watching you successfully present your dissertation. Congratulations on your graduation.
• Good things come to those who wait for them, and you sure have witnessed that. Congratulations, pal!
• Congratulations on the degree, my baby. I wish you all the love and success in life ahead!
• You were always the most dedicated and disciplined student I have ever come across. Congratulations on what you have achieved.
• You are allowed to take a break now. You have worked too hard. Many congratulations on your degree.
• Best wishes on your PhD degree. This is an achievement that everyone is proud of.
• You have made us proud every day with everything you have achieved so far. Please come and celebrate with us as you shine in your gown.
• It’s a pleasure to have a daughter like you. Congrats on your success! You are now a doctor!
• I cannot imagine that my baby is now a doctor. Congratulations on your PhD, son.
• I wish that all the goals that you have set become more attainable now since the biggest dream of your life has already come true. Congrats.
• Please be happy and rejoice in hitting your target. Best wishes for your achievements!
• Perseverance is one key that has landed you in such a remarkable position of attaining your Ph.D. degree. Many congrats!
• Congratulations, my lovely sister. I wish you all the best in all your future endeavors and that you achieve all the more success after your Ph.D.
• Congratulations, Dr. Nerd, on your success. We always knew that you were going to make it to the top.
• Today will always be a special day for you. Congratulations and scale higher heights.
• We always knew the intellectual person you are behind your geeky glasses. Congratulations, doctor!
• I am so happy you made it to the top. Many congrats on your PhD degree! You are a winner.
• You have always been a high achiever since elementary. I am so proud of you, my daughter.
• Success was always obliged to come before you, with the right attitude and determination of all those years.
• I wish society could produce many more like you. You are truly inspirational. Congratulations on your PhD, sir.
• The great hard work and efforts you put into your endeavors are beyond excellent. Congratulations on another success to you!
• A doctorate comes with a great deal of admiration from everybody. You are our hero.
• You have indeed worked for the respect that you have rightfully earned. Congratulations on your doctorate.
• We are grateful to God for the great victory He has bestowed upon you this day. Congratulations.
• It’s a success for everyone who offered you great support in your days of hard work. So, congratulations to you on your achievement.
• We take great pride in the far you have come and we have faith in the far you will go. Congrats on the big milestone you have achieved this day.

Ph.D. congratulations cards and messages are an excellent way of making your friend who just got their doctorate feel happy about what they have. Share that lovely message and brighten their day. You can even throw them a little party to celebrate the day with them. Graduating with a PhD is a milestone for many.

What’s your take on this? We believe this article was helpful, if yes, don’t hesitate to share this information with your friends on Facebook, Twitter, WhatsApp, and other Social Platforms.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Enter your email address below to receive updates each time we publish new content.

Type your email…

Latest on the Desk

• How To Check Lesotho LGCSE Results 2023/2024 (PDF Download)
• Correctional Services Learnership Application Form 2024/2025
• How To Join The Kenya National Youth Service (NYS) 2024/2025
• AIC Kijabe School of Nursing Admission Application Form 2024
• Netcare Paramedic Learnership 2024/2025 Application Form (PDF)
• Masomo Education Foundation Scholarship 2024 for Zambian Citizens
• Mzansi Magic Auditions Application Form 2024/2025
• KDF Recruitment 2024/2025 Application Form Portal
• Ghana Immigration Service Recruitment 2024/2025 Application Form
• GNFS Recruitment 2024/2025 Application Form Portal
• Privacy Policy

Congratulations to Vasant on his PhD defense.

• Post published: July 22, 2024

Congratulations EPM Lab PhD Student Vasant Iyer who successfully defended his PhD on Monday 7/22! Thesis title: “Integrating graphene Hall sensors with co-designed silicon circuits for high-throughput magnetic biosensing.” Best wishes as you continue your work as a postdoctoral fellow at the University of Pennsylvania.

You Might Also Like

Congratulations to Kaisar on his PhD defense.

Congratulations to Mohamad

Congratulations to Mohamad and Farshid for their PhD defense.

Congratulations to MCIP PhD Candidate, Emily Chiem who was awarded an NIH F31 NRSA! Well-deserved! Congratulations also to her faculty mentor, Dr. Mirella Dapretto!

612 Charles E. Young Drive East Box 957246, 328 Hershey Hall Los Angeles, CA 90095-7246

(t) (310) 825-3891 (f) (310) 206-7599

Information

• Academic Calendar

Getting Around

• Maps & Directions
• Campus Shuttles
• Public Transit
• Prospective Students
• Current Students
• Parents & Families
• Media & Journalists

• Education Home
• Medical Education Technology Support
• Graduate Medical Education
• Medical Scientist Training Program
• Public Health Sciences Program
• Continuing Medical Education
• Clinical Performance Education Center
• Center for Excellence in Education
• Research Home
• Biochemistry & Molecular Genetics
• Biomedical Engineering
• Cell Biology
• Genome Sciences
• Microbiology, Immunology, & Cancer Biology (MIC)
• Molecular Physiology & Biological Physics
• Neuroscience
• Pharmacology
• Public Health Sciences
• Office for Research
• Clinical Research
• Clinical Trials Office
• Funding Opportunities
• Grants & Contracts
• Research Faculty Directory
• Cancer Center
• Cardiovascular Research Center
• Carter Immunology Center
• Center for Behavioral Health & Technology
• Center for Brain Immunology & Glia
• Center for Diabetes Technology
• Center for Immunity, Inflammation & Regenerative Medicine
• Center for Membrane & Cell Physiology
• Center for Research in Reproduction
• Myles H. Thaler Center for AIDS & Human Retrovirus Research
• Child Health Research Center (Pediatrics)
• Division of Perceptual Studies
• Research News: The Making of Medicine
• Core Facilities
• Virginia Research Resources Consortium
• Center for Advanced Vision Science
• Charles O. Strickler Transplant Center
• Keck Center for Cellular Imaging
• Institute of Law, Psychiatry & Public Policy
• Translational Health Research Institute of Virginia
• Clinical Home
• Anesthesiology
• Dermatology
• Emergency Medicine
• Family Medicine
• Neurosurgery
• Obstetrics & Gynecology
• Ophthalmology
• Orthopaedic Surgery
• Otolaryngology
• Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation
• Plastic Surgery, Maxillofacial, & Oral Health
• Psychiatry & Neurobehavioral Sciences
• Radiation Oncology
• Radiology & Medical Imaging
• UVA Health: Patient Care
• Diversity Home
• Diversity Overview
• Student Resources
• GME Trainee Resources
• Faculty Resources
• Community Resources

Congratulations to PHS Faculty Promoted & Tenured for 2023-2024!

Congratulations to all of the newly promoted and tenured School of Medicine faculty on their hard work and excellence, which has been recognized by the SOM Promotion and Tenure Committee and the Board of Visitors. In the 2023-2024, there were 38 promotions to Associate Professor, 26 promotions to Professor, and 21 faculty were awarded tenure.

The Office of Faculty Affairs manages all promotion and tenure actions at the School level for both regular cycle actions and expedited reviews. The promotion and tenure process spans 18 months and concludes with the  Board of Visitors approval  of recommended faculty. In-cycle P&T approvals are effective July 1.

For more information:

• Dr. Abbie Salcedo , SOM Director of Faculty Affairs,  [email protected]
• Dr. Robert Nakamoto , SOM Coordinator of Academic Achievement,  [email protected]
• Emily Schneider, MILR, SHRM-CP,  SOM Assistant Director of Faculty Affairs,  [email protected]

Promotions & Tenure in the Department of Public Health Sciences:

Promotions to Associate Professor:

• Kristen Wells
• Melissa Little
• Nathan Sheffield

For the full list of Promotions & Tenure in the School of Medicine, click here .

• Consulting & Collaboration
• Faculty & Administration
• Research Programs, Affiliated Centers & Departments
• Submit PHS News & Events
• instructional
• Uncategorized
• Viewpoints - Guest Blogs
• Viewpoints - Spotlight
• Viewpoints - Week in Review
• Viewpoints: Health Policy Blog

ORIGINAL RESEARCH article

Phd-supervisors experiences during and after the covid-19 pandemic: a case study.

• 1 Department of Education, University of Bergen, Bergen, Norway
• 2 Department of Educational Studies in Teacher Education, Faculty of Education, Inland Norway University of Applied Sciences, Hamar, Norway
• 3 Department of Psychosocial Science, University of Bergen, Bergen, Norway
• 4 Faculty of Arts and Physical Education, Volda University College, Volda, Norway

Introduction: The COVID-19 pandemic has significantly impacted the education sector, and this case study examined nearly three hundred PhD supervisors in Norway. The study was driven by the urgent need to better understand the professional, social, and existential conditions faced by doctoral supervisors during extended societal shutdowns. This explorative case study builds on a former study among PhD candidates and investigates the experiences of doctoral supervisors when remote work, digital teaching, and digital supervision suddenly replaced physical presence in the workplace, largely between March 12, 2020, and autumn 2022, due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

Methods: A mixed-methods research approach, incorporating formative dialog research and case study design, was employed to bridge the conceptual and contextual understanding of this phenomenon. The primary data sources were a survey ( N = 298, 53.7% women, 46.3% men, response rate 80.54%) and semi-structured interviews (with nine PhD supervisors). Supplementary data collection was based on formative dialog research. It included field dialog (four PhD supervision seminars), open survey responses ( n = 1,438), one focus group ( n = 5), an additional survey ( n = 85), and document analysis of PhD policy documents and doctoral supervision seminar evaluations ( n = 7). The survey data, interview data, focus group data, and supplementary data focus also retrospectively on the first year of the pandemic and were collected from August 2022 until October 2023.

Results: The findings from the explorative case study revealed that the PhD supervisors faced numerous challenges during the pandemic, both professionally and personally. For PhD supervisors who extensively worked from home over a long period, the situation created new conditions that affected their job performance. These altered conditions hindered their research capacity, their ability to follow up with their PhD candidates, and their capacity to fulfill other job responsibilities. Although the PhD supervisors received some support during the pandemic, it seems that the incremental measures provided were insufficient.

Discussion: The case study results indicate that it is more important than ever to understand the gap between the formulation, transformation, and realization arenas when distinguishing between incremental, semi-structural changes and fundamental changes in PhD regulations and guidelines brought on by societal crises. This highlights the need for better crisis preparedness at the doctoral level in the years to come.

1 Introduction

Effective doctoral supervision is crucial for guiding PhD candidates through the complexities of their research, ensuring academic rigor and the successful completion of their dissertations ( Bastalich, 2017 ; Wichmann-Hansen, 2021 ; Kálmán et al., 2022 ). The role of PhD supervisors during the pandemic and their impact on educational quality at various levels has been an under-researched area both nationally and internationally ( Börgeson et al., 2021 ; Krumsvik et al., 2022 ). Supervisors who have varying experiences and work under diverse conditions are key players in the transformation arena where central policies are applied at the institutional level. Their interaction with PhD-candidates, whether in-person or remotely, shapes partly the quality of PhD-programs and candidates’ learning experiences. The COVID-19 pandemic has influenced the education sector in numerous ways, and this case study examined nearly three hundred PhD-supervisors in Norway with a Mixed Method Research design and different methods and data. The impetus for the study was the urgent need for a better knowledge base to understand the professional, social, and existential conditions for doctoral supervisors when society is shut down for an extended period. This explorative case study builds on our former study among PhD-candidates ( Krumsvik et al., 2022 ) and investigates the experiences of doctoral supervisors when remote work, digital teaching, and digital supervision suddenly replaced physical presence in the workplace (to varying extents).

First, the introduction contextualizes the study; second, the methodology is described; third, the main part presents the results from the survey part of the study; fourth, the data from the interviews and Supplementary data are presented; fifth, the discussion and conclusion are presented.

International policy documents underline the importance of PhD-supervision [ European University Association (EUA), 2010 , 2015 ] and, in Norway, it is crucial to view PhD supervision considering the specific frame factors for the PhD’s and some general trends of changed frame factors in doctoral education over the last 10 years ( Krumsvik, 2016a , 2017 ). It is therefore important to examine such frame factors in light of PhD-supervisors’ experiences during the pandemic, but the current state of knowledge is still limited around this topic. However, “The United Kingdom Research Supervision Survey Report 2021″ found that among the 3,500 PhD supervisors in the United Kingdom, 65% felt that supervisory responsibilities have increased during the pandemic, 32% agreed that “concerns over supervision have kept me awake at night over the last 12 months” and 31% agreed that “supervising doctoral candidates makes me feel anxious over the last 12 months” ( UK Council for Graduate Education, 2021 ). With these abovementioned issues in mind, this doctoral supervision study builds on our previous research on doctoral-level education ( Krumsvik and Jones, 2016 ; Krumsvik and Røkenes, 2016 ; Krumsvik et al., 2016a , b , 2019 , 2021 ; Krumsvik et al., 2022 ) and aims to examine the experiences of PhD supervisors in Norway during the pandemic to answer the research questions below:

1. To what extent has the COVID-19 pandemic impeded the PhD supervisors’ frame factors on the micro-level, and how do they perceive this situation?

2. To what extent has the COVID-19 pandemic influenced PhD supervisors’ frame factors on the meso-level, and how do they perceive this situation?

3. How do the PhD-supervisors experience the more general aspects of their supervision role during and after the pandemic?

1.1 The Norwegian context

To contextualize the research questions to the Norwegian context, one must remember that doctoral candidates in Norway are not students per se but are employees (on a 3–4 years contract) and more regarded as colleagues than students, and in this sense, the roles are more equal than in traditional supervisory relationships at a lower level (supervisor-student). Both by having PhD fellows being considered highly competent adult employees with state employment contracts, where they receive regular salaries, and have regular offices, they are initially part of the work community found within academia with its routines, duties, and rights. Another contextual aspect is that Norwegian PhD-candidates defend their theses relatively late in their careers. The average age for a candidate’s defense is between 37 and 38 years and higher for many candidates within the humanities and social sciences. In comparison, the median age across OECD countries is 29 ( Sarrico, 2022 , p. 1304). Table 1 provides a generalized comparison of doctoral education across Nordic countries, the UK, and the US ( Andres et al., 2015 ; Burner et al., 2020 ). While such broad overviews might exaggerate differences, they provide a framework for understanding doctoral education on a spectrum. This spectrum ranges from countries with significant government influence, where PhD candidates are employed (e.g., Nordic countries), to countries with moderate government influence, where PhD candidates are not employed (e.g., the UK), and finally to countries with minimal government influence, where PhD candidates are also not employed (e.g., the US). Despite these variations, the global trend indicates that doctoral education is becoming increasingly dependent on external funding ( Bengtsen, 2023 , p. 45).

Table 1 . Overview of the Nordic PhD model in comparison to UK and US models.

In addition, women defend their theses on average 2 years later than men. Taking into account that the average age for first-time mothers in Norway is now 30.1 years, there is a lot that needs to happen within a few years, and this may sometimes affect the feasibility of their PhD-projects. This can, e.g., be related to the gender differences in Norway about parental leave days during the pandemic which is much higher for women than for men at the universities ( Krumsvik et al., 2022 ) 1 . Another contextual factor that distinguishes doctoral supervision from other supervision (at lower levels) is that over 90% of the doctoral theses in Norway are article-based theses ( Krumsvik, 2016b ; Mason and Merga, 2018 ; Solli and Nygaard, 2022 ), which implies 3–4 published articles and an extended summary or synopsis (a “kappe” in Norwegian, ranging between 50 and 90 pages). This means that the PhD-candidates receive “supervision” and feedback from approximately 8–10 referees in scientific journals on their articles, in addition to feedback from their PhD supervisors. Because of this, many PhD-supervisors are co-authoring their doctoral candidates’ publications. A final contextual aspect is the recent studies indicating a decrease in doctoral disputations nationwide in Norway over the past two years ( Steine and Sarpebakken, 2023 ) – probably as a consequence of the pandemic. In a survey, Ramberg and Wendt (2023 , p. 22) found that about 60 percent of PhD candidates and 50 percent of postdoctoral candidates ( N = 300) were delayed during the autumn of 2022. The study showed that illness or leave, often due to caregiving responsibilities during the pandemic, was the most common reason for delays among PhD candidates and postdoctoral candidates, particularly impacting women more than men. Following illness, reduced access to supervisors, empirical data, research facilities, and external partners were significant factors contributing to delays in their research activities. Nearly a third of delayed candidates reported reduced access to supervisors, and about a fifth faced issues with external partner access, highlighting the critical role of these resources in completing research projects. When it comes to the PhD-supervisors, more specifically, the supervision differs from other types of supervision in that a formal PhD agreement is signed with a binding supervisor contract that lasts for 3–4 years (the PhD period) and is signed by both the supervisor and the candidate. The supervisor also has an overarching responsibility to avoid delays and ensure that the PhD program can be completed within the standard time frame. Supervisors are primarily responsible for guiding doctoral candidates on the specific, content-related aspects of their projects. This includes helping candidates identify the knowledge frontier in their field, position their study within the research field, develop clear and consistent research questions, choose appropriate scientific and methodological approaches, and provide expert guidance in discussing results and addressing ethical issues related to the thesis. This obviously places relatively high competence requirements on the supervisors, both in terms of their academic and research skills, and in relation to the doctoral supervision itself, as poor or inadequate supervision at this level can expose the candidate to a certain “drop-out risk” in the project.

Maintaining education quality during the COVID-19 pandemic has been challenging due to the widespread shift to digital teaching, supervision, and remote work. Many university teachers were unaccustomed to the online, digital learning environment, working with PhD candidates remotely for extended periods. Some taught in hybrid settings, with some PhD candidates quarantined at home while others attended in-person classes. Additionally, others navigated ordinary learning contexts with COVID-19 precautions like masks and social distancing. This situation altered frame factors, adding complexity to the discussion of education quality.

Considering this, the case study seeks to understand if, and potentially how, external factors in pedagogical contexts over which institutions, academics, and teachers have no direct control play out. Lindensjö and Lundgren (2014) find that such external factors might have a significant impact on the outcomes of educational training, teaching, and supervision. Therefore, it is crucial to contextualize the pandemic experiences among PhD supervisors with respect to these factors, as they imply national and institutional frames for their PhD supervision. Though there exist several quantitative, survey-based studies on the impact of COVID-19 on PhD supervision (e.g., Pyhältö et al., 2023 ; Löfström et al., 2024 ), there is still a lack of in-depth qualitative understanding of the impact of COVID-19 on the supervisory relationship. The studies of Löfström et al. (2024) and Pyhältö et al. (2023) indicated that supervisors faced significant challenges in identifying when PhD candidates needed assistance and providing adequate support for their well-being during the shift to remote supervision. Supporting the progress and wellbeing of full-time candidates, who were more adversely affected by the pandemic than their part-time peers, became increasingly difficult. The increase in email communications could overwhelm supervisors, exceeding manageable levels and complicating their ability to offer timely and effective feedback. The lack of spontaneous, informal conversation, previously facilitated by in-person meetings, further hindered their ability to monitor and support the candidates effectively. These challenges were particularly pronounced for supervisors in scientific fields requiring lab work and practical training, which were severely disrupted by the pandemic, and supporting the progress and wellbeing of full-time candidates, who were more adversely affected by the pandemic than their part-time peers, became increasingly difficult. Furthermore, supervisors reported that their PhD candidates’ lack of a scholarly community and inadequate supervision were significant challenges. This reflects the supervisors’ view that the availability of a supportive research environment and adequate supervision are critical for candidates’ success ( Pyhältö et al., 2023 ). The study by Pyhältö et al. (2023) also found that supervisors generally estimated the impact on candidates’ progress and well-being to be more negative than the candidates themselves did, which may imply that supervisors have a broader perspective on the long-term consequences of disruptions like the COVID-19 pandemic. Research prior to the pandemic ( Pyhältö et al., 2012 ) has shown that apart from the importance of having clear and long-term financing, proper research facilities, and sufficient time to pursue a PhD, supervisors also stress the significance of PhD candidates’ motivation, self-regulation, efficacy, and engagement as essential personal regulators for success in the PhD process.

1.2 Theoretical framework

This case study is exploratory and intrinsic ( Stake, 1995 , 2006 ), utilizing an abductive approach to theory with frame factor theory as our theoretical framework ( Lundgren, 1999 ; Lindensjö and Lundgren, 2014 ). Frame factor theory suggests that society’s influence on education manifests through a target system, an administrative system, and a legal system. This theory, used in educational sciences and pedagogy, acts as a lens for planning and analysis, positing that external factors, beyond the control of institutions and educators, significantly affect educational outcomes. We will further explain the contextual application of frame factor theory in this case study below.

Previous research highlights a gap in (doctoral) education between the formalization and realization arenas in frame factor theory ( Lindensjö and Lundgren, 2014 ; Krumsvik et al., 2019 ). Linde (2012) introduces a transformation arena between these two, explaining the difficulty of implementing measures in complex organizations like universities. There is rarely a straightforward relationship between central decisions (formulation arena or macro-level) and their implementation (realization arena or micro-level). Policy documents require interpretation and application by faculty leaders, PhD program leaders, supervisors, and PhD candidates (transformation arena or meso-level) ( Linde, 2012 ).

Given this context, a main focus of this case study was to evaluate how Norwegian PhD supervisors managed changed frame factors and education quality during the pandemic. The Norwegian Agency for Quality Assurance in Education (NOKUT) defines education quality as “the quality of teaching classes, other learning facilities, and students’ learning outcomes in terms of knowledge, skills, and general competence” ( Skodvin, 2013 , p. 2). It is important to differentiate between educational quality, study quality, and teaching quality.

Education quality is a broad concept encompassing everything from the subject/study program level to the government’s education policy. In contrast, study quality is narrower, referring specifically to the educational institution ( Skodvin, 2013 , p. 3). Teaching quality goes further to the micro-level, focusing on course quality, teacher effectiveness, and PhD supervision. This study examined how PhD supervisors experienced COVID-19 restrictions at the micro- and meso-levels, considering two of the three levels. Figure 1 illustrates the analytical lenses in this mixed methods research (MMR) and formative dialog research case study:

Figure 1 . The analytical focus in the case study ( Krumsvik et al., 2019 ) is based on the frame factor theory ( Linde, 2012 ; Lindensjö and Lundgren, 2014 ).

2 Methodology

To understand and corroborate conditions faced by doctoral supervisors related to COVID-19 extended societal shutdowns, both in breadth and in depth, we employed a mixed-methods research design, combining quantitative data to show the strength of associations and qualitative data to explore their nature ( Johnson et al., 2007 ; Creswell and Plano Clark, 2017 ). We utilized a three-stage design, QUAL-QUANT-QUAL (qualitative-driven sequential design, Schoonenboom and Johnson, 2017 ), making it a qualitative-dominant mixed-methods study ( Johnson et al., 2007 , p. 124). Using mixed methods research allowed us to explore the complex research problem more comprehensively compared to using either quantitative or qualitative data alone. Though the approach is less common in case studies ( Tight, 2016 , p. 380), the mixed methods are increasingly used (e.g., Ertesvåg et al., 2021 ; Hall and Mansfield, 2023 ; Peters and Fàbregues, 2023 ). Advocates of such approaches consider mixed methods to “complement and extend one another and thus lead to better descriptions, clearer explanations and an enhanced understanding of phenomena, research aims and questions” ( Ertesvåg et al., 2021 , p. 655).

Specifically, an exploratory, sequential mixed-methods design was used to address the research questions ( Fetters et al., 2013 ; Creswell and Plano Clark, 2017 ). This design involves collecting and analyzing qualitative data first (QUAL), using those findings to guide the quantitative data collection and analysis in the second phase (QUANT), and then using the quantitative results to inform further qualitative data collection and analysis in the third phase (QUAL). This method integrates through building, where results from one phase inform the next.

We conducted a cumulative data collection and analysis process ( Creswell and Guetterman, 2021 ), basing survey questions on previously collected data from field dialogues, online observations, seminar evaluations, and document analysis. The questionnaire consisted of a general demographic questions (e.g., gender, educational background and what field(s) the supervisor supervised in), in addition to a range of multiple response items addressing four key themes: (1) important factors to complete a PhD, (2) supervisor challenges, (3) working from home experiences, and (4) perceived need for future competences as supervisors. Finally the questionnaire contained a range of statements measured on a Likert-scale from 1 to 5 where 3 was neutral (e.g., to what extent do you feel that your PhD-candidate(s) are on track with their doctoral project?). The qualitative interview guide ( Kvale and Brinkmann, 2015 ) was developed from the prior quantitative data (survey), and the focus group guide was based on earlier survey and qualitative interview data (see Figure 2 below). We integrated research questions, methods, interpretation, and reporting at various points, using narratives where qualitative and quantitative results are presented in different sections of the same article through the contiguous approach ( Fetters et al., 2013 ). This article primarily examines the coherence between qualitative and quantitative findings based on confirmation , expansion , or discordance ( Fetters et al., 2013 ). The approach used in the study is similar to Hall and Mansfield (2023) and the coherence is derived from joint displays using visual means.

Figure 2 . The research process. The yellow arrows show the main data sources, and the blue arrows show the Supplementary data in this article. In addition, we have conducted focus group interviews and an extra survey, which will be published in another article (since they mainly focus on academic writing with the large language models).

As a consequence of the mixed-methods design, this study combines two approaches in case study research. The first, proposed by Stake (1995 , 2006) and Merriam (2009) and Merriam and Tisdell (2016) , is situated in a social constructivist paradigm, and is attached to the qualitative part (connected to the second part of each research question). The second, based on Eisenhardt (1989) , Flyvbjerg (2011) , and Yin (2012) , approaches the case study from a post-positivist perspective ( Hyett et al., 2014 , p. 1) (connected to the first part of each research question). This intrinsic case study ( Stake, 1995 ) aims to focus on ecological validity:

“Ecological validity is the degree of correspondence between the research conditions and the phenomenon being studied as it occurs naturally or outside of the research setting” ( Gehrke, 2018 , p. 563). Informant selection was based on a purposeful method ( Maxwell, 2013 ), in which we recruited PhD supervisors from Norway.

Next, all interviews were analyzed using reflexive thematic analysis ( Braun and Clarke 2019 , 2021 ) where themes were constructed and presented in this paper (see section 4). In addition, we also conducted a sentiment analysis ( Dake and Gyimah, 2023 ) of the nine interviews (see Supplementary file ).

To answer the research question, we combined formative dialog research ( Baklien, 2004 ) and case study research ( Stake, 2006 ). Data collection consisted of fieldwork (see Supplementary file ), a survey N = 298, 53.7% women, 46.3% men, response rate 80.54%, nine semi-structured interviews (with PhD supervisors), and one focus group ( N = 5). Supplementary data consisted of an additional survey ( N = 85), PhD-policy document analysis ( N = 6), field dialogues (4 PhD supervision seminars), open survey data (1,438 responses), seminar observations ( N = 4), and reviews of relevant documents such as evaluations of doctoral supervisor seminars. We also used policy documents and regulations concerning PhD education in Norway as supplementary sources.

We focused on how PhD supervisors experienced changing frame factors, such as university lockdowns, remote work, digital teaching, digital supervision, doctoral progression, and others, with an emphasis on illuminating the micro-level (course and teaching level) from the PhD supervisors’ perspective. This focus is twofold: the program’s structure and quality directly affected the PhD- supervisors during the pandemic. The second is simply that they conducted several evaluations about matters related to the structure and quality compared with the others. However, PhD- candidates’ opinions are also important, and their views are also interwoven because some of them have been present during field dialogs and participated in the PhD-supervision seminars.

When focusing on how PhD-supervisors experience their supervision, PhD’s research progression, psychosocial aspects, their nearest superior, and the main focus are on illuminating the meso-level (institutional and program level).

2.1 Cumulative research process

In our case study, we brought the experiences and our study among PhD’s ( Krumsvik et al., 2022 ) from the period March 12, 2020, to November 30, 2021, into our design of this study. We executed an excessive cumulative data collection process (including a part during the pandemic) and analysis, especially from August 2022 – October 2023. The relatively long time period allowed the researchers to test their interpretations along the way and detect contrary evidence, e.g., reach saturation during the coding and analysis of the qualitative data ( Creswell and Guetterman, 2021 ).

3.1 Quantitative part (survey)

Above and below are the results of the quantitative part of the study, based on the survey data. This analysis is tentative and covers only the survey results. The interview data and Supplementary data will be presented later in the paper. Two hundred and forty respondents completed the survey ( N = 298, 80.54% response rate). The academic backgrounds of the supervisors were diverse, with the three largest groups coming from natural sciences, humanities, education and teacher training. The largest group of supervisors (41.75%) supervised PhD candidates in education and teacher training (see Table 2 ).

Table 2 . Distribution of supervisors by academic background and PhD supervision in various fields.

A narrow majority (58.08%) of the supervisors had submitted an article-based dissertation (see more in attachment 5 in the Supplementary file ), in the Supplementary file meaning that approximately four out of ten supervisors have not “hands on” experience with article-based thesis as their thesis in their own doctoral degree. A large majority (81.67%) had supervised PhD candidates before and after the pandemic, while 11.67% had only supervised during and after. 41.27% of the supervisors stated that the coronavirus pandemic (from March 12, 2020 - January 2022) had impeded their candidate(s) progress in their doctoral project. 21.12% agreed (to a large or very large extent) that the PhDs’ publication process of articles to scientific journals has been delayed because of the journal’s peer review process during the pandemic (i.e., journal processing times seemed to increase due to several factors including a lack of available peer reviewers because of heavy workloads, health issues, more teaching, etc.).

3.1.1 Challenges in supervision

Results in Table 3 indicate that the most commonly reported challenges faced by supervisors during the pandemic were balancing work and family life and working from home, each affecting more than a third of the supervisors. Psycho-social aspects, such as loneliness, also emerged as a notable challenge. The cancelation of conference participation and stays abroad were significant issues, reflecting the broader impact on professional development opportunities. Concerns about supervision quality were also prominent. Some supervisors reported no challenges, highlighting a degree of variability in experiences. Other challenges included delays in the peer review process for journals, difficulties with publishing, and issues related to research ethics, though these were less commonly reported.

Table 3 . Challenges faced by supervisors during the pandemic in terms of supervision.

3.1.2 Challenges in working from home

Results in Table 4 indicated that supervisors faced multiple challenges while working from home during the pandemic. The most common issue was having little contact with colleagues, which affected more than six in ten supervisors. Supervisors also frequently reported having little contact with their PhD candidates. Distractions from others at home were another prevalent challenge. Many supervisors experienced an increased workload due to digital teaching from home, and lacking office equipment, such as desks and office chairs, was also commonly reported. Psycho-social aspects, such as loneliness, were significant issues as well. The lack of space and increased home responsibilities, such as childcare, were notable challenges. A smaller number of supervisors reported having no challenges at all. Other less commonly reported issues included limited access to library services and poor internet access.

Table 4 . Challenges faced by supervisors during the pandemic working from home.

3.1.3 Factors PhD candidates need to complete their doctorate

We find that there is a high degree of consistency between what supervisors ( Table 5 ) and PhD candidates ( Table 6 ) consider to be the most important factors for completing the doctorate. In particular, it is persistence, resilience, and the ability to work independently are the most important factors, in addition to supervision and co-writing with supervisors.

Table 5 . Most important factors in completing a PhD as reported by PhD supervisors.

Table 6 . Most important factors in completing a PhD as reported by PhD Candidates.

Thus, there is considerable agreement between what the supervisors and the PhD candidates report, which may indicate that within the academic tradition, the doctoral journey is primarily seen as an individual endeavor (feat of strength) where the supervisor is the closest supporter.

3.1.4 Appreciation of supervision

The supervisors mostly agreed that both they and the PhD candidates value supervision. 89.91% responded they agree or strongly agree to this question for themselves, and 92.47% responded they agree or strongly agree on behalf of the PhD candidates. In comparison, 61.25% responded similarly to whether the department values supervision, while 24.17% were neutral, and 14.59% responded they disagree or strongly disagree. This may suggest that the supervisory relationship is primarily between the PhD candidate and the supervisor, with less firm ties to the institution.

When it comes to what extent the supervisors think that their institution has been accommodating regarding compensating the loss of progress due to the coronavirus pandemic for their own PhDs, 27.2% stated that this had been done to a small extent or very small extent and 29.39% stated that this had been done to a large extent or very large extent. 30.1% agreed (large extent and very large extent) that supervisory responsibilities have increased during the pandemic. 13.3% expressed (to a large or very large extent) that supervising doctoral candidates makes them feel anxious’ over the last 24 months” (pandemic), but the majority (64.3%) experienced this to a small and very small extent. 9.3% expressed (to a large and a very large extent) that concerns over doctoral supervision have kept them awake at night over the last 24 months (pandemic), but the majority (69.3%) experienced this to a small and very small extent. 56.1% of the supervisors have not discussed any challenges with the progress of their doctoral candidate(s) project due to the coronavirus pandemic with the department’s human resources manager/head.

When asked how many hours they have enshrined in their working plan per semester as the main supervisor per PhD candidate, supervisors state this varies from zero to above 80 h, but for the majority, it is between 20 and 40 h per semester (40.46%). 23.1% state they do not think that their PhD-candidate(s) are on track with their doctoral project, while 50.2% state that their PhD-candidate(s) are on track with their doctoral project. Some PhDs publish their articles in their thesis based on pre-collected data (e.g., as a part of bigger projects), while others publish their articles in their thesis based on data collections done by themselves. 58.77% of the supervisors think this affects the completion time for the last group of PhDs (large and very large extent). 53.4% of the supervisors have been co-authoring their doctoral candidates’ publications.

3.1.5 What competencies supervisors need

As seen from Table 7 , nearly half of the supervisors believed they needed more pedagogical and methodological competence related to supervision. Additionally, about one-third felt they lacked knowledge about formal aspects, such as guidelines, related to the PhD program. The supervisors reported that the guidelines for the doctoral program were somewhat clear, particularly those for article-based dissertations. This perceived clarity was positively correlated ( r = 0.23, p = 0.002) with the extent to which the institution offered “continuing professional development” (CPD), and 39.88% of the supervisors stated that their institution did not provide supervisors with CPD. Thus, while many supervisors recognized the need for enhanced pedagogical and methodological skills, as well as a better understanding of formal guidelines, the availability of CPD programs was associated with clearer doctoral program guidelines. This suggests that increasing access to professional development opportunities could improve supervisors’ competence and clarity regarding program requirements, ultimately benefiting the supervision process.

Table 7 . Competencies PhD supervisors believe they need to increase.

3.1.6 Female academics with children

About four out of ten supervisors (41.07%) agreed (to a large or very large extent) that female PhDs with children seem to have more home responsibilities than men (e.g., for childcare, household, homeschooling, own children in quarantines, etc.) during the pandemic. About three out of ten (27.77%) agreed (to a large or very large extent) that female PhDs’ (with own children) submission rates to scientific journals have been delayed as a consequence of COVID-19, considering that women seem to have more home responsibilities (e.g., for childcare, household, homeschooling, own children in quarantine, etc.) during the pandemic. About two out of ten (23.64%) agreed (to a large or very large extent) that female supervisors’ (with their own children) submission rates to scientific journals have been delayed as a consequence of COVID-19, considering that women seem to have more home responsibilities (e.g., for childcare, household, homeschooling, own children in quarantine, etc.) during the pandemic.

Cronbach’s alpha ( α = 0.87) indicated a high level of consistency among three statements concerning the increased home responsibilities faced by female researchers with children compared to their male counterparts during the pandemic. These statements highlighted that female researchers with children appeared to bear more responsibilities at home, such as childcare, household tasks, and homeschooling, and as a result, their submission rates to scientific journals had been adversely affected by COVID-19. The average response (mea n = 3.18, standard deviatio n = 0.88) indicated that the supervisors were generally neutral toward these statements. However, closer inspection revealed that female supervisors (mea n = 3.29, standard deviatio n = 0.92) agreed with these statements more than male supervisors (mea n = 3.03, standard deviatio n = 0.79), a difference that was statistically significant ( p = 0.017) but with a small effect size (Cohen’s d = 0.30). There was a positive correlation ( r = 0.23, p = 0.002) between whether the PhD candidate had considered quitting the PhD program and the three statements, which suggests that supervisors who reported that PhD candidates had considered quitting also agreed more with the statements. Conversely, a negative correlation ( r = −0.21, p = 0.002) was found between considering quitting the PhD program and the belief that the institution made sufficient efforts to compensate for the lack of progress during the pandemic, indicating that better institutional support might have reduced the likelihood of candidates considering quitting.

3.2 Qualitative part (interview data and other types of qualitative data)

We conducted a cumulative data collection process where the qualitative interview guide questions were built upon previously collected quantitative data (survey). Based on a snowballing sample ( Patton, 2015 ), we recruited nine doctoral supervisors from the humanities, social-, and educational sciences with diverse experience and approaches to supervising PhD candidates during the pandemic. Using semi-structured interviews ( Brinkmann, 2022 ), each supervisor was interviewed online using Zoom with interviews lasting from 30 to 60 min. All interviews were conducted in Norwegian and later transcribed verbatim. We followed Braun and Clarke’s, (2019 , 2021) approach to reflexive thematic analysis to analyse the interview data. The themes constructed from the analysis of the interview data focus issues, such as “The Impact of the Pandemic on Supervision,” “Home Office Experience,” Workload and Employer Support,” “PhD Candidate Preparation for Article-Based Theses,” “Competence in Supervising Article-Based Theses,” and “Guidelines and Structuring the PhD Process.”

3.2.1 Analyzing the interview with Kyle

Introduction: Kyle, aged 47, specializes in professional ethics. He completed his doctoral degree through a monographic thesis and is relatively new to supervising PhD candidates, currently guiding three, two of whom he is the main supervisor.

Impact of the Pandemic : Kyle wore two hats during the pandemic: as a PhD supervisor and as a leader of a doctoral program. He noted that the pandemic did not significantly impact his supervisees due to well-planned data collection that adapted to digital formats when necessary. His role as the program leader gave him broader insights into how other candidates fared, with some experiencing difficulties in recruiting interviewees and needing to adjust their research plans accordingly.

PhD Supervision During the Pandemic : Kyle’s supervision was largely unaffected by the pandemic as most of it was conducted digitally, catering to students located in different parts of the country. He emphasized the importance of maintaining frequent contact, especially when usual social and professional gatherings were suspended. The pivot to online platforms like Zoom and increased digital communication tools helped maintain the continuity and quality of supervision.

Home Office Experience : Working from home was generally positive for Kyle, who appreciated the reduced distractions and the ability to maintain productivity with a well-equipped home office. However, he missed informal interactions with colleagues, which were hard to replicate through digital means.

Workload and Employer Support : Kyle experienced a slight increase in workload as more effort was required to monitor and support students remotely. His interactions with his Head of Department/direct manager were supportive, helping him navigate the challenges of remote supervision.

PhD Candidate Preparation for Article-Based Theses : Kyle observed that many PhD candidates were unprepared for the intricacies of article writing, including the lengthy processes of submission and peer review. He attributed this to their educational background, which primarily focused on monographic work at the bachelor’s and master’s levels.

Competence in Supervising Article-Based Theses : Although Kyle has not written a synopsis (‘kappe’, i.e., a synthesis chapter for article-based theses) himself, he feels prepared due to his involvement in supervisor training programs that include synopsis writing. He believes in collaborative supervision where co-supervisors with more experience in specific areas can complement his guidance.

Guidelines and Structuring the PhD Process : Kyle praised the clarity of guidelines regarding the synopsis writing at his program, highlighting proactive efforts to discuss and understand these guidelines among candidates and supervisors. He supports the idea of starting the synopsis early in the PhD journey, allowing candidates to develop a clear perspective on how their articles will integrate into their larger thesis narrative.

Summary: Kyle’s approach to PhD supervision during the pandemic was proactive and adapted to the challenges of remote interactions. He emphasizes the importance of clear guidelines, structured support from the academic program, and the benefits of collaborative supervision. His perspective offers valuable insights into managing PhD supervision under crisis conditions and highlights areas for potential improvement in preparing candidates for the demands of article-based theses.

3.2.2 Analyzing the interview with Sally

Introduction: Sally, aged 46, is experienced in the field of educational sciences and professional research, having supervised 15 PhD candidates to completion. She conducted her doctoral research through an article-based thesis.

Impact of the Pandemic on PhD Candidates : Sally observed that the pandemic had a limited impact on most of her PhD candidates, except for 2–3 individuals who experienced delays, partially due to the pandemic. Disputations were delayed for some candidates who preferred physical attendance, affecting their completion timeline.

Adaptations in Supervision Methods: The pandemic made Sally diversify her supervision methods, including more frequent digital meetings with Zoom or Teams and asynchronous communications like email. She shifted from paper-based to digital comments on drafts, which enhanced the efficiency and immediacy of feedback. This change is something she intends to continue using beyond the pandemic.

Home Office Experience: Sally found working from home manageable and returned to the office as soon as feasible, particularly because she needed to balance work with family responsibilities. The transition to the home office did not significantly disrupt her supervision activities, though it introduced minor challenges like occasional distractions from family.

Increased Workload During the Pandemic: Sally reported a slight increase in her workload during the pandemic due to a need for more frequent communication to ensure the continuity and quality of supervision. This was compounded by the timing of her candidates being in critical phases of their thesis work.

Support from Employer: She felt that the focus of her institution’s support during the pandemic was more on ensuring that PhD candidates were well-supported rather than directly supporting the supervisors themselves.

Preparedness of PhD Candidates: Sally noted that while the PhD candidates were generally well-prepared academically, they often lacked specific training in writing article-based theses, a significant adjustment from writing monographic theses typical at the bachelor’s and master’s levels.

Competence in Supervising Article-Based Theses: Sally felt confident in her ability to supervise article-based theses despite recognizing the ongoing need to adapt and learn, particularly in managing the synthesis chapter or “kappen.”

Clarity of Guidelines for the Synopsis: She found the guidelines for writing the synopsis at her institution clear and involved in educational efforts to help candidates understand these guidelines better. However, she questioned whether standardization would improve understanding or unnecessarily restrict academic freedom.

Timing for Writing the Synopsis: Reflecting on her experience and current practices, Sally advocated for thinking about the synopsis early in the doctoral process but cautioned against producing extensive texts prematurely. She emphasized the importance of adapting the scope of the synopsis as the research evolves.

Use of Doctoral Committees’ Guidelines: Sally observed that adherence to guidelines varies depending on whether committee members are national or international, with international members often impressed by the candidate’s ability to publish in high-ranking journals.

Overall, Sally’s experiences and insights provide a nuanced view of PhD supervision during the pandemic, highlighting flexibility, adaptation, and the importance of maintaining high standards of communication and support. Her approach demonstrates a balance between structured guidance and allowing academic independence, aiming to foster resilience and adaptability among her PhD candidates.

3.2.3 Analyzing the interview with Gabbie

Introduction: Gabbie, aged 54, specializes in school and teacher education. She has supervised two PhD candidates to completion and is currently guiding four others. Her doctoral thesis was article-based.

Impact of the Pandemic on PhD Candidates : Gabbie observed varied impacts of the pandemic on her PhD candidates. While two of her students were minimally affected, one faced significant challenges in data collection due to difficulties in recruiting informants. This disparity seems to have been influenced by the candidates’ approaches or perhaps their personal rapport with potential informants.

Changes in Supervision Practices: The pandemic shifted Gabbie’s supervision to entirely online formats using Zoom, Teams, or phone apps. While she was accustomed to digital interaction, the lack of informal, face-to-face interactions led to a more formal and structured supervision style. The spontaneous “corridor conversations” that often enhance relational aspects of supervision were missing, which she felt detracted from the personal connection in the supervisor-supervisee relationship.

Home Office Experience: Gabbie had a positive experience working from home, finding it efficient and beneficial due to eliminating commute times and the conducive environment at home for focused work. Her family setup supported this arrangement well, allowing her to balance work and home life effectively during the pandemic.

Workload Changes During the Pandemic: Her workload in terms of PhD supervision remained roughly the same, though the nature of interactions changed. Instead of impromptu office drop-ins, there were more scheduled meetings, primarily online via Zoom or Teams, which required a different kind of preparation and possibly led to more structured discussions.

Support from Employer: Gabbie noted a lack of specific support for supervisors from her employer during the pandemic; the focus was more on ensuring that she, like other staff, was generally coping with the pandemic’s challenges. There was an emphasis on looking out for the PhD candidates’ well-being, translating into a directive for supervisors to maintain close contact and support.

Preparedness of PhD Candidates for Article-Based Theses: Similar to Kyle and Sally, Gabbie agreed with the survey findings that many candidates are not well-prepared for writing article-based theses. She attributes this to their academic background, which primarily focuses on monograph writing. She advocates for collaborative writing for the first article to help familiarize candidates with the process of scholarly writing and peer review.

Evaluation of Own Competence in Supervising Article-Based Theses: She feels confident in her supervisory skills but acknowledges that continuous learning and discussion with peers are essential for handling complex or unfamiliar issues that arise during supervision. Gabbie appreciates the collaborative nature of the supervisory teams at her institution, which helps in managing any gaps in her experience or knowledge.

Clarity of Guidelines for the Synopsis: Gabbie finds the guidelines for writing the synopsis to be somewhat unclear and open to interpretation, suggesting that more explicit guidelines could help, especially for those new to supervising or external committee members who evaluate the theses.

When to Start Writing the Synopsis : She recommends that PhD candidates consider the synopsis throughout their doctoral journey but compile it towards the end. Gabbie advises keeping a file of potential content for the synopsis from the start of the doctoral process, which can include discarded sections from articles or ideas that do not fit into the articles but are valuable for the overarching thesis narrative.

Overall, Gabbie’s experience reflects a pragmatic and flexible approach to PhD supervision. She adapts to the demands of the pandemic while trying to maintain the quality of academic mentorship. Her strategies for managing remote supervision and her positive attitude toward the enforced changes highlight a successful adaptation to the challenges posed by the pandemic.

3.2.4 Analyzing the interview with Henrik

Introduction: Henrik, aged 46, specializes in school and educational research. He has successfully guided three PhD candidates as a primary supervisor and is supervising four more. His doctoral thesis was a monograph.

Impact of the Pandemic on PhD Candidates: Henrik noted that the pandemic affected his PhD candidates differently based on the nature of their research. Those engaged in classroom interventions faced significant challenges due to pandemic-related restrictions, particularly in accessing schools and conducting fieldwork. Conversely, candidates focused on desk-based research, such as literature reviews, experienced fewer disruptions. One of his candidates, involved in empirical research, had to receive an eight-month extension due to difficulties in data collection, exacerbated by strikes in the secondary education sector.

Changes in Supervision Practices: The transition to online supervision did not significantly affect Henrik, as he was already accustomed to conducting supervision via video conferencing tools like Teams and Zoom. However, he missed the informal, face-to-face interactions that often enrich the supervisory relationship. He noted that the absence of casual corridor conversations led to a more formal and structured online interaction.

Home Office Experience: Henrik found the exclusive home office setup challenging and detrimental to his well-being. He prefers a balance between working at the office and from home. The lack of physical interaction with colleagues and the continuous remote work environment negatively impacted his mental health, requiring him to seek professional health support.

Workload Changes During the Pandemic: Henrik reported that his workload related to PhD supervision did not increase significantly during the pandemic. However, other responsibilities became more demanding, and the overall context of working from home without the usual workplace interactions made certain tasks more difficult.

Support from Employer: There was no specific support provided by his employer concerning his role as a PhD supervisor during the pandemic. Support efforts were more generalized and not tailored to the unique challenges faced by supervisors.

Concerns for PhD Candidates: Henrik was particularly concerned about the mental health of his candidates, noting that the isolation and disruption caused by the pandemic were significant stressors. He proactively discussed these issues with his candidates, acknowledging the challenges faced by those with families and those who were isolated without a support network.

Personal Health Concerns: The pandemic had a substantial impact on Henrik’s mental health, highlighting the importance of considering the well-being of supervisors along with their candidates during such crises.

Effect on Completion Times: Henrik observed that the pandemic inevitably led to delays in the completion times of his PhD candidates, with some requiring extensions. He noted a disparity in how extensions were granted, suggesting a need for more consistent criteria.

Preparation for Article-Based Theses: Henrik believes that most PhD candidates are not well-prepared to write article-based theses, as their previous academic training typically does not include writing journal articles. He spends significant time discussing the publication process with his candidates to demystify it and help them understand the expectations of journal editors and peer reviewers.

Overall Reflection: Henrik’s experience reflects the diverse impacts of the pandemic on different types of research activities and highlights the importance of flexibility and support in PhD supervision. His proactive approach to discussing mental health and the structural changes in supervision practices illustrate adaptive strategies that can be beneficial in navigating future disruptions in academic settings.

3.2.5 Analyzing the interview with Luna

Introduction: Luna, aged 55, specializes in English as an Additional Language didactics. She completed her doctoral degree with an article-based thesis and has supervised a total of 11 PhD candidates, two of whom have completed their dissertations under her primary supervision.

Impact of the Pandemic on PhD Candidates : Luna discussed the varying impacts of the pandemic on her supervisees. One candidate, who was already far along in her research when the pandemic hit, was less affected in terms of supervision but faced uncertainty and stress related to her digital dissertation defense using Zoom. For two new candidates who started during the pandemic, the experience was particularly challenging. They struggled with integrating into the academic community and adapting to remote work, significantly affecting their progress and emotional well-being.

Changes in Supervision Practices : The pandemic required Luna to adapt her supervision methods, emphasizing digital communication tools and frequent check-ins via Teams, Zoom, or phone apps. She noted that these changes allowed for maintaining close communication but shifted many supervision interactions to support coping with the emotional and logistical challenges posed by the pandemic.

Home Office Experience: Luna had a positive experience working from home, which was facilitated by having enough space and a family structure that supported a conducive work environment. She did not face significant challenges balancing work and family life, which helped maintain her productivity and well-being.

Workload Changes During the Pandemic: While her direct supervision workload remained stable, Luna’s role as a researcher education coordinator significantly increased her overall responsibilities. She was deeply involved in supporting a broader range of PhD candidates beyond her direct supervisees, which included mediating between candidates and their supervisors and helping navigate the challenges posed by the pandemic.

Support from Employer: Luna felt well-supported by her employer, particularly in terms of responsiveness to her needs and concerns as she navigated her roles during the pandemic. This support was crucial in managing the increased demands on her time and ensuring the well-being of the candidates for whom she was responsible.

Concerns for PhD Candidates: Luna expressed significant concern for the mental well-being of her candidates, noting that the pandemic exacerbated feelings of isolation and stress. She was particularly worried about those who could not integrate into the academic community or faced severe disruptions in their personal lives.

Personal Health Concerns: Despite managing her workload and maintaining her health, Luna acknowledged the intense pressures of her role during the pandemic, which were compounded by the high demands of her coordinator position.

Effect on Completion Times: Luna observed that the pandemic delayed completion times for many PhD candidates, with extensions being necessary but variably granted. She emphasized the importance of transparent and equitable handling of extension requests to ensure fairness.

Preparation for Article-Based Theses: Luna believes that PhD candidates are generally underprepared for writing article-based theses, attributing this to the educational focus on monographic rather than article-based work before the PhD level. She highlighted the importance of guidance in academic writing and understanding publication processes as essential components of PhD education.

Overall Reflection: Luna’s experience during the pandemic underscores the critical role of adaptability in supervision, the importance of mental health support for PhD candidates, and the need for clear communication and guidelines in managing extended impacts on doctoral education. Her proactive approach to addressing these challenges reflects a comprehensive and empathetic supervision style aimed at supporting candidates through unprecedented times.

3.2.6 Analyzing the interview with Lydia

Introduction: Lydia, aged 52, specializes in educational research, focusing on professional development, assessment, and teacher education. She completed her doctoral degree through a monographic thesis and has supervised three PhD candidates to completion, with six currently under her guidance.

Impact of the Pandemic on PhD Candidates: Lydia noted that the pandemic affected the progress of her PhD candidates, especially those with young children or those who started their projects around the onset of the pandemic. The challenges of remote work and caring for family members led to minor delays in their research timelines.

Changes in Supervision Practices: For candidates who had already started their projects, Lydia managed to continue effective supervision by meeting them on campus when possible. However, starting a supervisory relationship entirely online via Zoom or Teams with new candidates presented difficulties, particularly in building rapport and trust.

Home Office Experience: Lydia found working from home to be somewhat liberating and enjoyed the quiet environment, which contrasted with the often-hectic campus life. Her home setup, which included adult family members who managed their responsibilities independently, provided a conducive environment for work without significant distractions.

Workload Changes During the Pandemic: While the actual supervision tasks did not significantly increase in time, Lydia spent more effort on providing emotional support to her candidates. Discussions often veered from academic topics to personal well-being, reflecting the heightened anxieties and social isolation experienced by the candidates.

Support from Employer : Lydia expressed disappointment with her institution’s lack of direct support during the pandemic. The focus remained on expecting faculty to adapt and manage without specific interventions aimed at easing the transition to remote supervision or addressing the unique challenges posed by the pandemic.

Concerns for PhD Candidates: She was particularly concerned about the psychological well-being of her candidates, as many were navigating difficult life stages compounded by the pandemic. Lydia felt a strong responsibility to reassure them and help them maintain confidence in their ability to progress in their research.

Personal Health Concerns: Lydia did not report significant concerns about her own health, feeling relatively privileged and well-adapted to the circumstances. She maintained a positive outlook, supported by stable family dynamics and the ability to engage in outdoor activities, which helped preserve her mental well-being.

Effect on Completion Times: Acknowledging the inevitable delays caused by the pandemic, Lydia noted that extensions were likely necessary for most PhD candidates during this period. She appreciated that post-pandemic policies allowed for extensions to address disruptions, especially those related to family responsibilities.

Preparation for Article-Based Theses: Despite not having written a synopsis herself, Lydia observed that candidates often lack preparedness for writing article-based theses, a gap she attributes to the traditional focus on monographic work at earlier academic stages. She advocates for enhanced training and support for candidates transitioning to this format.

Overall Reflection: Lydia’s reflections reveal a nuanced understanding of the challenges faced by PhD candidates and supervisors during the pandemic. Her approach highlights the importance of flexibility, emotional support, and the need for institutions to provide clearer guidelines and more robust support systems to adapt to such unprecedented circumstances effectively. Her experience underscores the critical role of empathy and adaptability in academic leadership during crises.

3.2.7 Analyzing the interview with Michelle

Introduction: Michelle, 41, specializes in educational science, teacher education, and language didactics. She has previously supervised five PhD students to completion and is currently the main and co-supervisor for ten PhD candidates.

Impact of the Pandemic on PhD Candidates: Michelle reported varied impacts of the pandemic on her PhD candidates. Those who were in the final stages of their research before the pandemic began experienced minimal disruptions, benefiting from the shift to remote work which allowed them more focused time for writing. However, candidates in earlier stages of their projects or those with young children faced significant challenges due to reduced childcare hours and the need to juggle multiple responsibilities.

Changes in Supervision Practices: The pandemic greatly affected Michelle’s ability to provide regular supervision. With the demands of her own childcare responsibilities and the limitations of remote work, the frequency and quality of her interactions with her PhD candidates suffered. Supervision sessions were delayed, and Michelle had to adjust her practices, often conducting meetings via phone, online with Zoom or Teams, or in socially distanced outdoor settings.

Home Office Experience: Michelle found working from home to be extremely challenging, particularly due to the presence of young children and the constant interruptions that blurred the lines between work and home life. She experienced a persistent sense of being unable to adequately meet all her responsibilities as a supervisor and a parent.

Workload Changes During the Pandemic : Her workload related to PhD supervision became more demanding due to the difficulties in maintaining regular and effective communication. Michelle had to find creative ways to support her students, which often meant extended work hours and adapting to less conventional interaction methods.

Support from Employer: Michelle expressed significant disappointment with the lack of support from her employer during the pandemic. She felt that the institutions did not provide clear guidelines or additional support for managing the unique challenges brought on by the pandemic, leaving supervisors to manage as best they could under difficult circumstances.

Concerns for PhD Candidates: Michelle was particularly concerned about the psychological well-being of her candidates, noting that the isolation and disruptions affected different groups in varied ways. She observed that while parents were stressed and overextended, single young men often felt isolated and unproductive, which sometimes led to detrimental lifestyle changes.

Personal Health Concerns: Michelle mentioned that, like many in academia, she was accustomed to working excessively and did not have time to focus on her own health due to the demands of the pandemic situation.

Effect on Completion Times: Michelle anticipated that the pandemic would likely extend the completion times for many PhD candidates due to delays in data collection and the general disruption of academic schedules. She noted that while some extensions were granted, many were not, which added to the stress and uncertainty for the candidates.

Preparation for Article-Based Theses: Michelle believes that PhD candidates are generally not well-prepared to write article-based theses, which is often not addressed until during the PhD program itself. She emphasized the importance of structuring doctoral education to prepare better candidates for the realities of academic publishing and the peer review process.

Overall Reflection: Michelle’s experience during the pandemic highlights the complex challenges faced by PhD supervisors. Her insights underscore the need for better institutional support and clearer guidelines to navigate such unprecedented situations. Her commitment to adapting her supervisory practices despite personal and professional challenges demonstrates her dedication to her role and the success of her students.

3.2.8 Analyzing the interview with Ollie

Introduction: Ollie, aged 55, specializes in educational science and has completed his doctoral degree with a monograph. He has guided one PhD candidate to completion and is currently supervising three, with one about to defend their thesis.

Impact of the Pandemic on PhD Candidates: Ollie noted significant disruptions for his PhD candidates due to the pandemic. One candidate was fortunate to have completed major data collection just before lockdowns, which somewhat insulated their progress. However, others struggled as their research depended heavily on data collection in schools, which became nearly impossible due to access restrictions and subsequent strikes affecting the school system.

Changes in Supervision Practices: While the physical data collection was hindered, Ollie found digital supervision effective, especially for discussing and editing texts. He appreciated the direct focus on the text that digital platforms such as Teams or Zoom facilitated, contrasting with the sometimes-awkward setups of physical meetings. Nonetheless, the lack of access to schools for his candidates meant there was less content to supervise, which altered the dynamics of his guidance.

Home Office Experience: Ollie had a relatively positive experience working from home, appreciating the convenience and reduced commute time. He noted that being at home allowed for a more relaxed dress code and flexible work hours, although he acknowledged a potential for decreased social interaction and the blurring of work-life boundaries.

Workload Changes During the Pandemic: Ollie’s workload in terms of PhD supervision remained largely the same, but the nature of the supervision changed. He spent more time helping candidates pivot their projects to adapt to the new realities, which included more discussions and finding alternative approaches to research obstacles.

Support from Employer: Ollie felt that there was a lack of specific support for PhD supervisors from his employer during the pandemic. The focus seemed to be more on undergraduate and master’s students, with little attention paid to the challenges faced by PhD candidates and their supervisors.

Concerns for PhD Candidates: He was concerned about the delays and the psychological impact on his students, noting the challenges of maintaining motivation and morale under such uncertain and stressful conditions.

Personal Health Concerns: Ollie was proactive about maintaining his physical health during the pandemic, investing in ergonomic furniture to ensure comfort while working from home. He did not express concerns about his psychological health, suggesting a pragmatic approach to dealing with the pandemic’s challenges.

Effect on Completion Times: He anticipated that the pandemic would significantly delay his PhD candidates’ completion times, mainly due to disrupted data collection processes. Ollie stressed the importance of data quality and how difficulties in data collection could impact the overall quality of doctoral research and subsequent publication opportunities.

Overall Reflection: Ollie’s insights reflect a nuanced understanding of the diverse challenges posed by the pandemic to doctoral education. His adaptation to online supervision using videoconferencing platforms such as Zoom or Teams highlights the potential benefits of digital platforms for focused academic work, even as he recognizes the significant disruptions to traditional research pathways. His experience underscores the need for institutions to provide more robust support systems for doctoral candidates and supervisors, ensuring that doctoral training quality and integrity are maintained even in adverse circumstances.

3.2.9 Analyzing the interview with Tyler

Introduction: Tyler, aged 60, specializes in the philosophy of science, organization, and educational leadership. He completed his doctorate with a monograph and has guided two PhD candidates to completion, with four currently under his supervision.

Impact of the Pandemic on PhD Candidates: The pandemic significantly disrupted the plans of Tyler’s PhD candidates, particularly affecting those involved in international collaborations and empirical research. One candidate missed a crucial research stay in Italy, impacting their opportunity to engage with an international academic community. Another had to revise their empirical approach due to restricted access to schools, which was a common issue during the pandemic.

Changes in Supervision Practices: Tyler’s supervision was heavily affected by the pandemic, with all interactions moving to digital platforms, including Teams and Zoom. This shift resulted in less frequent and less personal guidance, which he felt was less effective than the planned intensive seminars abroad. Like Ollie, however, Tyler noted some benefits to digital supervision using videoconferencing platforms, such as the ability to engage with text during sessions directly.

Home Office Experience: Initially, Tyler took on additional teaching responsibilities to compensate for colleagues struggling with digital formats, which increased his workload. Over time, he found a rhythm of working from home and even appreciated the focused time that allowed him to complete a book. He alternated working from home and the office, leveraging the strengths of both environments to maintain productivity.

Workload Changes During the Pandemic: Tyler’s workload in terms of PhD supervision did not increase significantly. Digital Teams or Zoom meetings tended to be shorter and more focused, which somewhat compensated for the increased preparatory work required for effective digital instruction.

Support from Employer: Tyler expressed frustration with his institution’s management during the pandemic, particularly concerning doctoral courses and the increased bureaucratic oversight that he felt stifled academic freedom. He noted a lack of focus on the needs of PhD supervisors and candidates compared to other groups within the university.

Concerns for PhD Candidates: While not overly concerned about the mental and physical health of his candidates, Tyler was worried about the practical aspects of their research, especially those needing to conduct fieldwork, which was severely impacted by the pandemic restrictions.

Personal Health Concerns: Tyler did not express particular concerns about his health; however, he took proactive measures to ensure a comfortable working environment by investing in ergonomic office equipment.

Effect on Completion Times: Tyler anticipated that the pandemic would extend the completion times for his PhD candidates, especially due to disruptions in data collection and the broader impact on academic research activities.

Overall Reflection: Tyler’s experiences reflect the complex challenges faced by academic supervisors during the pandemic, balancing the shift to digital platforms with maintaining academic rigor and support for their candidates. His story highlights the need for institutions to provide better support and flexibility for supervisors and PhD candidates during crises, ensuring that academic standards and well-being are maintained. Tyler’s ability to adapt and find personal benefits during the pandemic, such as completing a book, also underscores the potential for finding opportunities in the face of challenges.

3.2.10 Comprehensive analysis of the Main findings across nine interviews of doctoral supervisors in Norway

3.2.10.1 overview.

This analysis integrates the findings from interviews with nine doctoral supervisors in Norway, structured by the interview guide (based on the main findings from the survey) and analyzed using Braun and Clarke’s (2021) approach to reflexive thematic analysis. The analysis focuses on how the COVID-19 pandemic affected the progression of PhD candidates and the corresponding changes in supervision practices.

Main Themes Identified:

1. Impact of the Pandemic on PhD Progression:

• Disruptions in Data Collection : Most supervisors reported significant disruptions in their candidates’ ability to collect data, especially those requiring access to external facilities like schools or international institutions. This was primarily due to lockdowns and restrictions imposed to curb the spread of the virus. As one supervisor noted: “One of my candidates had to delay their project significantly due to the inability to collect data as schools were not accessible.” (Ollie)

• Adaptations in Research Plans : Many candidates had to alter their research methodologies or adjust their empirical scopes to suit the new constraints, highlighting the flexibility required under crisis conditions. However, one of the supervisors mentioned that: “It affected them very differently. I had three candidates before the pandemic, and two of them were barely affected. However, the third struggled significantly with data collection due to difficulties in recruiting informants.” (Gabbie)

2. Changes in Supervision Practices:

• Shift to Digital Supervision : All supervisors transitioned to online platforms for conducting supervision, such as Zoom, Teams, or phone apps (e.g., Facebook Messenger, WhatsApp). While some found digital tools effective for sharing and reviewing written work, others felt the lack of physical presence reduced the quality of interaction and guidance they could provide. As one supervisor noted: “Digital supervision worked very well because it allowed sharing and discussing texts more effectively than in-person meetings. This actually enhanced the focus on the text during sessions” (Ollie).

• Increased Need for Emotional Support : Supervisors noted an increased need to support the psychological well-being of their candidates, as many struggled with isolation and stress due to the pandemic. As one supervisor noted: “I was particularly attentive to the mental health of my candidates, especially those without local family support. Regular check-ins were crucial during this period” (Gabbie).

3. Work Environment and Work-Life Balance:

• Home Office Challenges : Responses about working from home were mixed; some supervisors appreciated the flexibility and reduced commute times, while others struggled with distractions and the blending of personal and professional spaces. As one supervisor mentioned: “I actually enjoyed working from home as it provided a peaceful environment, but I missed the informal interactions with colleagues.” (Lydia)

• Institutional Support : There was a notable lack of targeted support for supervisors from their institutions. This often left supervisors and their candidates feeling overlooked in broader university responses to the pandemic. As one supervisor noted: “There was no specific support for me as a PhD supervisor during the pandemic. The general support was the same as for all staff members” (Lydia).

4. Professional Development and Academic Output:

• Delays in Academic Milestones : The pandemic delayed key academic milestones, including thesis submissions and defenses, primarily due to halted data collection and extended research timelines.

• Publication Challenges : The disruption also impacted candidates’ abilities to publish their research, a crucial component of their academic careers, due to delays and changes in their research projects.

Integration of Findings with Saldaña’s Coding Framework and Interview Guide:

• Using Saldaña’s coding method allowed for identifying recurring challenges and adaptations among the supervisors’ experiences. The thematic analysis revealed a consistent need for increased flexibility in research planning and supervision methods.

• The interview guide helped maintain a focus on how the pandemic specifically impacted various aspects of PhD supervision and candidate progression. It ensured that all relevant areas, such as changes in work routines, supervision adjustments, and overall impacts on PhD timelines, were systematically explored.

Comprehensive Assessment : The interviews collectively underscore the resilience and adaptability required by PhD candidates and their supervisors during the pandemic. They highlight several areas for improvement:

• Enhanced Institutional Support : Institutions clearly need to provide more structured support tailored to the needs of PhD candidates and supervisors during crises.

• Flexibility in Research and Supervision Plans : Adapting research plans and supervision methods to accommodate unexpected disruptions is crucial for maintaining the integrity and continuity of PhD education.

• Focus on Mental Health : The increased emotional and psychological support needed by candidates suggests that institutions should integrate mental health resources more fully into their doctoral training programs.

• Preparedness and Training : The experience has shown the importance of preparing PhD candidates for unexpected changes in their research environment, including training in digital tools and remote research methodologies.

In conclusion, the pandemic has not only disrupted traditional PhD education paths but also provided insights into how flexibility, digital preparedness, and institutional support can be enhanced to better prepare for future crises. These insights are vital for shaping resilient and adaptive academic environments that can withstand global challenges while supporting doctoral candidates’ academic and personal well-being.

From the analysis of the nine interviews, a few aspects stood out as particularly notable, offering deeper insights (expansion) into the unique challenges and responses within the context of PhD supervision during the pandemic:

1. Resilience and Innovation in Supervision:

• Some supervisors noted that despite the significant challenges, the shift to digital platforms allowed them to explore new forms of engagement with texts and supervision methods. For example, one supervisor highlighted the effectiveness of digital tools for collaborative work on documents, suggesting that these might even surpass traditional face-to-face interactions in certain aspects. This adaptation was a positive takeaway that some found surprising and worth integrating into their post-pandemic practices.

2. Diverse Impacts on Different Research Types:

• The differential impact of the pandemic on empirical versus theoretical research was striking. Supervisors of candidates who needed to conduct fieldwork, especially in schools or abroad, faced severe disruptions. As one supervisor noted: “We had to adjust research plans significantly, shifting to alternative data sources and methods where possible.” (Kyle). In contrast, those whose work was more theoretical or could be conducted remotely experienced fewer setbacks. This variance highlighted certain types of research vulnerability to external disruptions, which was a notable point of concern.

3. Underestimation of Emotional Challenges:

• Another well known, but still important aspect was the depth of emotional and psychological impacts on PhD candidates as noted by their supervisors. The extent to which these challenges affected the candidates’ productivity and well-being was significant and perhaps underappreciated by the institutions themselves. This underscores a critical area for future academic support systems to address more robustly.

4. Lack of Institutional Support:

• The widespread sentiment of insufficient institutional support was particularly striking. Several supervisors felt that there was a lack of targeted strategies to support PhD supervision during the pandemic. This lack of support was not just in terms of transitioning to online modes but also in addressing the specific needs of PhD candidates and their projects during such a disruptive period.

5. The Positive Impact of Forced Adaptation:

• Interestingly, some supervisors pointed out that the forced adaptation to new circumstances led to unexpected benefits, such as enhanced focus and productivity in certain cases, and even opportunities for personal and professional growth, such as writing a book or developing new teaching methods. These outcomes, while not universal, were surprising positives that emerged from a generally challenging time.

The sentiment analysis of the 9 interviews (see attachment 4 in the Supplementary file ) showed some individual variations, but that resilience and adaptability among doctoral supervisors during the pandemic were quite common. Supervisors recognized the challenges but overall maintained a positive and proactive stance, focusing on solutions and effective management of their supervisory roles. The objective nature of their responses indicates a practical approach to dealing with the pandemic’s impact, emphasizing the importance of communication, adaptation to remote supervision, and institutional support.

These insights not only highlight the varied experiences of PhD supervisors during the pandemic but also suggest areas for improvement in how institutions support doctoral education in times of crisis. The resilience and innovative approaches developed during this period could inform future policies and practices to better support PhD candidates and supervisors alike.

3.2.11 Integrated analysis: the main findings from the interviews and the open survey responses

To integrate and analyze the findings from the interviews (see attachment 1) and the 1,483 open survey responses (see attachment 2) from the survey among 293 doctoral supervisors, we can draw on several key themes and concerns that emerge consistently across these data sources. This approach will help us understand the broader implications of the insights gathered from different perspectives within the same study.

1. Adaptation to Digital Tools and Platforms:

• Interviews : The interviews highlighted how supervisors adapted to using digital tools for communication and supervision. This was generally seen as effective but lacking in certain qualitative aspects, particularly in building deeper relationships and managing more nuanced discussions.

• Open Survey Responses : The survey also reflected a reliance on digital tools, with many supervisors recognizing their utility in maintaining continuity. However, there was also an acknowledgment of the challenges in fully replicating face-to-face interactions.

2. Ethical and Practical Concerns with Digital Supervision:

• Interviews : Concerns were raised about the relational and ethical implications of the lack of physical presence and interaction, and the extensive use of digital tools in academic settings during the pandemic.

• Open Survey Responses : Similar concerns were noted, with supervisors emphasizing the importance of ensuring academic integrity and the genuine intellectual development of PhD candidates.

3. Impact of the Pandemic on Supervisory Practices:

• Interviews : The pandemic’s impact was a significant theme, affecting the logistical aspects of supervision and the mental well-being of both supervisors and their candidates.

• Open Survey Responses : Responses indicated varied impacts of the pandemic, with some supervisors noting increased stress and difficulty in maintaining research productivity and supervisory quality.

4. Institutional Support and Professional Development:

• Interviews : There was a noted lack of sufficient institutional support for adapting to new modes of supervision and research during the pandemic.

• Open Survey Responses : This theme was echoed in the survey responses, with mixed reports about the availability and effectiveness of continuing professional development (CPD) related to research supervision. Some respondents felt unsupported, particularly in navigating the challenges posed by remote supervision and digital tools.

5. Preparedness of PhD Candidates:

• Interviews : Discussions highlighted concerns about the varying levels of preparedness among PhD candidates, especially in writing the synopsis and adapting to new research methodologies that include digital tools and remote data collection.

• Open Survey Responses : Supervisors expressed a range of experiences regarding candidate preparedness. While some noted their candidates were well-equipped, others pointed out significant gaps, especially in writing the synopsis and article-based theses and handling the referee process, the timeline and complex research independently.

6. Valuation of Supervision:

• Interviews : Supervisors discussed feeling that their efforts were not adequately valued by institutions, with a need for greater recognition and support for their roles.

• Open Survey Responses : This sentiment was reinforced by survey data, where some supervisors felt that their contributions to doctoral training were undervalued by their institutions, particularly when compared to other academic duties.

7. Suggestions for Institutional Changes:

• Interviews : There were calls for institutions to adapt more proactively to the changing landscape of doctoral education, including better training for using digital tools and more robust support systems for both supervisors and candidates.

• Open Survey Responses : Supervisors suggested various improvements, such as more structured professional development opportunities, better guidelines for remote supervision, and enhanced support for mental health and well-being.

3.2.12 Summary

The integrated analysis across interviews and open survey responses suggests a complex landscape of doctoral supervision during and potentially beyond the pandemic era. Key themes highlight both challenges and potential areas for policy and practice enhancements:

• Digital Adaptation and Ethical Concerns : While digital tools have provided necessary solutions for continuity in supervision, they bring up ethical concerns that institutions need to address more thoroughly, particularly concerning academic integrity and the quality of student learning.

• Support and Development Needs : There is a clear need for institutions to offer more targeted support and development opportunities for supervisors, addressing both the technical aspects of digital supervision and the broader pedagogical skills required in a changing academic environment.

• Recognition and Valuation of Supervision : Supervisors feel that their work is not sufficiently valued, suggesting that institutions should reevaluate how they recognize and support supervisory roles within the academic career framework.

• Candidate Preparedness : There is variability in how prepared PhD candidates are for the demands of modern doctoral research, indicating the need for more robust preparatory programs and entry assessments.

• These insights call for a strategic reassessment of doctoral training programs, supervisory support mechanisms, and institutional policies to better align with the evolving needs of both supervisors and their candidates.

4 Limitations and future research

The present study provides in-depths insights into PhD supervision during the pandemic; however, the study also has several limitations apart from inherited limitations of self-reports and interview data. Firstly, the findings might be context-specific to the educational setting in Norway. The unique characteristics of the Norwegian educational system, cultural aspects, and institutional structures may not be entirely generalizable to other countries. However, the globalization of doctoral education, with increasing international collaborations, international publishing, and standardization of academic practices, might mitigate this issue to some extent, making the findings relevant beyond the Norwegian context. Secondly, the study lacks data on PhD supervisors’ experiences prior to the pandemic. This absence of baseline data means we cannot directly compare the pre-pandemic and pandemic periods. Nonetheless, the experiences reported in this study correspond well with prior research on academic supervision ( Pyhältö et al., 2012 , 2023 ; Löfström et al., 2024 ), indicating that the challenges and adaptations observed are not entirely unprecedented, even if intensified by the pandemic context.

Future research should aim to explore the long-lasting impacts of COVID-19 on doctoral education. It is necessary to investigate whether the changes observed in supervisory practices during the pandemic are fleeting or have led to a permanent shift in how supervision is approached. Specifically, studies should examine if new models of remote supervision, increased flexibility, and the use of digital tools will continue to be integrated into doctoral education post-pandemic, or if traditional methods will resume dominance. This is of special interest in cases where PhD supervisors and PhD candidates are located at different institutions. By addressing these questions, future research can contribute to a deeper understanding of the pandemic’s legacy on doctoral education.

5 Conclusion

In this article we examined the experiences of PhD supervisors in Norway during the pandemic to answer the research questions:

1. To what extent has the COVID-19 pandemic impeded the PhD supervisors’ frame factors on the micro- level, and how do they perceive this situation?

2. To what extent has the COVID-19 pandemic influenced PhD supervisors’ frame factors on the meso- level, and how do they perceive this situation?

We conducted a cumulative data collection process and analysis, where survey questions were based on previously collected field dialog data, online observation data, seminar evaluation data, and document analysis data. The qualitative interview guide questions were built upon previously collected quantitative data (survey), and the Supplementary data was based on previously collected quantitative data (survey) and qualitative interview data.

The coherence between qualitative and quantitative findings is mainly examined based on confirmation , expansion , or discordance in this article ( Fetters et al., 2013 ).

The findings from the explorative case study revealed that the PhD supervisors faced numerous challenges during the pandemic, both professionally and personally. They found digital supervision with their PhD fellows via platforms like Teams and Zoom to be convenient and efficient but occasionally lacking in quality. They also encountered difficulties in addressing the psychosocial aspects of their PhD candidates’ experiences and faced various research-related challenges with their PhD-candidates during the pandemic. For PhD supervisors who extensively worked from home over a long period, the situation created new conditions that affected their job performance. These altered conditions hindered their research capacity, their ability to follow up with their PhD candidates and their capacity to fulfill other job responsibilities. Although the PhD supervisors received support during the pandemic, it seems that the incremental measures provided were insufficient. The PhD regulations were established before the pandemic under normal conditions and for normal circumstances. However, it appears that no significant adjustments have been made to accommodate the extraordinary pandemic conditions, which have altered some aspects of their professional roles as academics and PhD supervisors. This was particularly critical for PhD supervisors with young children, especially female supervisors, who had to deal with lockdowns, social distancing, remote work, homeschooling, quarantine for themselves and their children, and COVID-19 illness, since the data showed that they seemed to have more home responsibilities than men during the pandemic. We also found that some supervisors thought that female PhDs’ (with own children) submission rates to scientific journals have been delayed as a consequence of COVID-19, considering that women seem to have more home responsibilities. In addition, the supervisors thought that female supervisors (with own children) submission rates to scientific journals have been delayed as a consequence of COVID-19, considering that female supervisors seem also to have more home responsibilities (e.g., for childcare, household etc.).

This slow-motion disaster lasted up to 20 months and can be perceived as an “external intervention” or a naturalistic experiment which was impossible to predict for universities and society. The case study results indicate that it is more important than ever to plan for the unforeseen in order to be better prepared for the next societal crisis. Therefore, it is important to be vigilant and understand the gap between the formulation, transformation, and realization arenas when it comes to the distinction between incremental, semi-structural changes and fundamental changes in PhD regulations and guidelines brought on by societal crises. Although some support from employers has been offered, the overall PhD guidelines, regulations, and supervision norms remained unchanged in the transformation arena (meso- level) during the pandemic. On a general level, this highlights the need for better crisis preparedness at the doctoral level in the years to come.

A common finding related to RQ1 and RQ2 and across the different data sources was that the COVID-19 pandemic has significantly impacted some of the PhD supervisors in different ways on both micro- and meso-levels, and some of them perceive this long-lasting pandemic challenging and difficult, while others have experienced this to a lesser degree. This reveals a confirmation across the quantitative and qualitative data in the study. Also, these findings mostly confirmed and expanded on the understanding of the impact of the pandemic on PhD candidates ( Krumsvik et al., 2022 ), with some minor discordance.

More specifically, the PhD supervisors in the study were somewhat satisfied with the educational quality regarding digital teaching but experienced various supervision, research-related and psycho-social challenges. Although some of the supervisors received support during the pandemic, it seems like the majority did not receive sufficient support and their workload increased significantly during the pandemic. This is due to the high complexity of frame factors that have changed the underlying premises for doctoral education during the pandemic, affecting both the PhD- supervision and the PhD candidates’ feasibility on several levels. The regulations for PhD scholarships and PhD regulations, implemented before the pandemic in 2018, were designed under normal educational and social conditions and may not fully address the challenges faced during the pandemic. Therefore, this study shows that to reduce this gap and strengthen the feasibility of the PhDs and the frame factors for PhD-supervision, the institutions must significantly enhance their preparedness to effectively manage demanding situations at both micro- and meso-levels, ensuring they are fully equipped to address future societal crises of a similar nature.

When it comes to RQ3 we find both confirmation, expansion, and discordance across the quantitative and qualitative data. We find confirmation across the quantitative and qualitative data when it comes to the variability in preparedness of PhD candidates for writing the article-based thesis. Article-based theses present unique challenges compared to traditional monograph-based dissertations, particularly in terms of integration and the breadth of skills required. One of the primary challenges with article-based theses is integrating articles that may cover slightly different aspects of a research topic into a coherent overall thesis. This integration is critical, it requires a high level of academic writing skills and ability to secure the coherence of the synopsis. Candidates often come into PhD programs with varying levels of experience in academic writing and publication. The survey and interviews, as well as Supplementary data , indicate that many candidates are not well-prepared for writing article-based theses, highlighting a need for more targeted training in academic writing and publishing early in the doctoral process. The need for robust supervisory support is acutely felt in guiding article-based theses, where candidates must navigate the complexities of publishing in peer-reviewed journals alongside synthesizing their research in the synopsis. This implies that PhD-candidates both are taking a doctoral degree in the Norwegian context and at the same time are publishing articles for the international research context, which can be challenging.

We find expansion when it comes to the need to have guidelines for the synopsis. Supervisors reported significant variation in the guidelines for the synopsis across institutions, both in the qualitative and quantitative part, which can lead to confusion and inconsistency in expectations for candidates and supervisors. Some respondents found these guidelines sufficient, while others find them unclear or obscure, complicating their task of effectively guiding PhD candidates. Clear, comprehensible guidelines are essential for ensuring that the synopsis effectively synthesizes the research in a manner that meets academic standards ( Wollenschläger et al., 2016 ).

And we find some discordance regarding variability in candidate preparedness where both strands of the data indicated a significant variability in how prepared PhD candidates are when they enroll in doctoral programs. Candidates’ preparedness often depends on their previous educational experiences, which can vary widely regarding exposure to research methods, academic writing, and critical thinking skills. The variability in preparedness suggests a need for more robust preparatory programs to equip all incoming doctoral candidates with the necessary skills and knowledge to succeed in their research endeavors. Implementing comprehensive entry assessments could help identify specific areas where candidates might need additional support, allowing programs to tailor preparatory courses or early doctoral training to address these gaps.

These findings collectively point to a need for doctoral programs to clarify guidelines, particularly for the synopsis in article-based theses, to enhance support for supervisory roles, and to develop preparatory programs that address the broad variability in candidate preparedness. This is also based on research on the need for rubrics ( Wollenschläger et al., 2016 ), which shows that transparency around requirements and guidelines is important for students learning. By tackling these issues, institutions can better prepare PhD candidates for the demands of modern doctoral research, ultimately leading to more consistent and successful outcomes in doctoral education. And despite that only 20 (8.3%) of the supervisors agreed or strongly agreed that they were supervising a PhD candidate who had considered quitting the PhD program during the pandemic, it is important to be vigilant around the (complex) reasons that causes this, since this is in many ways a drastic decision, first of all for the candidate themselves, but also for the supervisors, as well as for the society in general who has invested almost 5 million Norwegian kroner in each PhD-scholarship. Dropping out can partly be related to the observed findings that many PhD candidates were unprepared for the intricacies of article writing, including the lengthy processes of submission and peer review, attached to their educational background, which primarily focused on monographic work at the bachelor’s and master’s levels. This also implies that while PhD’s are perceived, assessed and evaluated as student/candidates when they are completing assignments in a doctoral program, there might be a quite new situation for them when they submit their articles to scientific journals with blind review, where they are evaluated as other researchers (and not only as students/candidates). Such findings (and similar findings) seem to go “under the radar” in doctoral programs in Norway and by taking into account such “tacit knowledge” we might be better prepared to bridge the formulation arena and realization arena within doctoral education in the years to come. This development also demands a vigilance within doctoral education of the importance of theory development within doctoral education since international research shows that doctoral supervision is under-theorized and lacks a solid knowledge base ( Halse and Malfroy, 2010 ; Halse, 2011 ) where also eclectic use of theories ( Dalland et al., 2023 ) can improve this area.

Author note

GPT-4o ( OpenAI, 2024 ) was employed in this article to translate interview findings to English after a general thematic analysis conducted in Norwegian and as one of several validity communities for the open survey responses. The GPT-4’s output was manually examined, edited, and reviewed by the authors. The sentiment analysis of the 9 interviews was done by the first author and by using the GPT-4o. Then it was carried out a validation of this sentiment analysis by SurveyMonkey ( SurveyMonkey, 2024 ), Claude ( Anthropic, 2024 ) and Gemini Advanced ( Google, 2024 ).

Data availability statement

The original contributions presented in the study are included in the article/ Supplementary material , further inquiries can be directed to the corresponding author.

Author contributions

RK: Conceptualization, Data curation, Formal analysis, Investigation, Methodology, Project administration, Resources, Software, Validation, Visualization, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing. FR: Conceptualization, Data curation, Formal analysis, Methodology, Validation, Writing – review & editing, Writing – original draft. ØSk: Conceptualization, Data curation, Investigation, Methodology, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing. LJ: Conceptualization, Data curation, Methodology, Validation, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing. SS: Data curation, Formal analysis, Methodology, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing. ØSa: Data curation, Validation, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing. KH: Methodology, Validation, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing.

The author(s) declare that no financial support was received for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.

Acknowledgments

We would like to thank all doctoral supervisors for their responses to the surveys and for participating in interviews and focus groups on this study.

Conflict of interest

The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.

The author(s) declared that they were an editorial board member of Frontiers, at the time of submission. This had no impact on the peer review process and the final decision.

Publisher’s note

All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.

Supplementary material

The Supplementary material for this article can be found online at: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/feduc.2024.1436521/full#supplementary-material

1. ^ Some of the Norwegian statistic from universities shows the following: about parental leave (day’s work) (women 69%, men 31%), sick children (day’s work) (women 69%, men 31%), self-certified sick leave (day’s work) (women 65%, men 35%) and doctor-certified sick leave (day’s work) (women 72%, men 28%) during one of the year in the pandemic ( Krumsvik et al., 2022 ).

Andres, L., Bengtsen, S. S. E., Gallego Castaño, L., Crossouard, B., Keefer, J. M., and Pyhältö, K. (2015). Drivers and interpretations of doctoral education today: National Comparisons. Frontline Learn. Res. 3, 5–22. doi: 10.14786/flr.v3i3.177

Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

Anthropic. (2024). Claude 3. Large Language Model (version 14. March 2024) . San Francisco. Available at: https://claude.ai/new

Google Scholar

Baklien, B. (2004). Følgeforskning. Sosiologi i Dag 34, 49–66.

Bastalich, W. (2017). Content and context in knowledge production: a critical review of doctoral supervision literature. Stud. High. Educ. 42, 1145–1157. doi: 10.1080/03075079.2015.1079702

Bengtsen, S. S. E. (2023). “Doctoral education in-the-world: (dis)connections between research and society” in From splendid isolation to global engagement . eds. B. Wolf, T. Schmohl, L. Buhin-Krenek, and M. Stricker (WBV Media), 43–55.

Börgeson, E., Sotak, M., Kraft, J., Bagunu, G., Biörserud, C., and Lange, S. (2021). Challenges in PhD education due to COVID-19- disrupted supervision or business as usual: a cross-sectional survey of Swedish biomedical sciences graduate students. BMC Med. Educ. 21:294. doi: 10.1186/s12909-021-02727-3

PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar

Braun, V., and Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qual. Res. Psychol. 3, 77–101. doi: 10.1191/1478088706qp063oa

Braun, V., Clarke, V., Hayfield, N., and Terry, G. (2019). “Thematic analysis” in Handbook of research methods in health social sciences . ed. P. Liamputtong (Singapore: Springer), 843–860.

Braun, V., and Clarke, V. (2021). Thematic analysis: a practical guide. Los Angeles, CA: Sage.

Braun, V., and Clarke, V. (2019). Reflecting on reflexive thematic analysis. Qualitative Research in Sport, Exercise and Health , 11, 589–597. doi: 10.1080/2159676X.2019.1628806

Brinkmann, S. (2022). Qualitative Interviewing: Conversational Knowledge Through Research Interviews (2 ed.) . Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Burner, T., Bjerkholt, E., Gaathaug, A. V., Kleiven, S., and Ljoså, T. M. (2020). Doctorateness across higher education Institutionsin Norway. Uniped 43, 3–18. doi: 10.18261/issn.1893-8981-2020-01-02

Creswell, J. W., and Guetterman, T. C. (2021). Educational research: Planning, conducting, and evaluating quantitative and qualitative research . 6th Edn. Hoboken, NJ: Pearson.

Creswell, J. W., and Plano Clark, V. L. (2017). Designing and conducting mixed methods research . 3rd Edn. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

Dake, D. K., and Gyimah, E. (2023). Using sentiment analysis to evaluate qualitative students’ responses. Educ. Inf. Technol. 28, 4629–4647. doi: 10.1007/s10639-022-11349-1

Dalland, C. P., Blikstad-Balas, M., and Svenkerud, S. (2023). Eklektisk bruk av teori i doktorgradsavhandlinger innen utdanningsforskning. Acta Didactica Norden 17, 1–24. doi: 10.5617/adno.9837

Eisenhardt, K. M. (1989). Building Theories from Case Study Research. The Academy of Management Review , 14, 532–550. doi: 10.2307/258557

Ertesvåg, S. K., Sammons, P., and Blossing, U. (2021). Integrating data in a complex mixed-methods classroom interaction study. Br. Educ. Res. J. 47, 654–673. doi: 10.1002/berj.3678

European University Association (EUA) (2010). “Salzburg II” in Recommendations. European universities’ achievements since 2005 in implementing the Salzburg principles (Brussels: European University Association (EUA)).

European University Association (EUA) (2015). Annual Report 2015 . Brussels: European University Association (EUA).

Fetters, M. D., Curry, L. A., and Creswell, J. W. (2013). Achieving integration in mixed methods designs—principles and practices. Health Serv. Res. 48, 2134–2156. doi: 10.1111/1475-6773.12117

Flyvbjerg, B. (2011). “Case study” in The SAGE handbook of qualitative research . eds. N. K. Denzin and Y. S. Lincoln. 4th ed (Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage), 301–316.

Hall, J., and Mansfield, L. (2023). The benefits and complexities of integrating mixed method findings using the pillar integration process: a workplace health intervention case study. J. Mixed Methods Res. doi: 10.1177/15586898231196287

Gehrke, P. (2018). “Ecological validity” in The SAGE Encyclopedia of Educational Research, Measurement, and Evaluation . Ed. B. Frey. (Thousand Oaks: Sage), 563–565.

Google. (2024). Gemini Advanced. Large Language Model (version 20 May 2024) . Menlo Park, California. Available at: https://gemini.google.com/advanced?hl=no

Halse, C. (2011). ‘Becoming a supervisor’: the impact of doctoral supervision on supervisors’ learning. Stud. High. Educ. 36, 557–570. doi: 10.1080/03075079.2011.594593

Halse, C., and Malfroy, J. (2010). Retheorizing doctoral supervision as professional work. Stud. High. Educ. 35, 79–92. doi: 10.1080/03075070902906798

Hyett, N., Kenny, A., and Dickson-Swift, V. (2014). Methodology or method? A critical review of qualitative case study reports. Int. J. Qual. Stud. Health Well Being 9:23606. doi: 10.3402/qhw.v9.23606

Johnson, R. B., Onwuegbuzie, A. J., and Turner, L. A. (2007). Toward a definition of mixed methods research. J. Mixed Methods Res. 1, 112–133. doi: 10.1177/1558689806298224

Kálmán, O., Horváth, L., Kardos, D., Kozma, B., Feyisa, M. B., and Rónay, Z. (2022). Review of benefits and challenges of co-supervision in doctoral education. Eur. J. Educ. 57, 452–468. doi: 10.1111/ejed.12518

Krumsvik, R. J. (2016a). Noen betraktninger om forskningsveiledning PhD- nivå (some considerations about supervision at the doctoral level). In R. J. Krumsvik. En doktorgradsutdanning i endring – Med fokus på den artikkelbaserte PhD- avhandlingen (a doctoral education in alteration – With focus on the article-based PhD thesis) (pp. 125–148). Bergen: Fagbokforlaget.

Krumsvik, R. J. (2016b). The synopsis of article-based theses. In R. J. Krumsvik. En doktorgradsutdanning i endring – Med fokus på den artikkelbaserte PhD- avhandlingen (a doctoral education in alteration – With focus on the article-based PhD thesis) (pp. 93–123). Fagbokforlaget.

Krumsvik, R. J. (2017). Trenerene i den akademiske maraton (The trainers in the academic marathon). Utdanningsforskning (Educational Research) , Oslo: The Educational Association. 1–3.

Krumsvik, R. J., and Jones, L. Ø. (2016). Hvorfor dropper “kronjuvelen” ut? (why do the “crown jewels” drop out?). Tidsskrift for Norsk Psykologforening 12, 1022–1024.

Krumsvik, R. J., Jones, L. Ø., Leer-Salvesen, K., Høydal, K. L., and Røkenes, F. M. (2019). Face-to-face and remote teaching in a doctoraleducation course: using flipped classroom, formative assessment and remoteteaching to increase the teaching quality of a literature reviewcourse. Uniped 42, 194–214. doi: 10.18261/issn.1893-8981-2019-02-07

Krumsvik, R. J., Mæland, B., and Solstad, S. H. (2021). “Doctoral education in Norway and inter-institutional collaboration within doctoral education” in The future of doctoral research . eds. A. Lee and R. Bongaardt. 1st ed. (New York, NY: Routledge), 110–119.

Krumsvik, R. J., Øfstegaard, M., and Jones, L. Ø. (2016a). Retningslinjer og vurderingskriterier for artikkelbasert PhD. Uniped 39, 78–93. doi: 10.18261/issn.1893-8981-2016-01-07

Krumsvik, R. J., Øfstegaard, M., and Jones, L. Ø. (2016b). Retningslinjer og vurderingskriterier for artikkelbasert PhD-avhandling (guidelines and assessment criteria for article-based doctoral thesis). In R. J. Krumsvik. En doktorgradsutdanning i endring – Med fokus på den artikkelbaserte PhD-avhandlingen (a doctoral education in alteration – With focus on the article-based PhD thesis) (pp. 78–93). Bergen: Fagbokforlaget, 39.

Krumsvik, R. J., and Røkenes, F. M. (2016). Literature review in the PhD thesis. In R. J. Krumsvik. En doktorgradsutdanning i endring – Med fokus på den artikkelbaserte PhD-avhandlingen (a doctoral education in alteration – With focus on the article-based PhD thesis) (pp. 51–91). Bergen: Fagbokforlaget.

Krumsvik, R. J., Skaar, Ø. O., Røkenes, F. M., Solstad, S. H., and Høydal, K. L. (2022). Experiences of WNGER II PhD. fellows during the COVID-19 pandemic – a case study. Front. Educ. 7:860828. doi: 10.3389/feduc.2022.860828

Kvale, S., and Brinkmann, S. (2015). InterViews: Learning the craft of qualitative research interviewing . 3rd Edn. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.

Linde, G. (2012). Det ska ni veta! En introduktion till läroplansteori (3rd Edn.). Lund: Studentlitteratur.

Lindensjö, B., and Lundgren, U. P. (2014). Utbildningsreformer och politisk styrning . Stockholm: HLS Förlag.

Löfström, E., Tikkanen, L., Anttila, H., and Pyhältö, K. (2024). Supervisors’ experiences of doctoral supervision in times of change. Stud. Grad. Postdoctoral Educ. 15, 34–48. doi: 10.1108/SGPE-01-2023-0004

Lundgren, U. P. (1999). Ramfaktorteori och praktisk utbildningsplanering. Pedagogisk Forskning 4, 31–41.

Mason, S., and Merga, M. (2018). Integrating publications in the social science doctoral thesis by publication. High. Educ. Res. Dev. 37, 1454–1471. doi: 10.1080/07294360.2018.1498461

Maxwell, J. A. (2013). Qualitative research design: An interactive approach . 3rd Edn Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.

Merriam, S. B. (2009). Qualitative research: A guide to design and implementation . Hoboken, NJ: Jossey-Bass.

Merriam, S. B., and Tisdell, E. J. (2016). Qualitative research: A guide to design and implementation . 4th Edn. Hoboken, NJ: Jossey-Bass.

OpenAI. (2024). ChatGPT (May 20204 version) [Large language model]. San Fransisco, LA Available at: https://chat.openai.com/chat

Patton, M. Q. (2015). Qualitative research & evaluation methods: Integrating theory and practic . Sage.

Peters, M., and Fàbregues, S. (2023). Missed opportunities in mixed methods EdTech research? Visual joint display development as an analytical strategy for achieving integration in mixed methods studies. Educ. Technol. Res. Dev. , 1–21. doi: 10.1007/s11423-023-10234-z

Pyhältö, K., Tikkanen, L., and Anttila, H. (2023). Is there a fit between PhD candidates’ and their supervisors’ perceptions on the impact of COVID-19 on doctoral education? Stud. Grad. Postdoct. Educ. 14, 134–150. doi: 10.1108/SGPE-05-2022-0035

Pyhältö, K., Vekkaila, J., and Keskinen, J. (2012). Exploring the fit between doctoral students’ and supervisors’ perceptions of resources and challenges Vis-à-Vis the doctoral journey. Int. J. Dr. Stud. 7, 395–414. doi: 10.28945/1745

Ramberg, I., and Wendt, K. K. (2023). Forskerhverdag under koronapandemien: Resultater fra en panelundersøkelse av norske forskere 2022 (Oslo: NIFU Working Note 9). Available at: https://hdl.handle.net/11250/3069589

Sarrico, C. S. (2022). The expansion of doctoral education and the changing nature and purpose of the doctorate. High. Educ. 84, 1299–1315. doi: 10.1007/s10734-022-00946-1

Schoonenboom, J., and Johnson, R. B. (2017). How to construct a mixed methods research design. KZfSS Kölner Zeitschrift Für Soziologie Und Sozialpsychologie 69, 107–131. doi: 10.1007/s11577-017-0454-1

Skodvin, O. J. (2013). “NOKUT og kvalitet i IKT-støttet høyere utdanning” in Ulike forståelser av kvalitet i norsk, fleksibel høyere utdanning . eds. T. Fossland, K. R. Ramberg, and E. Gjerdrum (Tromsø: Norgesuniversitetet).

Solli, K., and Nygaard, L. P. (2022). ‘Same But Different? Identifying Writing Challenges Specific to the PhD by Publication’, in Landscapes and Narratives of PhD by Publication . Eds. K. Solli and L. P. Nygaard Cham: Springer. 13–30.

Stake, R. E. (1995). The art of case study research . Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications.

Stake, R. E. (2006). Multiple case study analysis . New York, NY: The Guilford Press.

Steine, S., and Sarpebakken, B. (2023). Færre doktorgrader innenfor matematikk og naturvitenskap i 2022 . Oslo: Statistics Norway.

SurveyMonkey. (2024). SurveyMonkey . San Mateo. Available at: https://surveymonkey.com

Tight, M. (2016). “Case study research” in The BERA/Sage handbook of educational research . eds. D. Wyse, N. Selwyn, E. Smith, and L. Suter (Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications), 376–394.

UK Council for Graduate Education (2021). The UK research supervision survey report 2021 . London: UK Council for Graduate Education.

Wichmann-Hansen, G. (2021). DUT Guide on Supervision. Dansk Universitetspædagogisk Tidsskrift . 16, 1–13. doi: 10.7146/dut.v16i31.127292

Wollenschläger, M., Hattie, J., Machts, N., Möller, J., and Harms, U. (2016). What makes rubrics effective in teacher-feedback? Transparency of learning goals is not enough. Contemp. Educ. Psychol. 44–45, 1–11. doi: 10.1016/j.cedpsych.2015.11.003

Yin, R. K. (2012). Applications of case study research . 3rd Edn: Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.

Keywords: PhD-supervisors, experiences, COVID-19, supervision, PhD-fellows, frame factors

Citation: Krumsvik RJ, Røkenes FM, Skaar &O, Jones L, Solstad SH, Salhus & and Høydal KL (2024) PhD-supervisors experiences during and after the COVID-19 pandemic: a case study. Front. Educ . 9:1436521. doi: 10.3389/feduc.2024.1436521

Received: 22 May 2024; Accepted: 15 July 2024; Published: 09 August 2024.

Reviewed by:

Copyright © 2024 Krumsvik, Røkenes, Skaar, Jones, Solstad, Salhus and Høydal. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY) . The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.

*Correspondence: Rune J. Krumsvik, [email protected]

Disclaimer: All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article or claim that may be made by its manufacturer is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.