Recognizing task and relationship practices
Source: The COMFORT Communication Project developed by Elaine Wittenberg, PhD and Joy Goldsmith, PhD ( www.CommunicateComfort.com ), revised 2016. 15
With funding from the National Cancer Institute, the nurse communication curriculum was created for a 2-day training course for implementing evidence-based palliative care communication skills into practice. Clinical nursing faculty and communication researchers were brought together to teach the curriculum. To date, COMFORT communication training has been provided nationwide to 269 oncology nurses who have trained an additional 6863 other health care professionals at their home institutions. COMFORT has shown to improve clinician self-efficacy, attitudes toward communication, and reduce providers’ apprehension about communication. 18 – 20 Subsequent research with the curriculum has shown improvement in nurses’ attitudes, comfort levels, and perceived self-efficacy regarding palliative care conversations 21 and improvements in nurse-perceived confidence in initiating difficult communication topics with family caregivers. 22 Highlighted below are summaries of the four most popular modules of the curriculum (modules C, O, M, R), derived from a culmination of a review of the literature, efficacy research, concepts grounded in communication theory, and feedback from nationwide nursing audiences and expert clinical faculty.
Fundamental to the goal of palliative care in providing holistic, comprehensive care focused on the patient’s quality of life, nurse communication should involve clinical narrative practice to capture an awareness of the patient/family life experience and incorporate that experience into communication about cancer. Clinical narrative practice is about narratuves or the stories of our patients’s lives. It is defined as being with and relating to others while honoring the patient’s voice and lived experience. When gathering information about the patient/family, nurses should ask the patient/family to recall the cancer story. Storytelling is a natural form of human interaction and stories of illness reveal how health is defined, how symptoms and concerns are managed, and how care is evaluated. Stories also reveal understanding about the cause of cancer and personal risk of cancer, 23 help patients and families make meaning and manage identity, and reveal perceptions of reality. 24 The patient’s story reveals his/her account of events and understanding, the circumstances of the illness in terms of heredity and life events, their living environment and occupation, and personality. Stories provide insight not gained through routine assessments. 25
Clinical narrative practice involves understanding the illness story 26 and tailoring communication to help the patient/family take control and find “alternative ways of being ill.” 27 Frank 27 defines this as the quest narrative, when the story of illness is viewed as a journey from which something will be gained. As oncology nurses hear the patient’s story, they should engage in relational communication by practicing active listening strategies. Each patient/family has a unique life story and a unique illness story. 28 Focus on gaps, ambiguities, and conflicting plots within the story. The patient’s history can reveal common forms of self-blame (life decisions/actions that led up to the illness, feelings of guilt for poor decisions, and the desire to cure at all costs). Encourage reflection on loss and the changes cancer has brought to everyday living. 29 Table 2 provides example questions to ask patients that promote reflection on life and can aid in helping the patient identify values and goals for care.
Questions to Promote Reflection on Life
• “How has your illness (or his/her illness) affected your life and your relationships?” |
• “How do you think ignoring this will affect your life?” |
• “How does your illness (or his/her illness) reflect on you as a person?” |
• “How do you see the future?” |
• “How are you affected by others’ opinions?” |
• “What do you think influences this experience?” |
By learning the patient’s story, nurses can help families consider all dimensions of quality of life, create new solutions and plans, and explore alternative hopes for the future. Nurses can help the patient/family make meaning of what is happening, promote understanding and acceptance, and encourage reflection on how the illness has impacted daily life. To accomplish this, statements should explicitly recognize the patient’s life, elaborate on how illness impacts the patient’s life, and acknowledge the loss/change in life. In this manner, information is incorporated into important aspects of the patient’s life to promote understanding, as in the following example:
A 74-year-old woman, Lois, with newly diagnosed non–small cell lung cancer was introduced to the palliative care team to discuss management of her dyspnea and goals of care. She had smoked 1 pack of cigarettes per day for 40 years but had recently quit; she has significant COPD and limited activity because of impaired pulmonary reserve. Her husband of 50 years has dementia and Lois cares for him in their home; he is verbal and capable of some self-care activities. One daughter lives nearby and assists with shopping and other errands, although she is employed full time and has a family. A son lives at a distance with his family and has limited financial means to visit frequently. The patient has approximately an 18-month prognosis and will undergo chemotherapy.
“Fifty years of marriage is a very special life accomplishment, and so is quitting smoking. Congratulations on this achievement. You must have a lot on your mind with his care and your difficulty breathing.”
“Your cancer can be treated with chemotherapy, but it will be very hard on you, making it more difficult for you to care for Wendell, and it will not get rid of the cancer. Over time, it will not be possible for you to take care of Wendell. How are you feeling about all of this?”
“After caring for him and being together for so long, we understand that your inability to care for Wendell will be a major loss. You will need a lot of support.”
Oncology nurses bridge the divide between the language of medicine and the language of everyday life. They do this by helping patients and their families understand health within the context of daily living, translating medical words by using metaphors and adjectives, and conveying to the team what the patient and family understand and do not understand. When communicating about cancer, it is important that nurses provide orientation to the cancer stage by describing the big picture of a diagnosis (orientation) and summarizing the disease path (options). Nurses must explain options that have been provided to the patient and their family, and tailor the format and modality of information presentation.
For patient/family, the words used in everyday life make sense of health and illness. Body parts and functions are identified using plain language like-- puke, shaky, weak. Illness is understood by how it impacts work, family needs and expectations, and social relationships. On the other hand, providers, institutions, and online/printed material use the voice of medicine---nausea, malaise, activities of daily living. Medical terms, jargon, acronyms, and medical-speak identify parts of the body, procedures, and tests. 30 These are foreign and disorienting for a sick person and his/her family. Oncology nurses play a critical role during cancer care because they are often asked to translate medical terms, answer questions about the disease, diagnosis, and prognosis, and explain treatment and side effects.
Conversations about cancer need to match the health literacy of the patient family. Health literacy is different than ‘literacy,’ in that it requires more communication skills than reading. For example, collecting and selecting the best and most useful information and then acting on the information demands more than simply reading a set of instructions. Family and patient must be able to receive, acquire, understand , and use information to be health literate. Health literacy includes the language you use when communicating with patients/family (face-to-face or otherwise), the context of the interaction (are you in the ICU, ER, multiple patient room), culture (do you and the patient/family have the same cultural background), communication skill levels, and technology . Matching the health literacy abilities of a patient/family is central to delivering quality care. 31 The case of Mr K demonstrates the many components of health literacy to consider when providing care:
The primary treating team and ICU team have arranged for a discussion about goals of care with first- and second-generation family members of Mr K, a 63-year-old gentleman of Asian descent who has been in the ICU for 7 days. He remains ventilated and unresponsive, without evidence of being able to be weaned from the ventilator. The need for tracheostomy placement versus revision to the plan of care is the focus for the meeting. A conference room has been reserved because the patient is intubated and unable to participate in the conversation. A pre-meeting is held among the health care providers, at which time the oncology nurse who has worked closely with the patient informs the other providers of the importance of this family’s cultural background. In particular, he notes that if options are provided, the family will always choose whatever the doctor recommends, because doing otherwise would reflect disrespect, even if they know that the patient would disagree with the doctor’s recommendation.
It will be important to provide a thorough introduction of each provider and his or her role. Family members will be confused by meeting three sets of providers (oncology treating team, ICU team, and palliative care team). The meeting should begin by orienting the family to the three services and how they work together. A pictorial chart or visual aid should be used to explain.
The conference room should be large enough, so that all family members can sit down. Team members should be aware of where they sit; the team should not sit opposite the family. Team members should disperse and sit among the family to demonstrate partnership-building and decrease authority and hierarchy. Family members and health care team members should silence pagers and cellular phones to reduce interruptions.
A translator may be needed. The pre-meeting huddle by the team should include a discussion of any language barriers for this family. A team member should be designated to ask the family about cultural needs regarding care.
In a large family meeting, it is likely that communication skills among family members will vary. It is also likely that there is a member of the health care team that has already established a relationship with this family. The team should give careful consideration to who should lead the family meeting.
A patient and family’s cultural and social background are also important aspects in orienting patient and family about cancer. Thirty-six percent of all Americans have basic or below-basic health literacy, with older Americans and women aged 50–79 from all ethnic groups having the most difficulty communicating with providers. 32 There are several cultural and social factors that contribute to a patient’s health literacy level, including their level of acculturation and language, limited English proficiency, the use of translators in explaining options, a lack of available educational materials in languages other than English, and their individual health beliefs. 33 – 35 Cultural factors may affect a patient’s treatment and result in a limited desire or ability to participate in care, a misunderstanding of cancer stage/stage awareness, less desire/need for cancer information, inaccurate assessments of risk and fewer questions asked to health care providers.
Oncology nurses should use plain language as a strategy to reduce the gap between provider and patient/family health literacy levels. Using plain language includes using an active voice (eg, “Use your inhaler”) rather than a passive voice (eg, “After you have used your inhaler”). Plain language also involves speaking in the second person, limiting jargon, and defining new words (eg, everyday talk vs. health care talk). When using plain language, most sentences should have 15 words or less, limiting the information provided at one time. A list of tools for developing plain language materials can be found in Table 3 and includes a clear communication index for help translating medical terms as well as Web sites for evaluating the readability of written materials. Finally, the Plain Language Planner for Palliative Care (PLP) is a recommended resource for practicing plain language. The PLP is a tool for communicating about medications and symptoms in plain language at the 6 th grade level. The PLP translates common medications and symptoms in palliative care and oncology treatment and side effects and includes English and Spanish translations. The PLP is part of the Health Communication iPhone smartphone app and is available for free download in the iTunes store.
Tools for Developing Plain Language Materials
∘ Health Literacy Measurement Tools (revised) |
∘ Check the Readability Level of writing |
∘ Health Literacy Toolkit for Providers |
∘ Training by CDC for Practicing and Teaching Health Literacy |
∘ CDC Clear Communication Index |
∘ CDC Developing Materials Using Plain Language |
Mindful communication in palliative care includes reducing self-talk, avoiding judgment about patient and family or how an interaction will proceed, and the ability to adapt to changes in the interaction. A nurse can be in the moment with patient and family by avoiding pre-determined scripts and engaging in mindful self-monitoring of the inner experience. 36 The inner experience of nursing also involves being mindful of the toll of care, which can erode mindful communication practices overtime. Nurses often begin careers with motivation to practice effective communication with patients and families, yet may experience compassion fatigue from too little sleep and not enough time to meet demanding clinical tasks. 37 As a result, disconnection is communicated through interactions with patients and families. Repetition of ineffective communication experiences, such as the non-patient–centered delivery of bad news, can lead to diminished mindful communication.
There are specific communication stressors for nurses working in palliative care that can impact the ability to be mindful. For example, patients and families expect availability, access, competency, empathy, and patience from nurses. There are also specific factors that can affect the patient/family–nurse relationship. These factors include attachment, similarities, emotional balance, nurse mortality, and challenging spiritual beliefs. 15 All of these factors may contribute to burnout, which can lead to severe negative consequences, such as early retirement, unprofessional behavior, and an increased risk of medical errors. Consider the following example of Sylvia:
After a decade of working as an oncology provider, Sylvia joined the palliative care team about 6 months ago. She is passionate about her work and is a strong team member. As usual, the team’s case load remains high and the past month has included high-intensity s, consisting of two to three family meetings, often involving lawyers, caring for a patient who was an oncology provider that worked with Sylvia, and a newly diagnosed Alzheimer’s patient who keeps referring to Sylvia as her daughter. Sylvia has been short-tempered and is neglecting her personal appearance. She has constant fatigue, feels overworked, and is questioning whether or not palliative care is the right clinical setting for her. She feels like her efforts go unnoticed by her colleagues. She is just ‘going through the motions’ at work, trying to find enthusiasm to return to work each day. She has witnessed so much suffering over the last 6 months and feels like she is ‘failing’ as a health care provider.
Sylvia may be experiencing burnout. Burnout can be described as an adverse psychological state characterized by emotional exhaustion, depersonalization, cynicism, and a low perception of personal accomplishment. 38 , 39 Predictors of burnout among health care providers who work in palliative care include: working over 50 hours per week, working on weekends, less experience, isolation from peers, lack of confidence in regards to communication skills, time constraints that hamper successful communication, communicating bad news, addressing pain/suffering/death, working in smaller organizations, being under 50 years old, tensions between non-specialists and palliative care specialists, and regulatory issues. 38 – 40 Burnout also has detrimental effects on personal physical and emotional health, as well as relationships. 39 It has been suggested that increased burnout among oncology providers is associated with feelings of not being trained properly in cancer communication skills and having a desire to change communication with patients. 40 , 41 Table 4 summarizes indicators of stress at work that signify diminished ability to be mindful, which can result in poor quality of care, reduced patient trust and satisfaction, malpractice lawsuits, poor decision making, lower productivity, and emotional detachment from patients. 41 – 46
Indicators of Stress at Work
∘ Withdrawing from patients/colleagues |
∘ Ignoring or delaying patient/family requests |
∘ Quick emotional responses to others |
∘ Overreactions to colleagues |
∘ Calling in sick to avoid feelings |
∘ Keeping busy with work, ignoring emotions |
To prevent burnout, it is crucial for oncology nurses to create opportunities for self-care. For example, nurses should create ways to share difficult patient-family situations with colleagues. This can be done by seeking advice, confirming action, and sharing emotions. An activity that can be extremely helpful is journaling, which can aid in reflection. Journaling allows for the processing of emotions and feelings about events, and can aid in making meaning of situations. 47 Nurses can journal with other team members after the loss of a patient and share their writing with each other. They may also write a letter to a patient/family or to a colleague. 15 Self-care is critical for nurses because neglecting self-care may not only have detrimental personal effects, but may also be detrimental for their patients/families and colleagues.
Relating involves being aware of the patient’s/family member’s understanding of the disease and its probable course and being willing to meet patients and families where they are in accepting the change brought by serious illness. In relating to patient and family, nurses should recognize that medical information such as prognosis and treatment option may need to be repeated numerous times to help patient and family reach awareness and understanding. Relating to the patient and family involves being aware of the multiple goals that can exist when talking about uncertainty and learning what hope means to the patient.
Multiple goals exist because task and relational communication impact how our words are received and interpreted. Simply, task communication imparts the content of the message, whereas relational communication includes the nonverbal components of the interaction. This communication approach is predicated upon the axiom that every message (verbal or nonverbal) conveys both content (verbal message) and relationship (nonverbal communication). 48 Multiple goals can exist through the direct (verbal) and indirect (nonverbal) actions of words. For example, the way a patient or family members says “I’m worried” can reveal multiple concerns depending upon how it is said alongside nonverbal cues. Nonverbal communication can convey why they are worried, what they are worried about, how relationships influence worry, and whether or not they feel comfortable expressing worry to provider. It is essential for oncology nurses to learn how multiple goals are present for patient and family.
Relating to patient/family involves building trust and establishing a relationship. Trust depends on the interpersonal and technical competence of the health care provider 49 and is gained by patient’s perceived emotional support, ability to share personal feelings, whether or not multiple discussions have taken place, and collaboration with family. 50 It is established over time, not just in one visit, 49 and includes understanding patient/family preferences, values, and priorities. Encouraging patients to ask questions and actively participate in their care is one way to elicit preferences. 51 Question prompt list is a communication tool that can facilitate difficult discussions and stimulate questions so that the clinician can understand the patient’s most important concerns. 51 – 54 A coaching intervention using the question prompt list in breast cancer survivors prompted questions regarding symptoms and recurrence and resulted in improved breast cancer self-efficacy. 53 An intervention with gynecologic cancer survivors included reflection and symptom sheets to facilitate communication during the nurse telephone coaching sessions. 54 Sessions focused on assessing challenges, symptom education, and problem-solving strategies. The intervention group scored higher on quality-of-life and physical well-being subscales compared with the usual care group. 54
Relating to patient/family also involves exploring feelings of uncertainty that cause worry. Nurses can help patients manage uncertainty by framing information in terms of what is known and unknown and acknowledging that some uncertainty in unavoidable. 37 The ability to speak to nurses between follow-up visits can provide reassurance regarding the meaning of symptoms and may decrease anxiety. 55 Peer support groups and lay navigators are resources that can provide emotional and tangible support. 56 Cancer survivors who express ongoing anxiety, uncertainty, and fear of recurrence may benefit from cognitive-behavioral and cognitive-existential therapies, mindfulness-based strategies, and coaching and communication interventions. 57 , 58
Dean and Street 59 describe a three-stage model for clinicians to help patients navigate emotional distress and difficult feelings: a) recognition; b) exploration; and c) therapeutic action. Recognizing distress requires cognitive and communication strategies. Rapport building, listening, asking about patient concerns, and avoiding interruptions are strategies to help nurses recognize emotional concerns. 59 In the exploration phase, nurses can validate and normalize emotions using open-ended questions and empathic phrases. Even if the nurse is uncertain how to respond, listening and demonstrating caring behaviors can be therapeutic. In the therapeutic action phase, nurses can provide clear information about symptoms and follow-up care, and referrals to assist survivors in managing uncertainty. 59 Brief screening tools to assess distress and symptoms should be integrated with electronic medical records. For example, PROMIS instruments can be used to assess anxiety, depression, and quality of life and can help to identify psychosocial concerns. 57 , 58 Consider the following case:
Mrs Rogers recently completed treatment for stage III ovarian cancer and returns for her initial follow-up visit. Nurse Carol J. sits next to Mrs Rogers and asks if she has any questions or concerns she’d like to discuss during the visit. Mrs Rogers responds “I’m really not sure about what symptoms I should report or be concerned about. I’m also feeling anxious waiting for my CA-125 test result.” The nurse mentions that the transition to follow-up care can be stressful for many women and asked Mrs Rogers to tell her more about her concerns. Looking at the floor, Mrs Rogers explains: “I can’t stop thinking about the possibility that my cancer may come back. My husband gets upset if I try to talk with him about it.” The nurse responds “It must be difficult for you and your husband to deal with everything you have gone through in the past several months. Tell me about how he has helped you during your care and treatment. Do you think he is worried about the cancer returning?” The nurse quietly listens as Mrs Rogers shares about her relationship with her husband. The nurse provides education about common physical and emotional symptoms that survivors experience, suggesting that Mrs Rogers share these with her husband. The nurse reassures her that she will be available by phone if questions arise. She also mentions some support services that other women have found helpful and asks Mrs Rogers her thoughts on these options. The nurse ggests that she invite her husband to participate in the discussion with the oncologist arding surveillance and follow-up care.
In this case study, the nurse uses communication strategies based on principles from the Dean and Street 59 and COMFORT models. She asks about and actively listens to Mrs Rogers’ concerns (Recognition). The nurse uses an open-ended clarifying question and acknowledges how difficult this must be. The nurse discusses options and seeks the patient’s preference for possible support services (Exploration). The nurse provides education regarding symptoms to reduce uncertainty; reassurance that she will be available; and identifies possible resources (Therapeutic action). Using the COMFORT principle of R-relating, the nurse encourages Mrs Rogers to discuss her concerns to further explore her feelings. She recognizes that Mrs Rogers’ worry about her cancer returning is connected to a lack of communication about cancer with her husband. Moreover, Mrs Rogers is looking at the ground when she makes this statement (nonverbal cue), revealing that this is also a difficult topic for her to discuss with the nurse. To further explore how Mrs Roger’s relationship with her husband influences her anxiety, she asks Mrs Rogers to recall how her husband has participated in her care and to imagine how he must be feeling. Addressing the partners’ uncertainty and concerns will promote well-being because the partner’s and survivor’s adjustment are interdependent. 60 Fostering healing relationships is a key communication task to help facilitate trust and relate to patient and family. Finally, the nurse builds trust by emphasizing that she is available by phone if questions arise.
A major component of palliative care is whole-patient assessment that includes the impact of the patient’s illness on quality of life. Quality communication skills are essential to cancer nursing, enabling nurses to learn the patient’s story, address patient and family health literacy needs, discuss patient uncertainty and emotional distress, and be mindful of the need for self-care. Engaging in difficult or sensitive conversations requires trust, compassion, and self-awareness. 37 Palliative care communication training for oncology nurses is needed, especially given their vital role in cancer care. The COMFORT Communication model offers a nursing curriculum for teaching palliative care communication.
Research reported in this publication was partially supported by the National Cancer Institute of the National Institutes of Health under award number R25CA174627. The content is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of the National Institutes of Health.
Publisher's Disclaimer: This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication. As a service to our customers we are providing this early version of the manuscript. The manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting, and review of the resulting proof before it is published in its final citable form. Please note that during the production process errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.
Elaine Wittenberg, Department of Communication Studies, California State University, Los Angeles, CA.
Anne Reb, City of Hope Comprehensive Cancer Center, Duarte, CA.
Elisa Kanter, Chapman University, Department of Communication, Orange, CA.
Family communication is important in fostering intimacy and accumulating resources. They also help in raising children as independent people capable of interacting with other human systems. The family communication rules are guidelines that govern what is to be expected of all communication in the family, what is allowed and what is prohibited under given circumstances.
The rules are closely knit into the family culture and are transferred to newer generations by the senior members of the family. The rules dictate the emotional interdependence among family members and therefore family members directly affect each other emotionally, as well in their thoughts, feelings and actions (Le Poire, 2005).
In my family, there is a non-written rule that young members of the family should not question the elder members. The rule further implied that the young should always execute orders or requests by the older members of the family without seeking to know why they have been specifically chosen to perform those tasks. This rule has been very significant in shaping the relationships among the members of my family.
They were formulated mainly in order to govern the child to parent and parent to child communication and prevent incidents of children talking back to their parents when it is not desirable. As long as the communication rules have been observed, children have always been quiet when they are in the sight of their parents unless spoken to.
The effects of this rule include; the relationship among brothers and sisters is not very mutual. The elder children dominate the communication with the younger children. The rules have also made it impossible for the young in the family to air their grievances to parents since it is expected that they feel aggrieved because of their own mistake of failing to listen or act as commanded by their elder brothers or sisters.
The rule has therefore been a major source of fearful respect to elders. Even among adult members of the family the rule has made dispute resolution in favour of the much older members unless the situation is very clear that they are on the wrong. The rule has elevated the oldest member of the family to be the position of head of family since because of their age, their decisions are unquestionable.
Apart from elders, the rule also places wives under their husbands in the age hierarchy. When it comes to family business, important decisions are taken by the head of the family with or without consultations with other members. As a result, success of the family majorly becomes dependent on the wisdom of the head of the family.
Positive impacts of the rule have been that the family relations has been tight and there has always been general agreements on the direction taken by the family as siblings have no reason to debate among themselves on who is right. The rule has also checked on family rivalry.
Another family rule is that bad or sensitive news cannot be told to children. This was informed by the need not to disrupt children’s upbringing by informing them about events that might be too big for them to handle emotionally.
The rule has created the effect of ignorance of basic meanings in life, and has become an obstacle for children who want to learn about their family history and traditions. For example, in my family children cannot be informed of death of a family member including their parents and instead they are given excuses to explain the disappearance.
While the rule serves to insulate children from emotional baggage, it also becomes a source of contention when children grow up and discover that important facts that could have shaped their lives had been hidden from them. A lot of disagreements and breakups have happened in my family because of the non-disclosure rule.
To sum up, communication serves as vehicle that family members use to develop and maintain intimate relations (Vangelisti, 2004). Rules that govern this communication in the family are responsible for how well the communication serves to hold the family together and lead it to prosperity. The rules also significantly affect individual’s view of each other among the family.
Le Poire, B. A. (2005). Family communication: nurturing and control in a changing world. Southern Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
Vangelisti, A. L. (2004). Handbook of family communication. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Inc Publishers.
IvyPanda. (2018, August 21). Two Communication Rules in My Family. https://ivypanda.com/essays/two-communication-rules-in-my-family/
"Two Communication Rules in My Family." IvyPanda , 21 Aug. 2018, ivypanda.com/essays/two-communication-rules-in-my-family/.
IvyPanda . (2018) 'Two Communication Rules in My Family'. 21 August.
IvyPanda . 2018. "Two Communication Rules in My Family." August 21, 2018. https://ivypanda.com/essays/two-communication-rules-in-my-family/.
1. IvyPanda . "Two Communication Rules in My Family." August 21, 2018. https://ivypanda.com/essays/two-communication-rules-in-my-family/.
Bibliography
IvyPanda . "Two Communication Rules in My Family." August 21, 2018. https://ivypanda.com/essays/two-communication-rules-in-my-family/.
Postdoctoral Research Fellow, Department of Psychology, University of Calgary
Professor, Canada Research Chair in Determinants of Child Development, Owerko Centre at the Alberta Children’s Hospital Research Institute, University of Calgary
Marissa Nivison receives funding from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada.
Sheri Madigan receives funding from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council, the Canadian Institutes of Health Research, the Alberta Children's Hospital Foundation, an anonymous donor, and the Canada Research Chairs program.
University of Calgary provides funding as a founding partner of The Conversation CA.
University of Calgary provides funding as a member of The Conversation CA-FR.
View all partners
Sibling relationships are some of the longest-lasting relationships we have in our lives . Half of Canadians and around 80 per cent of people worldwide have at least one sibling. Sibling relationships are unique from all other relationships because siblings often grow up together and share family history. Biological siblings even share genetics.
In childhood, children spend more time with their siblings than anyone else, including their parents . A longitudinal study found that the quality of sibling relationships in young adulthood was one of the strongest predictors of well-being at age 65 .
Sibling relationships change as we grow. In early adulthood, maintaining the sibling relationship becomes a matter of choice, although most sibling relationships last a lifetime . In childhood, parents have important roles to play setting the stage for life-long positive sibling relationships.
As developmental and clinical psychologists, we recognize the profound impact siblings can have on development, especially having personally experienced the benefits, and sometimes the frustrations, within our own sibling relationships.
Not only is the sibling relationship unique, but it also serves an important role in a child’s development. Children with siblings tend to develop better relationships with their peers, engage in more creative play and have higher empathy and a better understanding of others’ thoughts and feelings . They often develop social skills much earlier than children without siblings, which helps them form friendships when they start school .
Some studies have shown that positive sibling relationships also serve as a protective factor during difficult times, like high levels of life stress and marital conflict between parents .
It is not surprising that siblings can have a large impact on an individual’s development. For example, children may adjust their personalities to avoid conflict and competition with their sibling . Additionally, just knowing they have a sibling can positively affect a child .
When we are kids, sibling relationships can be full of rivalry. In adolescence, sibling relationships tend to drift as we explore new relationships with peers and our own identity.
It is probably no surprise that a major topic in research on sibling relationships is conflict. Sibling conflict is quite common and, to some extent, can actually be good for children’s development . The sibling relationship offers a unique context for children to resolve conflict because, unlike friendships, the sibling relationship cannot just end after a quarrel. Through navigating conflict with siblings, children can learn valuable skills such as understanding others’ perspectives, developing empathy, improving listening skills, setting boundaries and standing up for their own self interests.
However, there is a fine line between small disagreements and conflict being the main feature of the sibling relationship. It is normal for siblings to feel rivalry and competition, but when this becomes the defining feature of the relationship, it can create a negative environment. Specifically, children can become jealous and start to resent their sibling when they feel the need to compete for their parents’ attention and approval .
Although most parents say they don’t play favourites among siblings, up to 85 per cent of children believe their parents had a favourite.
One of the biggest predictors of sibling conflict is differential treatment by parents — including perceived differences in parenting. This means that even if a parent believes they are treating all children equally, a child often feels they are being treated differently .
For example, if both children are running through the house on separate occasions and one child receives a time out while the other is not allowed to go to a friend’s birthday party, the second child may perceive this as unfair, and naturally it creates tension in the sibling relationship. Parents should strive to be as fair as possible in their parenting by ensuring consistent consequences for similar misbehaviours among siblings.
Another key factor is for parents to recognize the individual strengths of each child and avoid unhealthy competition between siblings. For example, if one child does well in math, and the other does well in science, recognize their individual abilities and accomplishments and avoid comparing one sibling’s strength with the other’s weakness.
There are science-backed ways parents can promote positive sibling relationships.
Encourage positive engagement : Choose activities and interests that all siblings can enjoy together.
Identify what’s going well: Recognize when siblings support, co-operate and help each other.
Engage in shared experiences : Highlight each sibling’s unique strengths during activities that require teamwork.
Regulate emotions : Help children identify and process their emotions during difficult times.
Facilitate social and emotional understanding : Teach children about how to share their own feelings and understand and respect feelings of siblings.
Manage undesirable behaviours : Address negative behaviours like bossiness towards siblings.
Help children learn to consider the actions of their siblings, without assuming these actions are directed at them : It is important for children to understand that accidents happen and their siblings often do not have malicious intent toward them. For example, a parent might see a sibling accidentally knock over the toy tower.
Manage conflict : Parents can mediate conflict between children to help resolve situations fairly.
Examine parental differential treatment : Talk with children about instances when they feel they are being treated unfairly. Ask them to explain why they think something is “not fair” and discuss it together.
By implementing these strategies, parents can help build strong, positive and supporting relationships between siblings, which can support their well-being throughout their lifetimes.
Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this site’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to Writing9 with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.
IELTS says that you should write a minimum of 250 words in writing task 2. If you go under word count you will lose marks in task response.
A very long essay will not give you a higher band score.
Aim for between 260 to 290 words in writing task 2. This will ensure a concise essay and will be realistic in terms of time management. You have only 40 minutes to write the essay and you need around 10 minutes of planning time, so you will not be able to write a long essay in 30 minutes.
Discover more tips in The Ultimate Guide to Get a Target Band Score of 7+ » — a book that's free for 🚀 Premium users.
Some people think that advertisements aimed at children should be banned. to what extent do you agree or disagree, prevention is better than cure. out of a country’s health budget, a large proportion should be diverted from treatment to spending on health education and preventive measure. to what extent do you agree or disagree, your neighbours have recently written to you to complain about the noise from your house flat. write a letter to your neighbour's. in your letter explain the reasons for the noise apologies describe what action you will take write at least 150 words., children at secondary school are often taken on visits to museums,zoos and concerts and sometimes even to other countries.what do you think the advantages and disadvantages of such visits are.
IMAGES
VIDEO
COMMENTS
According to Graham, "In order for effective communication to take place within families, individual family members must be open and honest with on another" (1996, p. 24). Trust creates strong relationships among family members. Family Communication: Essay on My Family's Survival: As narrated by my mother
Communication between my family and me is based on the following special and unique principles. Our relationship is based on mutual interaction and cooperation, verbal and nonverbal methods of transmitting information, and dynamic interaction (Pace). Primarily, the connections between members of my family and me are directly conditioned by ...
Summary. Through the years, the concept of family has been studied by family therapists, psychology scholars, and sociologists with a diverse theoretical framework, such as family communication patterns (FCP) theory, dyadic power theory, conflict, and family systems theory. Among these theories, there are two main commonalities throughout its ...
Family relationships offer a unique source of emotional support. Within the familial circle, individuals find comfort, understanding, and empathy. Family members provide a safe haven where vulnerabilities can be shared without judgment. This support creates a sense of security and belonging that nurtures emotional well-being and encourages open ...
Nurturing family members entails providing basic care and support, both emotional and financial. Socializing family members refers to teaching young children how to speak, read, and practice social skills. Transactional definitions of family focus on communication and subjective feelings of connection.
This introductory essay attempts to accomplish the following: (1) discuss the importance of talk regarding death; (2) highlight the formative role of family interactions on the death and dying process; and (3) outline the articles in this special issue. Scholars contributing to this special issue on "Family Communication at the End of Life ...
Summary. Families shape individuals throughout their lives, and family communication is the foundation of family life and functioning. It is through communication that families are defined and members learn how to organize meanings. When individuals come together to form family relationships, they create a system that is larger and more complex ...
Pathways Linking Family Relationships to Well-Being. A life course perspective draws attention to the importance of linked lives, or interdependence within relationships, across the life course (Elder, Johnson, & Crosnoe, 2003).Family members are linked in important ways through each stage of life, and these relationships are an important source of social connection and social influence for ...
Be available: Make time in everyone's busy schedule to stop and talk about things. Even 10 minutes a day without distractions for you and your child to talk can make a big difference in forming good communication habits. Turn off the television or radio. Give your undivided attention to your child. Sit down and look at your child while you talk.
Abstract. Each stage of the human life course is characterised by a distinctive pattern of social relations. We study how the intensity and importance of the closest social contacts vary across the life course, using a large database of mobile communication from a European country. We first determine the most likely social relationship type ...
Family Relationship, Childhood Delinquency, Criminality. In regard to the relationship between the effect of various factors involved in a child's upbringing and the likelihood of becoming a criminal during adulthood, varied findings were made. Modality of Family Faith and Meanings and Relationships in Family Life.
Family communication patterns. Koerner and Fitzpatrick (Citation 2006) family communication patterns theory (FCP) suggests family communication schemata are defined by conversation and conformity orientations; as such, FCP provides a useful framework for understanding whether individuals disclose health information.Conversation orientation refers to how freely family members express ideas ...
Communication is found to be the most important factor for cohesion in families and sustainability of family wealth. Statistics show that more than 70% of families are unsuccessful at multi-generational wealth transfer and further, that 65% of the time this failure is attributed to lack of communication and trust within the family.*. The ...
You communicate with members of the family not just with your words but using language and behavior. If you use negative methods to communicate or avoid communicating at all, this can make matters worse through adulthood and even affect who we become as adults. Poor family communication can include yelling, holding grudges, keeping secrets ...
His research suggests that problems communicating with our loved ones and friends come from several different factors. First, most people seriously overestimate their ability to communicate effectively. Keysar's studies suggest that nearly 50% of the time when we think we are understood, we are actually wrong.
Communication is the basic building block of our relationships. It is through communication that we convey our thoughts, feelings, and connection to one another. Developing good communication skills is critical for successful relationships, whether parent, child, spouse, or sibling relationship. We all have had experiences where (1) we have ...
The objective of this study is to examine interpersonal communication and spoken skills. This work will examine communication skills using the theories of Pragmatic Perspective, Psychological Perspective, Social Constructionist, and social responsibility theory. Trenholm (2008) states that communication "is very important to everyone.
Based on the facts I furnished above, I strongly believe the communication gap between the family members is increased compared to the past decade. Submitted by tahsin291287 on Mon Apr 05 2021. ... A great argument essay structure may be divided to four paragraphs, in which comprises of four sentences (excluding the conclusion paragraph, which ...
Communication between nurse, patient, and family members involves more than just providing information. It includes discussing a range of topics, encouraging the sharing of feelings and fears about the illness, treatment, and prognosis, and helping patients and family members find a sense of control and a search for meaning and life purpose. 1 Nurses with strong communication skills have been ...
Get a custom essay on Two Communication Rules in My Family. The rules are closely knit into the family culture and are transferred to newer generations by the senior members of the family. The rules dictate the emotional interdependence among family members and therefore family members directly affect each other emotionally, as well in their ...
In this modern contemporary era, where technology has played a crucial role in the development of methods where people can easily communicate, commute and get the information at their door-steps. It is observed that the interaction among family members has been drastically reduced compared to the olden days | Band: 8
time. with their family which,accounts for less communication between family. For instance. ,the survey conducted at a university showed that because of less. time. spent between the families they less interaction between family members. In conclusion,due to the introduction of electronic gadgets and the modern ,era people become less ...
Strong, positive and supporting relationships between siblings can support people's well-being throughout their lifetimes, and parenting approaches matter.
A very long essay will not give you a higher band score. Aim for between 260 to 290 words in writing task 2. This will ensure a concise essay and will be realistic in terms of time management. You have only 40 minutes to write the essay and you need around 10 minutes of planning time, so you will not be able to write a long essay in 30 minutes.
PNSB Palau Fellowship Award Recipients Discuss Studying abroad and internships | August 7, 2024 | EPFM Studio